Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Corn Cobbers]

Pies are the best performed team in history, not up for dispute

 

[Worm4]

If Carlton win the flag, then sure.

But they haven't, yet.

Not even the worst flag defence in the past handful of years, there's a side that won a flag three seasons ago and have not won a final since (and look like continuing with that this year).

You did read the title of the thread though , yeah ?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Show me where I said Pies weren't joint leaders?

Keep struggling

Funny looking table

 

[Arr0w]

Funny looking table

Can you find one that doesn't have 3 sides equal on 16 flags?

You really aren't that good at this baiting stuff

 

[Worm4]

You're getting emotional. Eat a Snickers

981 posts in this edition of the thread alone and what will you have to show for it? A losing elimination final but it's a win since the Pies missed the 8 after winning a flag?

Sorry, is 2024 over ? My mistake. Should I leave now ?

 

[Fadge]

No , you had us at 16th.
You are way off.
You had pies at top 4.
You are way off again
You had Saints top 4
Again .....way off

Thanks CArr0w, I mean Worm (aptly named).

 

[CarmenSandiego]

The AFLCA award used to be the most well-regarded individual accolade in the game.. until Fly came along.

He seriously gave Daicos 5 votes on the weekend? Seriously? How many week is that he's given Daicos unworthy votes? Almost as bad as when he gave him votes for a 30 touch 0 goal & 30% efficiency one week.

Cuddles McRae is taking his 'ted lasso i love my players so much' act way too far. It's compromising the competition.

 

[Arr0w]

Thanks CArr0w, I mean Worm (aptly named).

Facts matter fudge

Like trending top 4, hilarious

 

[Fadge]

Who cant make the 8 this year Pathetic GF defence

Yeah, we should instead defend a wooden spoon with another wooden spoon.

That's how title defences are done, the Carlton way!

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Can you find one that doesn't have 3 sides equal on 16 flags?

You really aren't that good at this baiting stuff

I'm not going around in circles with you Fatty, prove the Pies are not first, put up or shut up

 

[Worm4]

Thanks CArr0w, I mean Worm (aptly named).

Nice deflection. Are you claiming bragging rights on the 2024 ladder prediction thread yet ?

 

[Arr0w]

2024, Pies still in Mexico, fact!!

Juan week after another

 

[Arr0w]

I'm not going around in circles with you Fatty, prove the Pies are not first, put up or shut up

3 sides on 16 flags, refute that. Put up or shut up

 

[Arr0w]

Yeah, we should instead a wooden spoon with another wooden spoon.

That's how title defences are done, the Carlton way!

Can you repeat that in english

 

[Fadge]

The AFLCA award used to be the most well-regarded individual accolade in the game.. until Fly came along.

He seriously gave Daicos 5 votes on the weekend? Seriously? How many week is that he's given Daicos unworthy votes? Almost as bad as when he gave him votes for a 30 touch 0 goal & 30% efficiency one week.

Cuddles McRae is taking his 'ted lasso i love my players so much' act way too far. It's compromising the competition.

If McRae really did give Daicos 5 votes, meaning Voss gave the AFLCA leader 0 votes, it says more about the lack of integrity from Voss than it does about McRae.

But interesting that you'd raise it - zero self awareness as usual.

 

[adammania9]

Sorry, is 2024 over ? My mistake. Should I leave now ?

If you wanna fly your flag because you're 8th and out of the premiership hunt then go ahead, mate. Pies fans are content with this year, especially knowing you can only dream of experiencing a drop off like this

 

[Corn Cobbers]

3 sides on 16 flags, refute that. Put up or shut up

Prove that the original comment "best performed" means just flags without reference to the next column if flags are equal, and then reconcile that with all your Juan/border crap within an individual season, put up or shut up

 

[Fadge]

Prove that the original comment "best performed" means just flags without reference to the next column if flags are equal, and then reconcile that with all your Juan/border crap within an individual season, put up or shut up

Get it right (or wrong like CArr0w), it's 'boarder'.

 

[adammania9]

If McRae really did give Daicos 5 votes, meaning Voss gave the AFLCA leader 0 votes, it says more about the lack of integrity from Voss than it does about McRae.

But interesting that you'd raise it - zero self awareness as usual.

Blues fans displaying extreme tunnel vision today it seems. Why are they always so focused on individual awards and making up crazy agendas as to why Carlton players are being hard done in them?

The very same supporters who believe Cripps deserved his Brownlow

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Its a strategy nonetheless
Look at the glass half full side - pies sitting in double digits hanging shit on Carlton who are in the top 8.
They should be embarrassed their club has let them down this year. Pre season flag favourites and all.....

In years to come I will fondly remember Daicos's goal and McGoverns kick to beat your sorry mob twice. Not as great as the grim reaper game but still up there.

I suspect they will end up being the only things Carlton fans remember from 2024 in the future too.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Get it right, it's 'boarder'.

That "joke" flew way over our heads

 

[Arr0w]

Prove that the original comment "best performed" means just flags without reference to the next column if flags are equal, and then reconcile that with all your Juan/border crap within an individual season, put up or shut up

3 Sides equal on 16 flags, fact

Pies Juan more week in mexico, fact

 

[CarmenSandiego]

If McRae really did give Daicos 5 votes, meaning Voss gave the AFLCA leader 0 votes, it says more about the lack of integrity from Voss than it does about McRae.

But interesting that you'd raise it - zero self awareness as usual.

So, Daicos is entitled to votes because he's the current leader?

By almost all measures he was ranked the 10th-15th player on the ground, his DE was 53% with half of them handballs & took 0 marks, 7 turnovers, 3 frees against. In what world does that warrant 5 coaches votes? He has a history of getting undeserved coaches votes and there's one common denominator there.. his coach that's giving them to him.

It's pretty sad, I've never seen this sort of thing before.

 

[Robertio]

Yeah, we should instead defend a wooden spoon with another wooden spoon.

That's how title defences are done, the Carlton way!

You're starting to dribble mate.

 

[YeoShuey]

That "joke" flew way over our heads

The Cripps avatar is crazy, but still a massive upgrade on your old one.