Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Worm4]

Won't be an issue for any genuine contenders, regardless of where Carlton finish.

You keep saying something in the vicinity of "should they make finals" in your posts, yet you have them at bottom 4 . What would be refreshing from you instead of an each way take, is to say that "they will finish bottom 4 irrespective of the fixture, or run of injuries" its been your stance since October, I'm not sure why you don't run with it in every thread you post in relating to Carlton

 

[Arr0w]

You keep saying something in the vicinity of "should they make finals" in your posts, yet you have them at bottom 4 . What would be refreshing from you instead of an each way take, is to say that "they will finish bottom 4 irrespective of the fixture, or run of injuries" its been your stance since October, I'm not sure why you don't run with it in every thread you post in relating to Carlton

Fadge the ultimate hedger as the season goes on

Will finish 13th, won't make finals, blah, blah

 

[Fadge]

If I was you, I'd be more worried about the Pies exiting mexico

Another opportunity for you to discuss footy, but you just go with the old, reliable 'Mexico'.

You are such a hypocrite.

 

[Fadge]

You keep saying something in the vicinity of "should they make finals" in your posts, yet you have them at bottom 4 . What would be refreshing from you instead of an each way take, is to say that "they will finish bottom 4 irrespective of the fixture, or run of injuries" its been your stance since October, I'm not sure why you don't run with it in every thread you post in relating to Carlton

We saw the difference in their performance last year when De Koning was there, and after he went down - it is poles apart.

With a good run with injuries, Carlton can contend for a finals spot for the 4th year in a row (what a dynasty!).

They lose one of Cripps, Weitering, Curnow or TDK for a significant stretch and it will get very ugly very quickly.

They are that fragile.

 

[Worm4]

We saw the difference in their performance last year when De Koning was there, and after he went down - it is poles apart.

With a good run with injuries, Carlton can contend for a finals spot for the 4th year in a row (what a dynasty!).

They lose one of Cripps, Weitering, Curnow or TDK for a significant stretch and it will get very ugly very quickly.

They are that fragile.

An opportunity to discuss footy and you throw in the "what a dynasty!" smartarse remark. You sir, are the hypocrite

 

[Arr0w]

Another opportunity for you to discuss footy, but you just go with the old, reliable 'Mexico'.

You are such a hypocrite.

"Because they won't be able to do it during finals (if they make it)."

See, when you are so definite, making a statement rather than asking how, to extend the debate, it's not worth considering

Then you hedge you position by " if they make it"

But, not sure I'd be focused on us, given you couldn't make the 8

 

[Fadge]

An opportunity to discuss footy and you throw in the "what a dynasty!" smartarse remark. You sir, are the hypocrite

Um, it is a banter thread...

 

[Worm4]

Um, it is a banter thread...

Does that mean that every post you write MUST have a smartarse response ?

 

[Fadge]

"Because they won't be able to do it during finals (if they make it)."

See, when you are so definite, making a statement rather than asking how, to extend the debate, it's not worth considering

Then you hedge you position by " if they make it"

But, not sure I'd be focused on us, given you couldn't make the 8

Of course there's an 'if' about Carlton making finals.

Are you really THAT offended that I've indicated there is a chance Carlton miss finals in 2025?

You really are a fragile bunch...

 

[Fadge]

Does that mean that every post you write MUST have a smartarse response ?

Jeepers, someone's getting a bit precious.

Chin up, it's December, and all teams are equal on 0 points on the ladder for 2025.

What a time to be a Carlton supporter!

 

[Worm4]

Pies to finish between 9th and 12th
Wheels to fall off early. A few old fellas to go in for surgery in July

 

[Fadge]

Where did I state anyone?

You don't need to 'state' it.

It's your MO.

 

[Arr0w]

Of course there's an 'if' about Carlton making finals.

Are you really THAT offended that I've indicated there is a chance Carlton miss finals in 2025?

You really are a fragile bunch...

Not offended at all, I don't need affirmation from you of all people given your track record of cognitive bias predictions

I actually think pie supporters are fragile and insecure, especially when they think they are a powerhouse contender or thinking the rabbit is a goat

 

[Arr0w]

You don't need to 'state' it.

It's your MO.

It really isn't surprising you are once again the scoreboard leader in another Carlton thread

Everyone, knows your MO

 

[Fadge]

Pies to finish between 9th and 12th
Wheels to fall off early. A few old fellas to go in for surgery in July

Is this where Collingwood supporters are meant to respond with - 'You're a nuffy troll and I don't value your opinion'?

 

[Fadge]

Not offended at all, I don't need affirmation from you of all people given your track record of cognitive bias predictions

I actually think pie supporters are fragile and insecure, especially when they think they are a powerhouse contender or thinking the rabbit is a goat

What is a 'Powerhouse Contender', and who thinks Nick Daicos is the GOAT?

 

[Arr0w]

No one expects a pie supporter in this thread to be able to conduct a balanced footy discussion

 

[Arr0w]

What is a 'Powerhouse Contender', and who thinks Nick Daicos is the GOAT?

You think the rabbit will be a GOAT, delusional arrogance

 

[Fadge]

No one expects a pie supporter in this thread to be able to conduct a balanced footy discussion

As Mr Meow said in the other thread, none of us have seen you have a 'balanced footy discussion' on the main board.

Stick to your laughing emojis and comments about Mexico and rabbits.

 

[Fadge]

You think the rabbit will be a GOAT, delusional arrogance

Which is quite different from 'thinking he IS the GOAT'....

Words are important.

 

[Arr0w]

As Mr Meow said in the other thread, none of us have seen you have a 'balanced footy discussion' on the main board.

Stick to your laughing emojis and comments about Mexico and rabbits.

You can't last 1 page discussing footy, but even your mates know that

 

[Fadge]

You can't last 1 page discussing footy, but even your mates know that

I've discussed more footy on the Main Board than I've seen you discuss...

 

[Arr0w]

Which is quite different from 'thinking he IS the GOAT'....

"Not a matter of if, a matter of when"

Seems pretty definitive

Oh boy

 

[Arr0w]

I've discussed more footy on the Main Board than I've seen you discuss...

You stalking again?

 

[Worm4]

Is this where Collingwood supporters are meant to respond with - 'You're a nuffy troll and I don't value your opinion'?

I can't make a valid prediction ?