Strategy Trade and List management Thread Part 6 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
TiAn_ said:
He seems a little too good for a delist. Our options back there are pretty limited. We need another AFL level small imo. Not keen on seeing Vandermeer or Scott back there again.
Click to expand...

The question is whether he is the type of small we need. Feel like he was more of a distributor back there rather than a proper defender.

flipper83 said:
Yeah I'd prefer Teakle to Lycett. At least there's some potential upside there and he's athletic enough to keep up with opposition rucks.
I noticed phoenix Spicer has been delisted. I think I recall a few posters being keen on him when he was drafted. Might be a possible addition as a small forward. Only 2 years in the system and North Melbourne's system at that, so might be salvageable. Would bring some speed.
Click to expand...

There is zero point getting Lycett I think. Had a good career but his body looks shot now.

Teakle I’m not totally against. Had a real rough season, probably the worst player in the league, and they preferred playing Finlayson as number one ruck over him at times and an unable to move Lycett over him at other times. He’s athletic though and coming into the right age, showed some decent signs in his first games after being drafted. Can’t go into the season with just English and no other rucks so it would make some sense as the last spot on the list. Probably wouldn’t give him more than a one year contract.
 
Seeing if Tom Downie wants another couple of years on an AFL list would be better than all these other options.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Freshwater said:
At least Bramble isn’t from Hawthorn when Bevo was there. And he is a Western suburbs kid. But isn’t this out of his lane? Unless recruiting and list managers have identified him and sent Bevo to interview him?
What about the captain of Footscray, Sullivan, that kid looks like a weapon at VFL level, probably deserves a chance?
Click to expand...

I'd imagine Power identified him and now Bevo is interviewing. It's standard procedure from what I can tell. I remember both Treloar and Lobb mentioning having chats with Bevo very early in the process.
 
doggiesin08 said:
Seeing if Tom Downie wants another couple of years on an AFL list would be better than all these other options.
Click to expand...
Yep. Sam Naismith was close to an AFL lifeline at the mid season draft too.
Downie would be my no 1 pick if he was willing to re-enter the AFL system
 
Bramble is definitely a cut above VFL level. I’ve mentioned a couple of times that small defender role is something you can address pretty quickly with a mature state league player. You need don’t a star, just a solid citizen type.

I haven’t watched him enough. What’s he like defensively? We need a good defender rather than an attacking option on the list.
 
Snarls Barkley said:
I was a little surprised that Bramble got delisted from Hawthorn. He’s not the worst, thought he would’ve been kept on. I guess D’Ambrosio coming over was the nail in the coffin and Seamus Mitchell had gone past him.

I’m not sure he’d be anything more than depth to be honest. Think he’d be a good Footscray pick up though
Click to expand...

I would give Bramble a crack. Looked head and shoulders above the Footscray mids (Garcia / Sullivan) in the recent final.
 
Golden_6 said:
Bramble is definitely a cut above VFL level. I’ve mentioned a couple of times that small defender role is something you can address pretty quickly with a mature state league player. You need don’t a star, just a solid citizen type.

I haven’t watched him enough. What’s he like defensively? We need a good defender rather than an attacking option on the list.
Click to expand...

I knew the name, quick google and he’s described as a “dashing defender” lol
 
doggiesin08 said:
Seeing if Tom Downie wants another couple of years on an AFL list would be better than all these other options.
Click to expand...
I like it and there is a good story there if he runs out in the AFL again after everything he has been through.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

flipper83 said:
Fox has made a list of delisted free agents who might get another go:

Obviously we need to add a mature ruck, either a DFA or mature state league player.

I also wouldn't mind Mathieson, we are a bit soft and he would bring a hard edge although I think there may be some 'character' issues there which may make him unsuitable.

JACKSON HATELY


The former Crow and Giant is searching for a third chance at the top level after he was let go from West Lakes. The former first-round pick played 15 games for Adelaide in three seasons after requesting a trade back to South Australia after two seasons at the Giants. Given how testy his trade talks were, it‘s arguably a surprise he wasn’t given greater opportunity at the Crows. Hately believes he can “match it with anyone”, telling Trade Radio was playing close to his best footy in the SANFL and banging down the door to no reward. ”This year, the opportunities weren’t really there. We had a very healthy midfield group and a list that was playing quite well,” Hately said. ”I feel extremely confident that I can still play good AFL footy. I feel like I have played good AFL footy in the past. This year the opportunities didn’t quite come, but I’m still super confident.” A big bodied mid who has spent five years in the system could prove to be a valuable option for clubs looking for extra midfield depth. Turning 23 this weekend, Hately is still in the right bracket to join a rebuilding or regenerating team and provide an extra layer of depth – perhaps a West Coast or North Melbourne, or maybe even a club like Hawthorn – who could try and stash him at Box Hill before picking him up as a rookie in the mid-season draft if he impresses.

