Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Fadge]

Have already stated that the Pies have enough scoring power

4-5 of those players WON'T kick 20 goals H&A season, so it's a meaningless debate

Which ones?

 

[Arr0w]

So everyone agreeing that the Tiger poster was talking rubbish.

Actually the opposition, have another crack though

 

[Arr0w]

Except CArr0w, which is no surprise.

Where did I agree with the Tigers poster Fudge

 

[Fadge]

^^^^^
I'm a bit confused.... does CArr0w think he's agreeing with the Richmond poster, or not?

 

[Arr0w]

Which ones?

Name 7 that will in the H&A

 

[Fadge]

Name 7 that will in the H&A

I'm not deluded like Carlton supporters and understand some of those players will be impacted by injury, not to mention it will depend on the role they will be required to play in the team (due to injuries to other squad members), which was exactly my point about having depth in a team's goalkicking ranks...

 

[carlton_99]

Name 7 that will in the H&A

Get in line. I'm still waiting for the names Long, Macrae and McInnes are getting regular games ahead of.

 

[Arr0w]

I'm not deluded like Carlton supporters and understand some of those players will be impacted by injury, not to mention it will depend on the role they will be required to play in the team (due to injuries to other squad members), which was exactly my point about having depth in a team's goalkicking ranks...

No, you are merely stating deluded rhetoric for 2 years that you have a dozen players, even though personnel has changed, that are "capable" of kicking 20 goals, but when challenged can't name 7

Again, I don't see an issue with the Pies scoring power as a, team, moreso with whether you can keep your older forwards on the park

 

[carlton_99]

No-one is saying all those players will kick 20 goals, what is being said is, if one goes down, another is capable of taking their place.

If you want to be another obsessed with Fadge Carlton supporter, that's your choice, but it just makes you sound like dumb as dogcrap, like your mates.

My comment has nothing to do with players kicking 20 goals

 

[LoungeLizard]

My comment has nothing to do with players kicking 20 goals

I know but it was in reply to another poster that was.

But all you talk about is Fadge.

You lot are obsessed, I come to see what's going on and the thread is about Fadge with you lot, are you ashamed of Carlton or something?

 

[carlton_99]

I know but it was in reply to another poster that was.

But all you talk about is Fadge.

You lot are obsessed, I come to see what's going on and the thread is about Fadge with you lot, are you ashamed of Carlton or something?

All I talk about is Fadge? Fadge made a comment on here related to Carlton and I asked one question in response and it still hasn't been answered. That must mean I am obsessed with Fadge and ashamed of Carlton!!!

 

[Arr0w]

I know but it was in reply to another poster that was.

But all you talk about is Fadge.

You lot are obsessed, I come to see what's going on and the thread is about Fadge with you lot, are you ashamed of Carlton or something?

Prolific last off season, then go MIA

"Are you ashamed of Collingwood or something?"

 

[LoungeLizard]

All I talk about is Fadge? Fadge made a comment on here related to Carlton and I asked one question in response and it still hasn't been answered. That must mean I am obsessed with Fadge and ashamed of Carlton!!!

You go an and on about it, just like your mates.

 

[carlton_99]

You go an and on about it, just like your mates.

Go on and on about what lol. It's a discussion forum - if you aren't willing to discuss your views what's the point?

 

[Arr0w]

Started as a respectful footy discussion this morning, but pie supporters are again incapable of continuing the theme and start with playing the poster

Might just start treating them as full blown trolls

 

[Arr0w]

Using a race of people as a means to try and degrade a football club, or make them seem lesser than another, is racist.

Nice reach, is this another gotcha moment?

Try this instead, south of the border = out of the 8

 

[Robertio]

No-one is saying all those players will kick 20 goals, what is being said is, if one goes down, another is capable of taking their place.

If you want to be another obsessed with Fadge Carlton supporter, that's your choice, but it just makes you sound like dumb as dogcrap, like your mates.

Maybe you should tell Fadge not to respond to Carlton supporters if you're getting offended.

 

[carlton_99]

Nice reach

Try this instead, south of the border = out of the 8

And also is used in other sports because Cancun specifically is seen as a popular holiday destination for players when their team is knocked out of or fails to qualify for "playoffs"/finals. Has nothing to do with the people that live there. That's some sort of stretch...

 

[LoungeLizard]

Maybe you should tell Fadge not to respond to Carlton supporters if you're getting offended.

What would it matter, most of you follow him to other threads anyway, that sparrow bloke is in every thread Fadge is.

 

[carlton_99]

What would it matter, most of you follow him to other threads anyway, that sparrow bloke is in every thread Fadge is.

Is that because Fadge is in every Carlton thread? I see no issue with this either it's a public forum people can post where they want.

 

[Robertio]

What would it matter, most of you follow him to other threads anyway, that sparrow bloke is in every thread Fadge is.

Fadge is mostly in Carlton threads where there are Carlton supporters, it's all give and take and Fadgey gives as much as he takes.

 

[Fadge]

No-one is saying all those players will kick 20 goals, what is being said is, if one goes down, another is capable of taking their place.

That was never stated

So when I start with a list of players 'capable' of kicking 20 plus goals, and immediately follow up with 'It also means that if certain players go down, there are others to fill the void' to clarify for those who don't have the mental capacity to understand that I'm not for one minute suggesting ALL 12 will kick 20 plus goals... ir was never stated?

 

[Robertio]

South of the border is ok, but trying to make them sound lesser being south is racist, but I know you wouldn't or can't understand that, you don't have the brain capable.

It's not racist at all, QLD and NSW punters call us Victorians Mexicans because we live in the south.

 

[Arr0w]

So when I start with a list of players 'capable' of kicking 20 plus goals, and immediately follow up with 'It also means that if certain players go down, there are others to fill the void' to clarify for those who don't have the mental capacity to understand that I'm not for one minute suggesting ALL 12 will kick 20 plus goals... ir was never stated?

Never said you claimed 12 players WOULD kick 20 goals

I said it was a meaningless statement as it will never happen, nor is it a vital component to "team" success

Whether it's 4 or upto 8 players, each side that is likely to finish in the 8 can make a similar claim

 

[Robertio]

So when I start with a list of players 'capable' of kicking 20 plus goals, and immediately follow up with 'It also means that if certain players go down, there are others to fill the void' to clarify for those who don't have the mental capacity to understand that I'm not for one minute suggesting ALL 12 will kick 20 plus goals... ir was never stated?

A lot of those players you listed are 30 and over, they'll need replacing soon.