Mega Thread Trade/Free Agency Open Discussion - RFC Forum

[Tomnat Tigers]

Conca's AFL form is so far ahead of anything Kennedy has produced, I've no idea how you can arrive at that conclusion.

Really? I think you do.

 

[Stylo]

Really? I think you do.

True

 

[TigerImposter]

Conca's AFL form is so far ahead of anything Kennedy has produced, I've no idea how you can arrive at that conclusion.

really 74games with about 6 good bits on the highlights reel. i Probably an exaggeration by me ,but we need more than 1 full game and two 1.5 quarter games from him to justify his existence on our list(injured or not).

 

[Stylo]

really 74games with about 6 good bits on the highlights reel. i Probably an exaggeration by me ,but we need more than 1 full game and two 1.5 quarter games from him to justify his existence on our list(injured or not).

It's still a shitload more than Kennedy has produced.

 

[TigerImposter]

It's still a shitload more than Kennedy has produced.

considering Kennedy was on an afl list in 2013 to conca's 2011, yeah right.
weighs up well on dollar to dollar value. cmon stylo he's under achieved injured or not

 

[Morro]

considering Kennedy was on an afl list in 2013 to conca's 2011, yeah right.
weighs up well on dollar to dollar value. cmon stylo he's under achieved injured or not

He has underachieved because of injury.

 

[TigerImposter]

He has underachieved because of injury.

agree,but 5 years on a list it maybe becoming more apparent that he has a body which is not up to the physical requirements of afl footy.
it's becoming a bit repetitive.

 

[THE_GUN]

agree,but 5 years on a list it maybe becoming more apparent that he has a body which is not up to the physical requirements of afl footy.
it's becoming a bit repetitive.[/QUOTE]

A little like posters constantly bagging our players

 

[Stylo]

considering Kennedy was on an afl list in 2013 to conca's 2011, yeah right.
weighs up well on dollar to dollar value. cmon stylo he's under achieved injured or not

I didn't say he hasn't underachieved, he has. I was just responding to your assertion that he's somehow behind Kennedy, which is ridiculous.

 

[TigerImposter]

I didn't say he hasn't underachieved, he has. I was just responding to your assertion that he's somehow behind Kennedy, which is ridiculous.

for his age, money to output he is.we will need to move on from here as this is the wrong thread for discussing Reece

 

[Bojangles17]

To be fair, they are all unproven

that's precisely my point , insufficient to build a case against seasoned balls and all AA calibre superstars , wouldn't you think

 

[Bojangles17]

open and shut case I would have thought , depending on how much you put a value on IFS, BUTS and MAYBEs
Richmond overall Player Ratings: 4707. Average: 214
Collingwood overall Player Ratings: 5451. Average: 248

 

[theflea]

That's where I see him as well, I think he'll improve a lot in his marking when he gets bigger but I don't see him being a game changer like Goldstein or Natanui.

I can see why he slipped now.

 

[theflea]

I never said he doesn't have a crack. The problem is he is tiny and has below average disposal which is unforgivable for a player <180cm. His tank and capacity to lay defensive pressure has also been questioned. The fact he is carving up the VFL every week yet looked way out of his depth when he got his opportunity just shows how big a difference there exists between the competitions. I wish him well at Melb because he was a courageous player but he's going to struggle unless he fixes his kicking and defensive aspects of his game. I'd be worried be worried for Conca if Kennedy was ahead of him tbh.

That's because that is bollox. In no way is Kennady ahead of Conca.

 

[Ned_Flanders]

If people want to talk about the Collingwood list, there is a Collingwood board....

 

[GoTigers2015]

Lids comments taken totally out of context, by Nat Edwards.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-11-27/deledio-treloar-got-a-bit-star-struck

RICHMOND vice captain Brett Deledio has hit back at comments made by Collingwood recruit Adam Treloar, declaring the Tigers are closer to a premiership. "I think Adam got a bit star struck when he got in front of the cameras and the microphone," Deledio said on Friday morning.

"Adam said what he said. But we just worry about what we're doing inside our four walls and we don't need to stress about what's been said across the road.
"It makes round two pretty interesting, doesn't it?

Would hardly call that criticism..

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Sounds like a tirade to me...

 

[Mr Magic]

for his age, money to output he is.we will need to move on from here as this is the wrong thread for discussing Reece

I think we need to groom him as a back pocket that can go in the guts.

We have the extra depth to do this now

 

[RockJobster0312]

I think we need to groom him as a back pocket that can go in the guts.

We have the extra depth to do this now

Pretty sure thats what the club were doing in the pre season of 2014 before he injured himself

 

[_RT_]

Up to 5 Victorian clubs have made contact with Ollie Wines in the hope of luring him home. Hopefully after taking a stab at Hartlett last season it was a part of a multi prong plan, either we land Hartlett who would have added that quality midfielder that we wanted or we forced Port to pay overs to keep him so that there was less money for Wines and we can pry him loose next year.

 

[RichoLedio]

Up to 5 Victorian clubs have made contact with Ollie Wines in the hope of luring him home. Hopefully after taking a stab at Hartlett last season it was a part of a multi prong plan, either we land Hartlett who would have added that quality midfielder that we wanted or we forced Port to pay overs to keep him so that there was less money for Wines and we can pry him loose next year.

I for one am glad we've pushed Ollie Wines out of Ports salary cap, it will make it much easier for Collingwood to recruit him

 

[Tigerbob]

Conca is a much better player than Kennedy. Not even a discussion.

 

[GoTigers2015]

Kennedy couldn't get a game at Lollingwood. No way he is better than Conca.

 

[Concatenate]

I for one am glad we've pushed Ollie Wines out of Ports salary cap, it will make it much easier for Collingwood to recruit him

I see Boak added another year to his contract -at the same time making hopeful noises about Wingard and Wines resigning. Hopefully only news is wingard this off season.

If he decides to go, surely no one else would be able to offer anything close to what we should be able to ???

 

[THE_GUN]

$850k should be on the table to his manager as we speak