-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Which 5 Players do you want on your team?
- Thread starter Hawthorn231533
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Hawthorn231533
Cancelled
- May 23, 2012
- 245
- 326
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Thread starter
- #77
James Frawley
Jack Riewoldt
Nic Naitanui
Scott Pendlebury
Brett Deledio
Jack Riewoldt
Nic Naitanui
Scott Pendlebury
Brett Deledio
Hand
Don't think, Do.
dont rate the cotch
I know right.. Cotchin would be in my top 10. Just didn't scrape in to my 5.
Mat the Cat
Debutant
Scott Pendlebury
Trent Cotchin
Gary Ablett
Dane Swan
Dean Cox
Trent Cotchin
Gary Ablett
Dane Swan
Dean Cox
Dustin Martin
Cyril
Buddy
Stephen Hill
Nic Nat
Cyril
Buddy
Stephen Hill
Nic Nat
Ablett
Franklin
Deledio
Griffen
Naitanui
Add in Ablett, Deledio and Griffen who all have pace and can break the lines but also kick goals.
Franklin and Cloke in tandem would arguably be the best forward combination in the game.
Naitanui in the ruck would be exciting. Very exciting with blokes like Swan, Pendlebury, Ablett, Thomas, Griffen and Ball roving to him.
B - Toovey Brown Maxwell
HB - Shaw Reid Deledio
C - Thomas Ablett Griffen
HF - Beams Cloke Sidebottom
F - Didak Franklin Wellingham
R - Naitanui Swan Pendlebury
INT - Jolly Ball Tarrant O'Brien
Franklin
Deledio
Griffen
Naitanui
Add in Ablett, Deledio and Griffen who all have pace and can break the lines but also kick goals.
Franklin and Cloke in tandem would arguably be the best forward combination in the game.
Naitanui in the ruck would be exciting. Very exciting with blokes like Swan, Pendlebury, Ablett, Thomas, Griffen and Ball roving to him.
B - Toovey Brown Maxwell
HB - Shaw Reid Deledio
C - Thomas Ablett Griffen
HF - Beams Cloke Sidebottom
F - Didak Franklin Wellingham
R - Naitanui Swan Pendlebury
INT - Jolly Ball Tarrant O'Brien
col23
Debutant
- Jul 6, 2011
- 145
- 48
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
1. Nic Nat - We have clear ruck issues at the moment (tempted to go sandilands or cox, but Nic Nat has more upside in terms of future)
2. James Frawley - We get monstered too often by big powerful forwards
3. Travis Cloke - Buddy and Cloke in the 50 with Cyril at their feet.
4. Kennedy (Syd)- Sewell is getting towards the end, Kennedy is an even better option along side Lewis as our inside grunt players who can kick goals (sigh, hawthorn royalty, emerging as a superstar and we let him go)
5. Pendlebury - Can't go past his class. Considered swan but midfield already heavy enough.
With cloke and Franklin up forward we can play Roughy whereever he is required in the situation as i think he is one of the most versatilebigmen going around.
Bailey comes back in and theres no room for hale.
It would be nice if we could just pluck 5 players at will
2. James Frawley - We get monstered too often by big powerful forwards
3. Travis Cloke - Buddy and Cloke in the 50 with Cyril at their feet.
4. Kennedy (Syd)- Sewell is getting towards the end, Kennedy is an even better option along side Lewis as our inside grunt players who can kick goals (sigh, hawthorn royalty, emerging as a superstar and we let him go)
5. Pendlebury - Can't go past his class. Considered swan but midfield already heavy enough.
With cloke and Franklin up forward we can play Roughy whereever he is required in the situation as i think he is one of the most versatilebigmen going around.
Bailey comes back in and theres no room for hale.
It would be nice if we could just pluck 5 players at will
wheres Cotchin hahaha
- Jun 22, 2008
- 24,580
- 21,287
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Dangerfield
Cotchin
Nic Nat or Maric
Rance or Glass depending on an immediate need or long term replacement for Scarlett.
Cloke to replace Pods.
Cotchin
Nic Nat or Maric
Rance or Glass depending on an immediate need or long term replacement for Scarlett.
Cloke to replace Pods.
Grockadoc
Brownlow Medallist
- Jul 25, 2008
- 25,888
- 50,019
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Fighting Furies, Man Utd, Cavaliers
I knew I left someone very important out. I originally had him named on the wing haha, but deleted him for Pendles and forgot to put him back in.
B: Grimes, Rance, Batchelor
HB: Newman, Frawley, Morris
C: Pendlebury, Watson, Foley
HF: Martin, Kennedy, Vickery
F: Fyfe, Riewoldt, Nahas
R: Maric, Deledio, Cotchin
IC: Grigg, Ellis, Tuck, Houli.
Better?
- Sep 10, 2010
- 28,939
- 42,097
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Toronto Maple Leafs
Barring current injuries...
