Lambs brain good for footy
List Mgmt. Welcome Tom Lamb Pick 32 2014 Draft
- Thread starter larrikin
- Start date
- Tagged users None
didnt we have a eagle kicked 5 or 8 goals on debut from subiaco ,, he was so good i cant remember his name ,, i think it was greek , Metropolis ?I wasn't on big footy back in 07, and trust me I want Lamb to be the best thing ever, but how did the board react after Brown's debut against the Swans? I'm all for optimism and excitement, although I'd probably consider myself a realist, but how about we judge players after a little more than 3 scratch matches of exposed form. Yes Lamb looks good, but he's played an Indig all stars team, a woeful Carlton and a PA side with an undermanned defence. I think I'll reserve my judgement until mid next season at least and then I'll pronounce him as the second coming he will be
Metropolis kicked 8.
I think he kicked 6.
4 with his first 4 kicks. Instant fav player (at least for a week). As a youngster, I was down the local park emulating this new legend we'd unearthed.
Traded to Freo eventually.
Funny how the one player who wasn't vanilla in our draft, was the one player everyone was crying about because we didn't get Blakely, and now low and behold he's Mr Sex and everyone is talking about how good he could be.
See what happens when the club decides to draft something other than a slow 180cm safe bet midfielder? I said as much on draft night, i was stoked we got Lamb, it made up for the devastation slightly on missing out on Laverde
See what happens when the club decides to draft something other than a slow 180cm safe bet midfielder? I said as much on draft night, i was stoked we got Lamb, it made up for the devastation slightly on missing out on Laverde
- May 18, 2014
- 1,579
- 1,381
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Cockatoo ?
Lamb seems to Hogget a little I think.
- Jun 1, 2010
- 10,214
- 8,466
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I think you lot have a player. Will be a menace to defend him in a few years given his physical attributes.
Has any heard anything about Laverde? Was highly rated before the draft.
Lamb becomes GOAT
Mr Sex
#garrywho?
Mr Sex
#garrywho?
kane249
Wibble
- Oct 27, 2006
- 53,075
- 71,694
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Sth Freo, Liverpool, Chicago Bulls
If we had got Laverde, we would have taken Blakely with our second pick instead of Lamb.
eagle eyed
Team Captain
- Nov 1, 2013
- 376
- 533
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth Football Club, Liverpool FC,
Half the people that wanted Blakely would be crying after his quarter last week and even the patient ones would be complaining in 3 years time when we have too many "slower" inside mids.
eagle eyed
Team Captain
- Nov 1, 2013
- 376
- 533
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth Football Club, Liverpool FC,
If Blakely was so flavoursome Freo would have taken him instead of Weller. The fact that he slipped through to their second pick means there were 30+ players rated higher than him by other clubs.
kane249
Wibble
- Oct 27, 2006
- 53,075
- 71,694
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Sth Freo, Liverpool, Chicago Bulls
I'm talking more in terms of our needs, we identified before the draft we needed more mids and Laverde doesn't fill that need. Getting Duggan ticked that box, so we could afford to go more speculative with our next pick and we went for Lamb.
Probably. I never wanted Blakely to be honest. We'd just got Waterman to go along with Sheed, still had no outside run and hadn't drafted to fix our lack of X factor and line breaking around the ball.
Lamb provides something different to everything else on our list. Just like Yeo did when he joined the team last year. 193cm wild forward that can be anything. Definitely a punt worth taking IMO. The first concern people raised was his softness, and he's got a tick for that so far going by his 2 nab games. Early days though.
eagle eyed
Team Captain
- Nov 1, 2013
- 376
- 533
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth Football Club, Liverpool FC,
I too was never super keen on Blakely (maybe for our third rounder but we took Nelson and so far he looks like an inspired pick), he was never really going to address our needs. Yes we needed mids, but another inside mid was definitely not what we needed when we had Waterman with our last selection. Have to agree with you that Lamb was speculative and he looks like just what we need. I read something the other day that said Richmond's problem was that their 2nd & 3rd round selections had failed, I think our problem is that our 2nd rounders were too safe and really hadn't lifted the overall rating of the team. Karpany was a small step away from safe and now Lamb is a real shift in strategy, I just hope this continues until we are a contender and hopefully past that too.
Apex Predators
Team Captain
- Dec 31, 2014
- 534
- 742
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I agree. Blakely was surplus since we have Sheed and Waterman. Plus, I like the Duggan and Lamb combination (as well as Nelson).
Duggan may be seen as the safe bet, but he brings elite dual-sided kicking and decision making. If he can develop this at AFL level, he can become the 'general' in the middle that adds poise to our midfield group. Not a sexy x-factor like Lamb, but great decision makers with great skills make the rest of the team look better.
Lamb could be anything, so hopefully he knuckles down and does what is needed to make the most of his natural abilities.
Very early days. Lamb has certainly put the right foot forward to begin with, but he's far from justifying selection over Blakely.
I still reckon Blakely has the better upside. Lamb has the physical and athletic capacity to impress from day one but there is of course a question mark over his midfield utility. Blakely on the other hand has the scope to become a high quality inside midfielder (IMO). His obstacle to overcome will be his footskills.
Lamb certainly seems a greater asset in 2015 but over the stretch it will be an interesting comparison.
- Sep 8, 2011
- 11,471
- 11,943
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Surely you've lost this argument now.
- May 18, 2014
- 1,579
- 1,381
- AFL Club
- West Coast
After picking Duggan , I would be dissapointed if they had of picked Blakely , lamb was the perfect pick after duggan, I have never been that impressed with Duggan but the way he get's talked up by everyone, there must be something special there, I have always admired lambs determination on field all though he can drop his head a bit when it doesn't go his way, but I take that as been critical on his own performance which is a good thing, and nelson has really impressed me he's hard at it and composure is great, blah blah blah wouldn't change any of our 2014 draft picks at this stage and it's been years since I have thought that !
I see it the opposite with Lamb having a far higher ceiling, 193cm 15 beepers with footy nouse and aggression aren't that common. I love the fact he's a hard trainer as well, these are the guys that lift the standard at training like Cuz used to do.
being an up and comer you probably wouldn't be overly enthused being compared to brown.
And if we turn another exciting forward prospect into a backman I will be pissed
and we turned him into a backman too
Monocle
And the rebuild begins.
- Sep 18, 2003
- 12,426
- 39,568
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Claremont NE Patriots Eagles AFLW
Credit to the recruiters they went X factor ( for once and not the local safe pick ) and also went point of difference 
and it looks at this early stage that we have a player on our hands. Once Lamb bulks up he is going to very hard to match up on, together with Jack they are going be a headache playing in tandem for opposition backlines.
I would not have been disappointed with Blakely with our second but thought a first rounder was way overs.
and it looks at this early stage that we have a player on our hands. Once Lamb bulks up he is going to very hard to match up on, together with Jack they are going be a headache playing in tandem for opposition backlines.I would not have been disappointed with Blakely with our second but thought a first rounder was way overs.
Early days with the Lamb over Blakey argument but i think we drafted in a more well rounded way in the sense we drafted a player with excellent skills as a mid (Duggan) , an inside mid to compliment Sheed ( Waterman) , a HBF/Mid (Nelson), a pacey mid/FWD (Cavka) and then we drafted Lamb as a 3rd tall with pace and endurance and capable of maybe being a Mid. Not saying all those players will work out but we did go along way to fixing our midfield problems.
Similar threads
