-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Which 5 Players do you want on your team?
- Thread starter Hawthorn231533
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Wacky Tiger
Parmy
Ablett
Cloke
Nic Nat
Dangerfield
Hurley
Cloke
Nic Nat
Dangerfield
Hurley
daniel2323
Senior List
Ablett
Reid
Nic Nat
Pendlebury
Fyfe
Reid
Nic Nat
Pendlebury
Fyfe
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
Keeping away from the absolute best players and leaning more towards players who are the best at a role we need to fill:
Josh Kennedy (Syd): We struggle at the clearances, Josh is one of the best players around in clearance situations. Also contributes on the scoreboard, which all of our midfielders not named Brad Ebert struggle with.
Brent Stanton (Ess): We also struggle on the spread, which leads to stagnant movement. Stanton runs harder than anyone and would make a huge difference to our midfield.
Jarryd Roughead (Haw): We need a forward who can rotate into the ruck, and Daniel Stewart doesn't look like he's up to it. Roughead is arguably the best forward who can rotate into the ruck in the competition. Mitch Clark would be another good option, but he struggled when asked to rotate between the roles at Brisbane, so I'd stick with the safer option.
Sam Butler (WCE): Not the best option for his position, but I went with him because he's a South Australian free agent who's spent time in the WAFL this season, so he might be a viable option for Port. Sam plays deep in defence, can defend well and can also rebound, something we've struggled with out of defence which has forced us to play Pearce and Hartlett out of position. If I had gone with the best option rather than a semi-realistic option, I would've said Grant Birchall.
Todd Goldstein (NM): Todd thrives as a No. 1 ruck who gets the majority of gametime. He's wasted in a partnership with McIntosh. Port need a No. 1 ruck, and Todd would do well rotating with someone like Roughead as he did rotating with Petrie last year rather than rotating with another player who's best position is in the ruck.
If Renouf continues in the same vein as he has in the last couple of weeks with 40+ hitouts, we may not need another ruckman. If that happens, I pick Fyfe instead of Goldstein. No specific justification for this, I just think he's awesome.
You can have him.
Josh Kennedy (Syd): We struggle at the clearances, Josh is one of the best players around in clearance situations. Also contributes on the scoreboard, which all of our midfielders not named Brad Ebert struggle with.
Brent Stanton (Ess): We also struggle on the spread, which leads to stagnant movement. Stanton runs harder than anyone and would make a huge difference to our midfield.
Jarryd Roughead (Haw): We need a forward who can rotate into the ruck, and Daniel Stewart doesn't look like he's up to it. Roughead is arguably the best forward who can rotate into the ruck in the competition. Mitch Clark would be another good option, but he struggled when asked to rotate between the roles at Brisbane, so I'd stick with the safer option.
Sam Butler (WCE): Not the best option for his position, but I went with him because he's a South Australian free agent who's spent time in the WAFL this season, so he might be a viable option for Port. Sam plays deep in defence, can defend well and can also rebound, something we've struggled with out of defence which has forced us to play Pearce and Hartlett out of position. If I had gone with the best option rather than a semi-realistic option, I would've said Grant Birchall.
Todd Goldstein (NM): Todd thrives as a No. 1 ruck who gets the majority of gametime. He's wasted in a partnership with McIntosh. Port need a No. 1 ruck, and Todd would do well rotating with someone like Roughead as he did rotating with Petrie last year rather than rotating with another player who's best position is in the ruck.
If Renouf continues in the same vein as he has in the last couple of weeks with 40+ hitouts, we may not need another ruckman. If that happens, I pick Fyfe instead of Goldstein. No specific justification for this, I just think he's awesome.
Balony_pony16 said:
You can have him.
Nat Fyfe- Gun, 10 year ahead of him, future brownlow medallist
Chris Yarran- Would be missing link in out backline, Leon Davis replacement
Lance Franklin- Freak, him and Cloke in same forward line, wow.
Lenny Hayes- In and under specialist
Dean Cox- Still the best ruckman, despite lack of game time.