LOCHIE O’BRIEN

A year ago it looked as if Lochie O‘Brien had saved his football career when he was rewarded with a two-year extension at Carlton. Now he is looking for a new home to salvage it, after he was delisted with a year remaining on his contract. The former pick 10 played 66 games for the Blues but only managed six games this year – four of them as the starting substitute – as recruit Blake Acres and draftee Ollie Hollands surged ahead of him in the wing pecking order at Carlton. He could add to a team with the dash, outside run and kicking skills that have always been a feature in his game. The Mildura product attended Geelong Grammar for school and could maybe see an opening back down the highway at the Cats as they look to keep regenerating their list with younger talent. Collingwood have also previously shown fleeting interest in O’Brien on multiple occasions but after the success and stability in the Collingwood list, it looks like that opportunity may not be there anymore.

TRENT BIANCO

Bianco was one of five Collingwood players not offered a contract after their Grand Final triumph, departing his boyhood club after playing 23 games including last year‘s Preliminary Final against Sydney, after being selected in the 2019 National Draft. Bianco only played the one game this season at AFL level, but was a constant performer at the lower level, averaging 23.4 disposals from 18 games in the VFL. AFL Media’s Josh Gabelich reported in August that there was rival interest in Bianco as a delisted free agent, and the Victorian has made it clear he’d be willing to play anywhere. “There’s a little bit of interest out there,” Bianco said on Trade Radio. ”I would just love to be on an AFL list again. I’m probably hungrier than ever at the moment and I feel like I’ve got so much more to give. I was playing some really good footy this year in the VFL. Our team was gone very well, so it was hard to sort of break in but I feel I’ve got so much more to give. I think I’m at an age now where I’ve lived the experience in Melbourne and I feel like I’d be ready to make a move (interstate).”

BRODIE MCLAUGHLIN

The SSP recruit was a surprise axing at the Suns because of their list squeeze, with a haul of Academy products coming down the pipeline. “I had plenty of open and honest conversations throughout the years with (Suns list boss) Craig Cameron, and with the current list set up and academy players coming in next year … we knew it would be tough to stick around at the club,“ he explained on Trade Radio. “Craig has been awesome with me and very complimentary of my year. He said he would have loved to keep me, but realistically … I probably wouldn’t be able to play next year.” The Frosty Miller Medallist and VFL premiership player is hitting the prime of his career at 25 years old, and could prove to be the perfect foil for a club in need of a marking and goal kicking target or that ready-made depth option. Melbourne certainly needs a bit of forward help but they‘re chips in on the Harrison Petty/Jacob van Rooyen combination, with Ben Brown and Tom McDonald as backup, and McLaughlin wouldn’t be an obvious starter ahead of that group. It was reported late in the trade period that St Kilda had shown interest in McLaughlin and could still look to bring him in to provide some assistance for Max King and stiffen up their front half with another genuine tall option; after all Anthony Caminiti was the last man on their list during the pre-season and ended up playing 18 games. Would North Melbourne see him as a ready-made option to assist Nick Larkey?

BRYNN TEAKLE

Up to three clubs have already been linked to the 24-year-old following his six game stint in a year and a half at the Power. Teakle was delisted in the club‘s first round of axings to make room for ruck recruits Ivan Soldo and Jordon Sweet who came into the club on deadline day. AFL Media reported the Western Bulldogs, North Melbourne and the GWS Giants have registered interest in the Western Australian. Sweet’s incoming exit could open a spot on the Bulldogs’ list for a player like Teakle to play a supporting role for All-Australian ruckman Tim English, while Teakle has also been trialled as a defender and can play as a forward target, potentially giving the Dogs more flexibility among their key position stocks. The Kangaroos will also be looking for depth options behind Tristan Xerri, while Teakle could rival Charlie Comben and Callum Coleman-Jones at Arden Street to partner Nick Larkey in attack. The Giants have committed to Braydon Preuss for another year to back up Kieren Briggs but having lost Matthew Flynn as a Free Agent to West Coast, could add some extra depth.

JACK PERIS

The son of Olympic champion Nova broke through for his senior debut in Round 18 this year against the Gold Coast after graduating from the Saints Next Generation Academy. It was the only game he played before he was delisted at the end of the year. Ironically it could be the Suns who give him a second chance. According to SEN‘s Tom Morris, the Suns are exploring the possibility of bringing Peris in to train through the pre-season, with a view to possibly handing him a rookie list spot. The lightning quick half forward impressed with his speed and fleet of foot skills and could still yet have plenty to offer at AFL level in a new environment.

