Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

[Westernheights]

Would anyone here conisder a trade for zorko? seeing as he is sitting out this week due to personal reasons

We need a bit of pace, he gets a fair bit of it and uses it quite well.

Hrovat and a second round?

 

[compact72]

Why do people keep suggesting Hrovat? He isn't going anywhere

 

[Dogsman16]

Would anyone here conisder a trade for zorko? seeing as he is sitting out this week due to personal reasons

We need a bit of pace, he gets a fair bit of it and uses it quite well.

Hrovat and a second round?

Turnover king! Can find the pill though and has pace but he turns the ball over far too often.

 

[ScragCity]

Why do people keep suggesting Hrovat? He isn't going anywhere

Would trade our first and more in a heartbeat. Gun.

 

[BRWB]

Why do people keep suggesting Hrovat? He isn't going anywhere

You seem very certain about Hrovat given he remains injured and is uncontracted at the end of the year. In the mix for delisting IMO.

 

[go you pups]

Good to see Stevens is still heavily underrated around here. Has been since he first pulled on a dogs jumper.

It was in a hypothetical if we landed Wood FFS

Would you want all of Crameri, Stevens, Jong, Stringer, Dunkley and Wood in the one team? IMO that is absolute overload on the medium rotation types, not to mention Bont can play that role also if needed.

Norf would laugh at us if we tried to give them Jong for Wood. Dunkley was only just drafted, and there's no chance we trade Crameri or Stringer. What Crameri is worth should be enough to land Wood for example but Crameri we rely on up forward.

Stevens is the odd man out here and has some currency.


If you want something good then you have to give something up, simples. I'm not advocating we trade Stevens, but via order of elimination if Wood wanted to come to us for example I'd look at it this way.


If a player of Nat Fyfes quality wanted to come to us for example and there was no way of a free agency type deal then I'd happily hand over Macrae (providing he wanted to go) and a first rounder for him

Would anyone here conisder a trade for zorko? seeing as he is sitting out this week due to personal reasons

We need a bit of pace, he gets a fair bit of it and uses it quite well.

Hrovat and a second round?

Rumours was his missus was expecting this week, don't buy into whatever it is


Hrovat and a second is absolutely laughable for him as he's elite, it's nearly as bad as whatever Essendon offered to us for Scott West all those years ago plus he is a born and bred Queenslander.

Would easily cost our first rounder + a solid player and well over 500k P.A, he is one of Brisbane's crown jewels imo

 

[immortalmike]

Would anyone here conisder a trade for zorko? seeing as he is sitting out this week due to personal reasons

We need a bit of pace, he gets a fair bit of it and uses it quite well.

Hrovat and a second round?

There's a lot to like about Zorko. Not the worst suggestion in this thread.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Our first is enough for Wood if it goes that way. Or this year's and next year's 2nd.

Edit: do we have a 2nd this year? What was the Carlton trade last year?

 

[Dogsman16]

Our first is enough for Wood if it goes that way. Or this year's and next year's 2nd.

Edit: do we have a 2nd this year? What was the Carlton trade last year?

Carlton have our third this year.

Currently we have a 1st, 2nd and two 4th rounders (one being Sydney).

We need to push hard to get the wood

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Carlton have our third this year.

Currently we have a 1st, 2nd and two 4th rounders (one being Sydney).

We need to push hard to get the wood

Yeah our first or 2xseconds would get it done IMO.

 

[ScragCity]

You seem very certain about Hrovat given he remains injured and is uncontracted at the end of the year. In the mix for delisting IMO.

He absolutely will not be delisted. Traded maybe but not delisted. He might be out of contract but he isnt an unrestricted free agent.

 

[Dogsman16]

Yeah our first or 2xseconds would get it done IMO.

North would want our first.

As it stands I'd be happy to give it up.

 

[ScragCity]

It was in a hypothetical if we landed Wood FFS

Would you want all of Crameri, Stevens, Jong, Stringer, Dunkley and Wood in the one team? IMO that is absolute overload on the medium rotation types, not to mention Bont can play that role also if needed.

Norf would laugh at us if we tried to give them Jong for Wood. Dunkley was only just drafted, and there's no chance we trade Crameri or Stringer. What Crameri is worth should be enough to land Wood for example but Crameri we rely on up forward.

Stevens is the odd man out here and has some currency.


If you want something good then you have to give something up, simples. I'm not advocating we trade Stevens, but via order of elimination if Wood wanted to come to us for example I'd look at it this way.


If a player of Nat Fyfes quality wanted to come to us for example and there was no way of a free agency type deal then I'd happily hand over Macrae (providing he wanted to go) and a first rounder for him


Rumours was his missus was expecting this week, don't buy into whatever it is


Hrovat and a second is absolutely laughable for him as he's elite, it's nearly as bad as whatever Essendon offered to us for Scott West all those years ago plus he is a born and bred Queenslander.

Would easily cost our first rounder + a solid player and well over 500k P.A, he is one of Brisbane's crown jewels imo

I love Stevens but he has a lot of trouble staying on the park. Would happily package him up on a trade for a needs based player.

 

[Roscoe_au]

I love Stevens but he has a lot of trouble staying on the park. Would happily package him up on a trade for a needs based player.

Bleeds red, white and blue. Hate seeing a heart and soul player depart, but I get your point.

As much as it hurt seeing Crossy wearing a Demons jersey, loved the fact he wasn't lost to the game.

 

[ScragCity]

Bleeds red, white and blue. Hate seeing a heart and soul player depart, but I get your point.

As much as it hurt seeing Crossy wearing a Demons jersey, loved the fact he wasn't lost to the game.

He came from the Eagles, he is used to being shopped around

 

[CaptainMurphy]

If we get Mason Wood and put him at CHF with Easton at CHB we will have a partially wooden spine.

 

[immortalmike]

If we get Mason Wood and put him at CHF with Easton at CHB we will have a partially wooden spine.

Wood you guys stop!?

 

[TedDougChris]

Wood you guys stop!?

Woodnt you know it, a critic....

 

[Pannalstaroz]

North would want our first.

As it stands I'd be happy to give it up.

My views on him are well documented

 

[Pannalstaroz]

I think talk of Stevens being traded is off the mark.

 

[fronkalicious]

2 quick ones:

1. I really really really really hope talk of us being into Zac Clarke is off the mark. He is shit.

2. I've never understood the line of thinking that Grundy is average. I'm a massive fan.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

2 quick ones:

1. I really really really really hope talk of us being into Zac Clarke is off the mark. He is shit.

2. I've never understood the line of thinking that Grundy is average. I'm a massive fan.

I said it about Zac Smith - any ruckman who shows something as a kid inevitably makes it at the level. Grundy fits.

 

[Dogs Rule]

Woodnt you know it, a critic....

We can get him.

Knock on....Wood.

Imagine having double Wood? There's a joke in that.

 

[Zephiisdaman]

Knightmare on the Collingwood website answered a query about Tom Lamb:
Knightmares reply:
Not a fan.
Has some special but more often than not lacks intensity and consistency.
Going into his attributes:
Below average user by hand and foot. Lacks a best position. For a tallish forward not a strong enough mark. Defensively below average.
So there isn't anything there that gives me great confidence in his chances to develop.

I replied: A bit like Aish then.
Not sure I am welcome back there soon.

 

[inyourfacedunk]

I think talk of Stevens being traded is off the mark.

Some people just see a good player who isn't on the park and decide they are trade bait.
Stevens was in great form before being injured and an integral part of the team. Once he is fully fit and back in the side, people will go right back to saying he is a required player.