Top 5 young guns i would take to build around would be;
Nat Fyfe- see above
Jeremy Cameron- Looks like an absolute gun
Trent Cotchin- Machine
Chris Yarran- see above
Nick Naitanui- Will be the best for 10 years
Chris Yarran- Would be missing link in out backline, Leon Davis replacement
Lance Franklin- Freak, him and Cloke in same forward line, wow.
Lenny Hayes- In and under specialist
Dean Cox- Still the best ruckman, despite lack of game time.
Top 5 young guns i would take to build around would be;
Nat Fyfe- see above
Jeremy Cameron- Looks like an absolute gun
Trent Cotchin- Machine
Chris Yarran- see above
Nick Naitanui- Will be the best for 10 years
Ablett
Pendlebury
Goodes
Selwood
Cotchin
Pendlebury
Goodes
Selwood
Cotchin
Hayes
Goddard
Fisher
McEvoy
Milne
Goddard
Fisher
McEvoy
Milne
You don't want to make the finals?
Bombers 2014
Senior List
Cotchin
Pendles
Ablett
Dangerfield
Rutten
Pendles
Ablett
Dangerfield
Rutten
- Mar 23, 2007
- 34,932
- 23,542
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Man U, Canucks and 49ers
NicNat
Frawley
GAblett
Pendles
Thomas
Frawley
GAblett
Pendles
Thomas
Perfect for bombers.
Right now (barring injuries)
West Coast's best 22:
Waters Glass A Selwood
Schofield MacKenzie Hurn
Gaff Priddis Rosa
Hill Kennedy Nicoski
LeCras Lynch Cox
Naitanui S Selwood Kerr
Shuey Darling Embley Masten
Gary Ablett (Middle) Replace Masten
Brett Deledio (Backline) Replace A Selwood
Scott Pendlebury (Middle) Replace Embley
Dayne Beams (Half Forward) Replace Nicoski
Lance Franklin (Full Forward) Replace Lynch
One can dream.
West Coast's best 22:
Waters Glass A Selwood
Schofield MacKenzie Hurn
Gaff Priddis Rosa
Hill Kennedy Nicoski
LeCras Lynch Cox
Naitanui S Selwood Kerr
Shuey Darling Embley Masten
Gary Ablett (Middle) Replace Masten
Brett Deledio (Backline) Replace A Selwood
Scott Pendlebury (Middle) Replace Embley
Dayne Beams (Half Forward) Replace Nicoski
Lance Franklin (Full Forward) Replace Lynch
One can dream.
Jade
Smug lives here.
- Jul 8, 2008
- 34,627
- 53,702
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Cotchin
Pendlebury
Dangerfield
Ablett
Lecras
And i'll be seeing you all after our twentieth flag.
Pendlebury
Dangerfield
Ablett
Lecras
And i'll be seeing you all after our twentieth flag.
For an immediate tilt at the flag:
Franklin
Frawley
Ablett
D.Martin
Jetta of the Sydney variety
Franklin
Frawley
Ablett
D.Martin
Jetta of the Sydney variety
Shupe
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 21, 2011
- 13,337
- 10,402
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Indianapolis Colts
Give me Cotchin. Don't care who else.
Or bring the WA boys back home - D Swallow, O'meara, Bennell, Coniglio
Or bring the WA boys back home - D Swallow, O'meara, Bennell, Coniglio
I would like Josh Kennedy, Mark Lecras, Andrew Embley, Luke Shuey and Mark Nicoski this weekend thanks.
Swan, L.Ball, Reid and H.Shaw would be handy ins
Chuck in Buddy to get you 5
Five that would improve the pies
A ruck - Cox/Mumford etc
A KPF/2nd Ruck - Tippett, Ryder
Good kick from the back - Hurn
A SF who is kicking goals - Betts
Ablett would be handy too
Chuck in Buddy to get you 5
Five that would improve the pies
A ruck - Cox/Mumford etc
A KPF/2nd Ruck - Tippett, Ryder
Good kick from the back - Hurn
A SF who is kicking goals - Betts
Ablett would be handy too
Similar threads