B: Waters, Glass, Schofield
HB: Hurn, MacKenzie, O'Brien
C: Dangerfield, Priddis, Shuey
HF: Ablett, Cloke, Darling
F: Le Cras, Kennedy, Nicoski
R: Naitanui, J Selwood, S Selwood
Int: Cox, Kerr, Rosa, Masten
B: Waters, Glass, Schofield
HB: Hurn, MacKenzie, O'Brien
C: Dangerfield, Priddis, Shuey
HF: Ablett, Cloke, Darling
F: Le Cras, Kennedy, Nicoski
R: Naitanui, J Selwood, S Selwood
Int: Cox, Kerr, Rosa, Masten
robertg22
Like a librarian
Ruby
Collingwood - Ben Kennedy Player Sponsor 2014
Collingwood - Quinten Lynch Player Sponsor 2013
Collingwood Magpies - Alex Fasolo 2012 Player Sponsor
Collingwood Magpies - Alan Didak 2011 Player Sponsor
Collingwood Magpies - Alan Didak 2010 Player Sponsor
Collingwood Magpies - Alan Didak 2009 Player Sponsor
Franklin
D Swallow
Darling
Patton
Naitanui
Key backs and mids we're pretty much set, but still feel D Swallow will be the best of the current young crop so he'd only make us better. Naitanui steps straight in to ruck now and in the future. Franklin to tandem with Cloke up forward and Darling to play third tall. Patton a future proposition.
D Swallow
Darling
Patton
Naitanui
Key backs and mids we're pretty much set, but still feel D Swallow will be the best of the current young crop so he'd only make us better. Naitanui steps straight in to ruck now and in the future. Franklin to tandem with Cloke up forward and Darling to play third tall. Patton a future proposition.
Ashley Sampi - small crumbing forward we need right now
Cayden Beetham - good midfield depth , great goal kicking ability
Danny Roach - Much needed backmen for our depleted kp backmen
Lawrence Angwin - Good foil for cloke to play other kp forward role
Nathan Ablett - Third leading tall up forward with experience
Cayden Beetham - good midfield depth , great goal kicking ability
Danny Roach - Much needed backmen for our depleted kp backmen
Lawrence Angwin - Good foil for cloke to play other kp forward role
Nathan Ablett - Third leading tall up forward with experience
Frawley - Best young key back.
Kennedy - Clearance machine (even with tuck in great form, kennedy is too hard to go past)
Ablett - Because its Ablett
Cloke - take some pressure off jack, put some pressure on Vickery to actually do something
Lecras - Love the bloke, shattered he is inj. doesnt get enough respect IMO.
Ablett/pendles is a toss of the coin IMO, I just love gaz.
Kennedy - Clearance machine (even with tuck in great form, kennedy is too hard to go past)
Ablett - Because its Ablett
Cloke - take some pressure off jack, put some pressure on Vickery to actually do something
Lecras - Love the bloke, shattered he is inj. doesnt get enough respect IMO.
Ablett/pendles is a toss of the coin IMO, I just love gaz.
Beams
Peds
Tippett
Selwood
...mmm...Cassisi
Peds
Tippett
Selwood
...mmm...Cassisi
1. Gary Ablett Jr
2. Lance Franklin
3. Trent Cotchin
4. Brett Deledio
5. Nat Fyfe
B: Colin Garland; James Frawley; Sam Blease
HB: Jack Grimes; Jared Rivers; Jack Watts
C: Brett Deledio; Trent Cotchin; Nathan Jones
HF: Jeremy Howe; Lance Franklin; Jack Trengove
F: Liam Jurrah; Mitch Clark; Colin Sylvia
R: Mark Jamar;Nat Fyfe; Gary Ablett
I: Stef Martin; James Magner; Brent Moloney; Jordie McKenzie
We're still shit.
2. Lance Franklin
3. Trent Cotchin
4. Brett Deledio
5. Nat Fyfe
B: Colin Garland; James Frawley; Sam Blease
HB: Jack Grimes; Jared Rivers; Jack Watts
C: Brett Deledio; Trent Cotchin; Nathan Jones
HF: Jeremy Howe; Lance Franklin; Jack Trengove
F: Liam Jurrah; Mitch Clark; Colin Sylvia
R: Mark Jamar;Nat Fyfe; Gary Ablett
I: Stef Martin; James Magner; Brent Moloney; Jordie McKenzie
We're still shit.
Kennedy (WCE)
Beams
Sidey
Danger
Phil Davis
Will be EPIC for us, oh to dream lol
Beams
Sidey
Danger
Phil Davis
Will be EPIC for us, oh to dream lol
Previous poster was right, very few picking Judd. Watching him this year and while he plays a role he is half the player he was between 2003-first half of 2007.
For West Coast
First give the midfield a boost in class and pace
Pendles
Ablett
Dangerfield
Cotchin
Add in another forward with Kennedy and Darling
Franklin
For West Coast
First give the midfield a boost in class and pace
Pendles
Ablett
Dangerfield
Cotchin
Add in another forward with Kennedy and Darling
Franklin
Selwood
Nic Nat
Pendlebury
Hurley
Bartel
Nic Nat
Pendlebury
Hurley
Bartel
TigerBlood87
Team Captain
Fyfe
Dangerfield
Nic Nat
Phil Davis at CHB
Scott Selwood or Carrazzo to replace Daniel Jackson
Dangerfield
Nic Nat
Phil Davis at CHB
Scott Selwood or Carrazzo to replace Daniel Jackson
This is sort of like dreaming of what you would do with lottery winnings.
I wouldn't even worry about a ruckman. If jacobs goes down I would rather just replace him with a 2nd ruck from your squad who is at least competitive and throw another selwood or deledio at their feet.
That in mind:
Pendlebury
Deledio
Fyfe
Franklin
Frawley
I wouldn't even worry about a ruckman. If jacobs goes down I would rather just replace him with a 2nd ruck from your squad who is at least competitive and throw another selwood or deledio at their feet.
That in mind:
Pendlebury
Deledio
Fyfe
Franklin
Frawley
PatrickBateman
Norm Smith Medallist
Ablett
Pendlebury
Franklin
Lake
Cox
Pendlebury
Franklin
Lake
Cox
Similar threads