ORAZIO FANTASIA

While he is yet to be officially delisted from Port Adelaide, it appears unlikely that Orazio Fantasia will be at Alberton Oval next season. After two injury riddled seasons, Fantasia has question marks over his body and fitness but is still capable of producing moments of brilliance in the forward half which has piqued rival interest as a depth option. Foxfooty.com.au‘s David Zita reported last week of the Giants’ interest in Fantasia, with the 28-year-old meeting with the club during the trade period and completing a medical. If he is to be let go by the Power, the Giants appear the club most likely to give Fantasia a third chance at AFL level on an incentive-based rookie deal.

SCOTT LYCETT

Similar to Fantasia, Lycett is yet to officially be moved on from Port Adelaide, but the Power‘s dual ruck acquisitions on deadline day all but confirmed that the premiership Eagle’s days at Alberton Oval are numbered. His manager Colin Young confirmed on Trade Radio on deadline day Lycett was deciding between retiring or continuing his career at a third club. After a solid performance in the Power’s unsuccessful finals run it’s clear Lycett still has a bit more to give, and there are always teams willing to spin the ruck merry-go-round. In a virtual trade, Lycett could replace Soldo at Punt Road and provide some experience for Richmond as backup to Toby Nankervis. North Melbourne might also be a suitor for Lycett if he puts himself on the open market as senior experience to young ruck duo Tristian Xerri and Callum Coleman-Jones who have both had their injury troubles in recent seasons. Don’t count out Geelong either, who love the look of young Toby Conway and have the ever-inconsistent Rhys Stanley.

RHYS MATHIESON

Mathieson‘s struggle for game time at the loaded Lions reached a peak in 2023 when he failed to break through for a single senior game. While he is yet to be moved on by the Lions, a move appears imminent after failing to find a new home in the trade period. Mathieson has played 72 games in eight years at the Lions and would feel he still has more to offer after being used as the sub across the 2022 finals series. His experience in big games could be appealing for a club seeking that extra edge in the midfield and maturity around the edges of a young list. As the Eagles continue their long rebuild, could they make a call with the promise of game time in a young team to help play a big role in the climb back up the ladder?

HAYDEN CROZIER
Another one who is yet to be delisted but his time at his current club appears close to up, Crozier could be moving onto his third AFL home. Crozier only managed four games in his sixth year at the Bulldogs. Having battled injuries in recent years, the 29-year-old has struggled to maintain a regular spot in Luke Beveridge‘s side. The 142-gamer could yet prove valuable depth for a side close to contending or provide cover for a side lacking defensive experience. The primary link through the trade period was with Carlton, and Crozier could yet be signed on or invited to train across the pre-season at Princes Park. Adelaide could use some defensive assistance with its young and injury-hit backline, though he doesn’t quite have the size they’d like, while Richmond’s back six has become a problem and they could opt for Crozier as a cheap fill-in.
Click to expand...

Would like to see us take Jackson Hately as an eventual Jack Macrae replacement - our VFL Mids are small and need some size. While speed and explosiveness is a need a good big mid would be handy - today out mid depth is West, Garcia, McNeil and was McLean and McComb - too same same. Need speed and size.
 
Dogs_R_Us said:
I'm just posting a hello to Bulldogs Legend and hope that he'll reply to me too :)

The Simpsons Hello GIF
Click to expand...
I dont like to disappoint even though I do it regularly
 
ScottyDogg said:
Totally agree. To win premierships you need role players on small contracts. I think the other side to this argument that’s fair however is that you should only be given 2-3 seasons max to prove yourself as a cheap role player otherwise rinse and repeat until we find the next Liam Picken etc. Anthony Scott has proven his value Roarke really hasn’t.
Click to expand...
I get that but it’s not like he was on the main list the whole time and he may well have been Scott if not for injuries
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Mutt
Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)
317 318 319 320 321
Replies
8K
Views
452K
Bulldogs85
Bulldogs85
goodcop badcop
Analysis Draft, List and Trade Analysis
Replies
4
Views
1K
BIG_BONTS
BIG_BONTS
Mutt
Rules Posting Extracts or Articles From Sources Which May Breach Copyright
Replies
12
Views
684
Cookie
Cookie
VitalDread
List Mgmt. 2025 Draft Thread
Replies
5
Views
553
House_of_Dahl
House_of_Dahl
goodcop badcop
List Mgmt. 2024 Draft Thread
117 118 119 120 121
Replies
3K
Views
149K
VitalDread
VitalDread
Next Waiting
Opinion Dogs and Horses - The Racing Thread
9 10 11 12 13
Replies
316
Views
10K
King Harold
King Harold
dogwatch
List Mgmt. WB Off Season News Items 2024
Replies
10
Views
1K
geoffjennings79
geoffjennings79

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top