Recommitted Tom Papley [wanted to return to Victoria, nominated Carlton - didn't get there]

[Bollox]

You absolutely 100% sure we cant somehow have Weitering ?
Might be a nice friendly gesture.
Got to at least ask

 

[PrinceCharles]

Papley will get to Carlton regardless of what happens to Joe imo

Exactly.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I think he'll re-sign in 12 months

Not fussed either way. Our midfield needs work not our forward line anyway

 

[jooce8891]

Blue and Swans have a good trading relationship.
SOS and Beatson are probably having conversations about what a nuffy Dodoro is, to kill time.

newman, everitt all went down smoothly iirc plus we got agresta who is sydneys ex recruiter

 

[zeggie]

I think he'll resign in 12 months

FTFY

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

awesome, we’ll give you pick 5 and 25 for Patrick Cripps

that’s a tidy little profit on the pick 13 he cost you in the draft

“That’s a decent offer ... now triple it!!”

 

[zeggie]

I think he'll re-sign in 12 months

Here's a fun statistic whilst we wait for trades to happen.

52% of your posts in the Papley thread are about Joe. lol.

 

[Brezsa]

I thought this was the Papley thread. Seems to be a lot of Joe Daniher posts

 

[Andy_Mac]

Hypothetical of course, and I don’t think it’ll happen but if Carlton can’t get a deal done and going of Montagna’s tweet about the Dees should get involved, what about:


P3&8 for Papley, P5 and P25. On points it values Papley as P15.

 

[Jibroni]

Would not be surprised if the Dees came in with a last minute offer involving Pick 8 and maybe some pick swaps.

Papley is the exact player we need ATM.

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

Hypothetical of course, and I don’t think it’ll happen but if Carlton can’t get a deal done and going of Montagna’s tweet about the Dees should get involved, what about:


P3&8 for Papley, P5 and P25. On points it values Papley as P15.

If carlton can't get it done with pick 9 why does the equivalent of pick 15 suddenly get it done...?

 

[Andy_Mac]

If carlton can't get it done with pick 9 why does the equivalent of pick 15 suddenly get it done...?

I’d assumed because the deal was Papley plus change.

He’s not worth P9 straight up... good luck with that...

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

I’d assumed because the deal was Papley plus change.

He’s not worth P9 straight up... good luck with that...

P9 with stuff coming back, whatever, semantics. The difference isn't going to be enough so that the equivalent of 15 suddenly gets it done lol.

 

[bmaurizio]

You absolutely 100% sure we cant somehow have Weitering ?
Might be a nice friendly gesture.
Got to at least ask

One would need a lot more currency than Papely to expect Weitering in return.

 

[WWSD]

Sydney get: Hawks pick 11 + pick 30 + Isaac Smith

Hawks get: Papley + future 3rd + 4th round pick

 

[Andy_Mac]

P9 with stuff coming back, whatever, semantics. The difference isn't going to be enough so that the equivalent of 15 suddenly gets it done lol.

Again it all points so it’s hardly relevant unless you need them, but what I proposed is better for Sydney than P9 with there 3rd rounder coming back to Carlton.

Notwithstanding it’s hypothetical, Dees are splitting P3 with the Giants.

 

[Login]

Again it all points so it’s hardly relevant unless you need them, but what I proposed is better for Sydney than P9 with there 3rd rounder coming back to Carlton.

Notwithstanding it’s hypothetical, Dees are splitting P3 with the Giants.

He would be a great fit for the Dees, they would be crazy not to try and pinch from under Carlton.
I don’t think he would mind going there either, I reckon he’s just desperate to get back to Victoria.

 

[Bay Pie]

SOSauge has said deal is 50/50. At least carlton should get Pittonet and save those early picks for youngsters.

 

[jooce8891]

SOSauge has said deal is 50/50. At least carlton should get Pittonet and save those early picks for youngsters.

come on, you dont reckon all this "its 50/50" and "we're a long way from completing a deal" isnt just to build it up for the final few hours for TV?

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Swans want pick 9 just do the trade if Swans miss out on Daniher then that's their problem

 

[Snarls Barkley]

Would be pretty surprised if this didn’t go through. Carlton seem pretty willing to give up pick 9 which should be enough to get it done.

Sydney always seem to do their trades pretty fairly and without much fuss. I’m guessing the only reason it hasn’t been done already is that Sydney have had their hands full with the Daniher deal.

 

[Elmer_Hauser]

Would be pretty surprised if this didn’t go through. Carlton seem pretty willing to give up pick 9 which should be enough to get it done.

Sydney always seem to do their trades pretty fairly and without much fuss. I’m guessing the only reason it hasn’t been done already is that Sydney have had their hands full with the Daniher deal.

It's been held up because the AFL have instructed both clubs to delay it until their TV coverage starts on FoxHell (similar to the Daniher deal which will happen)

 

[Tbone McGraw]

No chance without Daniher to Sydney

 

[tipstar]

Would Swans take 9, CFC 2020 Future 1st, 43 & 54 for Papley, 5 and 25, be interesting, take 5 off the table for Essendon.

Our future 1st could be the carrot pending your/their opinion on where Carlton finish next year...

 

[Croweaters_1991]

Would Swans take 9, CFC 2020 Future 1st, 43 & 54 for Papley, 5 and 25, be interesting, take 5 off the table for Essendon.

Our future 1st could be the carrot pending your/their opinion on where Carlton finish next year...

Why would the swans downgrade their first round pick, massively downgrade their second pick AND give up papley for a future first and a pick in the 50s?