List Mgmt. Trade/Draft/Targets Part II

[fargothegreat]

Watch us trade Menadue for pick 88 or a packet of chips.

I don't think we care. We'd just rather pay a draftee with more upside.

 

[Mr Unbelievable]

Joe Daniher is irreplacable according to him on Fox Sports news today, WOW!!

Just a moron.....
In his mind ... he is trying to up the price
If Daniher goes . . does that get in the head of the players ... does it undervalue them .. making finals without him
Dodoro ... dickhead

 

[Muddiemoose]

Joe Daniher is irreplacable according to him on Fox Sports news today, WOW!!



[

What a minnrow every single player is replaceable it’s just a matter of building a list that has depth so losing someone isn’t a make or break situation

We lost some of the best players in the comp this year and we managed to replace them

 

[THE_GUN]

People are having an orgasm about a pick #22
Ok whats pick #22 worth ?

18 year old kid named Cameron Tahaney or something

why is this a good thing losing 3 wingman at once

Im happy to keep McIntosh for 2020 we seen this year what injury's do and depth we need

 

[GPetro13]

Not sure why everyone is melting about doing nothing this trade period.

We are already bringing the best player available into our Premiership team and he costed us nothing.

His name is Alex Rance.

Best player and pick 3, Sydney Stack. We’re laughing

 

[GPetro13]

If they want the both of them that would be what I would ask for
Kmac a contracted, required player who hasn’t requested a trade, no reason to role over on him. Menadue some pretty handy steak knives in that as well, still has elite traits if he can put them all together.

They’ll want to sort out Hill I think before anything else. I wonder if the rumour of us being keen for Blakely is true and if a straight swap is on the cards. Langdon has gone now though so they may wanna hold onto Blakely

 

[THE_GUN]

Menadue + #41 for Pick #22 would be a good deal for Richmond

 

[Not Important]

Just a moron.....
In his mind ... he is trying to up the price
If Daniher goes . . does that get in the head of the players ... does it undervalue them .. making finals without him
Dodoro ... dickhead

there's no assurance daniher will ever play much footy again with his unsolved injury issues.

 

[TigersMP4]

there's nothing we really need to do this trade period. we'll work to get the some VFL regulars some greater senior opportunities.

i'd like to see us package some picks to move into/around the top 10 mark.

 

[TigersMP4]

Menadue + #41 for Pick #22 would be a good deal for Richmond

i agree. But Free will need that pick for their academy kid.

 

[Grechy]

People are having an orgasm about a pick #22
Ok whats pick #22 worth ?

18 year old kid named Cameron Tahaney or something

why is this a good thing losing 3 wingman at once

Im happy to keep McIntosh for 2020 we seen this year what injury's do and depth we need

Can't lose Macca. Perfect fit to come in if we need a replacement winger or backman.

 

[mad_tiggy911]

3rd or 4th I would imagine maybe a little more for Mac because he’s contracted and probably just out of our best 22

Lol wtf? Why are our players worth nothing?

 

[THE_GUN]

i agree. But Free will need that pick for their academy kid.

They use later picks for the points , Doesnt need to be a particular kid
but they wont do anything until the Hill deal is complete

 

[Tiges1229]

Can't lose Macca. Perfect fit to come in if we need a replacement winger or backman.

Yep don’t want Kmac to go either , lost some form but can get it back .

 

[mad_tiggy911]

Every time I watched Scully play this year he was awful. He’s not the player he once was and was down every key statistic from 2017 (his last full season) to 2019.

Tom Scully and Tom Scully AFL Stats Comparison

Tom Scully and Tom Scully AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

Frost is a B grade 26 year old key defender. He has some nice traits but Melbourne fans sh*t themselves when he’s running the ball out of defence due to his sub par kicking skills and decision making. I think what they paid for him is a fair price.

What else have they done recently?

They got Scrimshaw for peanuts. I’m not sold he will make it though. Bit of a nothing recruit who wasn’t getting a gig at the Gold Coast (G’day Jack’s dad if you’re reading). Fortunately they didn’t cough up too much for him.

Tom Mitchell was a win in hindsight, but at the time pick 14 was about right for him as he was a fringe midfielder at Sydney.

They paid massive overs for Wingard. They got Wingard plus Port’s future third for Ryan Burton and pick 18 (Duursma) and pick 40 which was then on traded to Brisbane.

Jaeger O’Meara cost them a first and second rounder. About fair price. I don’t think O’Meara is in the top echelon of midfielders and I don’t think he ever will be due to his knee.

Sounds like they’ll cough up a pick in the 30s for Patton, who is garbage.

I don’t think they’ve done well personally. Mitchell is obviously the big win but the rest is meh.

Clarkos a genius though.

 

[Conca Cuddle]

Dodo is always the smartest bloke in the room - Makes it very difficult when a second person walks into that room

 

[THE_GUN]

Silence around Callum Moore , Surprised no clubs enquiring

 

[Calcium Man]

Dodo is always the smartest bloke in the room - Makes it very difficult when a second person walks into that room

Unless the second bloke is Chris Scott

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

What would they give us for Menadue or Macca?

Picks from 10-20

 

[mad_tiggy911]

Yawn.

 

[cairo tiger]

any clubs interested in the russian markov?

 

[Conca Cuddle]

Unless the second bloke is Chris Scott

Touche'

 

[Oprah From Tigerland]

Someone do something pls. Or just make something up.

 

[mad_tiggy911]

any clubs interested in the russian markov?

This. We should farkov Markov instead. Offers nothing.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Silence around Callum Moore , Surprised no clubs enquiring

Find it amazing that if anyone who could replace Astbury it's Moore.
Right age.
I'd keep him with that in mind.