Bluelegs
Digging into the why
I’m now confused as to what we have left. I think serial’s right, in that Beaston can’t have been executioner or jester as there’s no way for Beaston to have been directed into Medusa, even accounting for the Coven Leader manipulating Beaston on.
All of a sudden the merit of a third doctor is questionable, unless there’s some other way a neutral evil role could have ended up looking directly at Medusa?
Type | Role | Poster | Status |
Village Main | Jailor | MWPP? | Dead |
Village Main | Sheriff | Hatchy1992 | Dead |
Village Main | Doctor | Barrybran | Dead |
Village Main | Investigator | Dero? | Alive |
Village Main | Vigilante | Headless | Dead |
Village Investigative | Lookout | dogs105 | Dead |
Village Investigative | Tracker | 3KZ is Football | Dead |
Village Protective | Doctor | Jack the Godfather | Dead |
Village Protective | Bodyguard | Croweater 41 | Dead |
Village Killing | Vigilante | hotchilli | Dead |
Village Support | Mayor | Bluelegs | Alive |
Village Random | Psychic | boncer34 | Dead |
Village Random | Spy | MP_ | Dead |
Village Random | Escort | Pie 4 Life | Dead |
Village Random | Investigator | omgfridge | Dead |
Village Random | Veteran | Tarks | Alive |
Village Random | Bodyguard? | Natural Disaster? | Alive |
Village Random | ? | Beaston? | Dead? |
Mafia Main | Godfather | NinjaSwan | Dead |
Mafia Main | Mafioso/Godfather | Sante | Alive |
Mafia Random | Framer | Dingster | Dead |
Mafia Random | Consort | CursingFijian | Dead |
Mafia Random | Blackmailer | MC Bad Genius | Dead |
Coven Main | Coven Leader | Pickitt | Dead |
Coven Main | Medusa | ??? | Alive |
Coven Random | Hex Master | Smeg Head | Dead |
Coven Random | Potion Master | ??? | Alive |
Coven Random | Necromancer | jmoo_wan | Dead |
Neutral Killing | Arsonist | Ligma | Dead |
Neutral Killing | Serial Killer | Serial Thrilla | Dead |
Neutral Evil | Jester | Robertio | Dead |
Neutral Evil | Jester/Executioner | ??? | Alive? |
Neutral Benign | Survivor | eth-dog | Dead |
Here's what I've got. If Beaston had to visit Medusa and he can't have done that as the Jester/Exe.
That means he has to be the last remaining Villager unaccounted for. As Sante is the Mafioso/GF.
Which means one of GUH or ND are lying about their role. I'm much more inclined to believe ND as his role was revealed under no pressure and was done specifically to target NinjaSwan. I also haven't seen much evidence to support a doctor still being in the game.
Who of GUH, ND, Zerg and Greenery are we thinking are the last two Coven?
Jester/Exe is still out there. I'm thinking Greenery may be the Jester with his little 'Fine lynch me' rant earlier today after recieving two votes at the start of the day.