Please don't pump us up, we have a lot of work to do as this year is a very tough division!
-
LIVE: Collingwood v Carlton - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Pies at 71% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
LIVE: Collingwood v Carlton - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Pies at 71% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
SFNL Div 1 2025
- Thread starter Bunk Moreland
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Please don't pump us up, we have a lot of work to do as this year is a very tough division!
St Pauls are equal favs with Chelt and Dingley and based on the players they have picked up, there is no reason to think they won't be playing deep into the finals, the rest is up to them.
If he plays enough games, Matty O'Brien will finish top 3 in the league b and f at minimum.
As for paying players, the whole system is a sham.
If he plays enough games, Matty O'Brien will finish top 3 in the league b and f at minimum.
As for paying players, the whole system is a sham.
FootballGuy95
Team Captain
- Apr 3, 2022
- 387
- 260
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Equal favs what are you smoking?
Look at the results last year.
St Pauls drew with Chelt late in the season, beat Dingley in the last game, lost to Dingley in a Prelim final by 2 goals, Dingley just lost to Chelt in the gf.
The second half of last year was very even between the three of them.
We are yet to know the impact from bringing in the two bulls from Benalla and if Matty O can push St Pauls even higher.
Senior games were different times. Was possible to catch glimpses of both like I did and a few opposition onlookers did.
I’m not so certain the whole system is a sham. Dollars have been around for years and some, just like everything else the dollar is greater in recent times than the past but that’s the world we live in. Inflation.
But what will be evident is who steps up and who doesn’t make the grade, there will be no where to hide for any club or individual in a season that on the surface looks as tight as it ever has in recent memory
Tightly contested comp this season. Be interesting to see if Port Colts and East Brighton can bridge the gap to the top 5, both high turnover high profile recruits , spend big. We will know where most sit by about round 5-6 , who has spent wisely and who has not.
The standard of the coaching has really increased with the standard of the play too. Looking forward to rolling around the grounds again and watching and comparing competitions again
For what it’s worth and speaking to some current division 1 coaches on how their lists are travelling and watching a fair few Praccys heres a stab at the end of season ladder in order
Dingley
Springvale Districts
Narre Warren
Cheltenham
St.Pauls
Cranbourne
East Brighton
Port Colts
Murrumbeena
Bentleigh
A fair report , i think Beena had 1 or 2 out and will use 19s as well . No excuses ,but probably the1 ruck and 5 or 6 that go through the guts
Beena are ok
This is a great post. I had thought very much the same watching both
Bedford - where do you see Ormond fitting in division wise if they ever did make the jump across to SFNL? Watching Beaumaris last year who were ‘B’ I thought they be bottom 2/3 Divi 1 at the time
Really hard to tell , Beaumaris were a basket case last year and lost so many players , probably due to the coach who's been retained . Ormond has a very young promising list , at the moment i would say Div2 with improvement to come . No doubt the parody account will have it's view
- Mar 12, 2016
- 3,991
- 3,293
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
I know your a Ormond man thru and thru but I like to see 1 day Ormond and maybe Glen Eira in the Southern but that will be up to those clubs to decide.
I have said it for years , the only future in the VAFA is for school and Uni clubs , Old Xavs will have 5 thirds sides , that's crap
Also many suburban clubs in the VAFA on the outer fringes are leaving , no one can compete
The VAFA give stand-alone non-school related clubs just enough to make them continue to fight but not enough to make them really competitive. Look what has happened up in the Northern League. Most of the VAFA teams have walked away and are now playing in the Northern FNL League because they can't complete with the big schools in the VAFA and are more like their northern FNL league counterparts who may improve by offering a few players some small salary incentives to play. If you are Prem C or Div 1 in VAFA, there is very little that you can offer someone to go to your club except for comradeship. And you hope that is the reason your u19s stay although if they are any good, they will go and look for coin somewhere. Hence teams like Old Paradians have left the VAFA and now play in the Northern League where they can pay players above the table. The Fact is the VAFA don't want any team to disrupt their cozy elitist system which is run by the top private schools for the top private schools.
Wild Thing
All Australian
- Jan 27, 2022
- 669
- 546
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Surely with their outlay and recruits in the All Stars don’t finish 7th. I guess it’s everyone’s opinion but they would be hugely disappointed if that was the case…big step backwards!
I have All Stars 3rd or 4th. Depth might be their biggest issue
St Paul’s couldn’t fill a reserves side on Saturday for the praccy match. What’s that mean for depth Greg Tivendale ?
Sure doesn’t help with a handful of 19s going to Ormond
Sure doesn’t help with a handful of 19s going to Ormond
A few of the younger guys were playing cricket grand finals so they will come back for the first game of the season but yes, this is exactly what we are saying. The overall playing numbers around the Bentleigh catchment area are decreasing considerably and it will start biting at reserves teams being able to field sides.
St Pauls have to rely on their juniors and call up u17s to make up numbers in their reserves teams by mid-winter. Its not always fair on the u17 as they have to play 2 games on the weekend, one against bigger bodied people.
With fewer junior teams as well, that puts pressure on numbers.
All the under 19s went to Ormond that was driven by one oor two of their leaders leaving the your before.
Last edited:
- Nov 27, 2018
- 1,082
- 1,806
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Why do Beena have so many numbers then?
No St Pauls?
FootballGuy95
Team Captain
- Apr 3, 2022
- 387
- 260
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
[emoji[emoji6]
[emoji6
]]
Good culture from top to bottom seniors coaching juniors leading them into the under
[emoji[emoji6
][emoji6]]s program. Men’s and women’s football connection is really good
- Nov 27, 2018
- 1,082
- 1,806
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
And it’s a credit to them as a club. I find it interesting so many clubs complain about Vafa this, APS that, oh there’s so many clubs in one area. My question to them is are you actually making a genuine effort to create a pathway for these kids to come through your club?
I can only really speak for East Brighton but if we can create a genuine pathway for our 900+ juniors to come through into our senior program then look out. Relationship with the junior club is the best it’s been.
Also think SFNL standard is rising across the board. If the 19’s and women’s comps keep growing and improve then the comp will be in an even better place.
I can only really speak for East Brighton but if we can create a genuine pathway for our 900+ juniors to come through into our senior program then look out. Relationship with the junior club is the best it’s been.
Also think SFNL standard is rising across the board. If the 19’s and women’s comps keep growing and improve then the comp will be in an even better place.
Strong group of 3's as well, younger group that know they aren't in the best 36 but still love the club and enjoy a kick. Excellent for culture to have people like that around
SaintsMagee
Senior List
- Nov 15, 2019
- 225
- 165
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
With the culture as well, the amount of players who stick around after their games (19s, 3s, womans) to watch all games and get a big crowd going (more for home games) shows the love for the club. Big groups behind the goals as well as a full wing down at the arena
notalegent
Debutant
- Sep 12, 2019
- 118
- 48
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Looks like most of their u19's (DOGGIES) have gone to Hampton Hammers. Looking at transfers about 20 plus, not as many to Ormond.
I thought there was a rule about sides moving from club to club. Could be wrong maybe it's the Ammos that have that rule.
Also, a major worry about their seconds, that's what hurt them last year running into finals. "NO DEPTH'
