Werewolf Town of Salem Werewolf IV (Coven Wins)

[BEaston]

This was discussed earlier. Possible responses aren't set in stone and can be customised. There is nothing that states they have to use the possible roles.

It says possible messages and then gives an exhaustive list.

If it said example messages, I'd tend to agree but I think possible means it could go both ways.

 

[Hatchy1992]

BarryBran please serial_thrilla. I'm happy to trust CF.

 

[Nunez]

It says possible messages and then gives an exhaustive list.

If it said example messages, I'd tend to agree but I think possible means it could go both ways.

I guarantee it was done as an example. Either that or Serial sent me a PM with a custom message on the fly which I sincerely doubt he did.

 

[Nunez]

Barry

serial_thrilla

 

[BEaston]

I guarantee it was done as an example. Either that or Serial sent me a PM with a custom message on the fly which I sincerely doubt he did.

or you're lying.

 

[CursingFijian]

Pretty much everything you just said was wrong (well...line one was ok at least).

Baz would be the one visited by a hex master or a framer to throw off your result.

Coven has only one possible killing role night one (the potion master), and they have 3 options only one of which is a kill. Baz could easily have been seered, with porps visited by the Coven Leader and Nunes hexed. Or Nunez could have been seered and Baz hexed.

I'm not saying this is what happened, but your logic is bad and you should feel bad

Interesting.

I'm catholic so I always feel bad.

 

[ZergMinion]

hotchilli is the play today I think serial_thrilla

Then a vigilante can shoot baz tonight because he's full of it.

 

[Nunez]

or you're lying.

Let's entertain that. Say I'm lying - what neutral role am I to go balls deep on the doctor on day 1 and why?

Take off the tunnel vision and give me your logic.

 

[Nunez]

hotchilli is the play today I think serial_thrilla

Then a vigilante can shoot baz tonight because he's full of it.

I like it.

Hot chilli serial_thrilla

 

[hotchilli]

I like it.

Hot chilli serial_thrilla

You are making the same mistake.

 

[Nunez]

You are making the same mistake.

... Are you claiming what I think you're claiming...

 

[DERO]

 

[MP_]

hotchilli until i get my lunch break and can take a decent look serial_thrilla

 

[BEaston]

Let's entertain that. Say I'm lying - what neutral role am I to go balls deep on the doctor on day 1 and why?

Take off the tunnel vision and give me your logic.

If you are lying, I'd say you're almost certain to be a mafia role.

MCBG was visited by mafia n1, it's possible they have a Consigliere, you saw he was Doc and you decided to go ham on him as his role is important to remove as mafia.
Or the blackmail theory is decent. Blackmail him to ensure he can't reply back and get a train started.

Both of these options would require you to go really hard on fake claims, obfuscation and smoke screens to try survive a lynch which is exactly what you've done.

Also, just be clear I'm not saying you're definitely lying (as we have no confirmation on how the hypno messages work) but these are possibilities, even if they are less likely than your own story... you haven't covered yourself in glory with all the mistruths since.

 

[Nunez]

If you are lying, I'd say you're almost certain to be a mafia role.

MCBG was visited by mafia n1, it's possible they have a Consigliere, you saw he was Doc and you decided to go ham on him as his role is important to remove as mafia.
Or the blackmail theory is decent. Blackmail him to ensure he can't reply back and get a train started.

Both of these options would require you to go really hard on fake claims, obfuscation and smoke screens to try survive a lynch which is exactly what you've done.

Also, just be clear I'm not saying you're definitely lying (as we have no confirmation on how the hypno messages work) but these are possibilities, even if they are less likely than your own story... you haven't covered yourself in glory with all the mistruths since.

If I was the mafia, why would I visit myself night 2?

 

[hotchilli]

... Are you claiming what I think you're claiming...

I am certainly claiming to not be evil.

 

[BEaston]

If I was the mafia, why would I visit myself night 2?

Good point. That goes into another possible theory I have but don't think I want to share at this point.

 

[ZergMinion]

If I was the mafia, why would I visit myself night 2?

Spy was outed day 1 so probably to cover yourself I guess seeing as the mafia chose not to roleblock the spy that night?

 

[Nunez]

Good point. That goes into another possible theory I have but don't think I want to share at this point.

If you think like I think then I assume that theory is once the spy was revealed, mafia targeted themselves to distance themselves from the group.

Given I was told I was poisoned last night but didn't die, I can only assume The hypnotist was responsible both nights.

You'd have found the message I got regarding the poison funny though, they literally copy pasted it from the possible messages thing Serial did. If that ain't trolling I don't know what is lol.

 

[ZergMinion]

Spy was outed day 1 so probably to cover yourself I guess seeing as the mafia chose not to roleblock the spy that night?

Actually that's probably not it as most of the benign mafia roles can't target mafia members.

 

[Nunez]

Spy was outed day 1 so probably to cover yourself I guess seeing as the mafia chose not to roleblock the spy that night?

Why would mafia waste a role on themselves night 2 when they can just block or kill the spy?

 

[Nunez]

Actually that's probably not it as most of the benign mafia roles can't target mafia members.

That too haha

 

[Nunez]

I am certainly claiming to not be evil.

I thought you were claiming doc and nearly had PTSD

 

[thewizardmelon]

hotchilli is the play today I think serial_thrilla

Then a vigilante can shoot baz tonight because he's full of it.

Any particular reason why that direction and not the other?

 

[ZergMinion]

Why would mafia waste a role on themselves night 2 when they can just block or kill the spy?

Look...I can't make any sense of your day 1 actions, and I want to find a reason that you're evil, but I have yet to come up with a plausible scenario where you're evil (or neutral). It's bugging the hell out of me

I also can't come up with a plausible scenario where you're good, which is also bugging the hell out of me