Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Cyclops]

Murphy a big loss for you guys during the season.

Oh awful. He played about 10cms taller than his actual height. He was always gutsy but only came into his own on kpf in 22/23, so was only important for a coupka years.

Huge loss to have a genuine lockdown fella gone to concussion. I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy.

 

[JustaBattler]

Interesting flex that you're announcing a 'return' to being an off-field powerhouse as a result of now being bracketed with 4 other clubs (including Collingwood of course) as teams who receive the minimum additional funding from the AFL.

But to be a real powerhouse, like Collingwood, you need the on-field results to match...

I'm not announcing anything - just posting a nuffie statement from a rag of paper only Collingwood posters would read- because of the "pichas"

Carlton has always and will always be THE POWERHOUSE CLUB- everyone knows this - it is why we are so hated and despised and envied

 

[adammania9]

Superior exposed form from when? Moore is a good intercept defender but very average at defending.

How can you say this after he shut down Curnow not once but twice this season?

 

[Robertio]

How can you say this after he shut down Curnow not once but twice this season?

He doesn't do it on his own, everyone knows that, good coaching by the Pies though.

 

[beerbandit]

Try focusing on 2024 mate, Weitering a class shead of Moore.

Yep I am, I see Weitering like a Darryl Wakelin type. Good and honest, not a star.

 

[beerbandit]

He doesn't do it on his own, everyone knows that, good coaching by the Pies though.

End careers now, and Moore has been the superior player. Fact.

 

[JustaBattler]

Yep I am, I see Weitering like a Darryl Wakelin type. Good and honest, not a star.

maybe lay off the beers then and get your eyes tested whilst at it.

 

[Robertio]

Yep I am, I see Weitering like a Darryl Wakelin type. Good and honest, not a star.

He holds the backline together and he has great leadership skills and rarely gets beaten one on one,

 

[JustaBattler]

How can you say this after he shut down Curnow not once but twice this season?

naaah his biggest impact was the late sideways knee into the ribcage of Petracca - that was a career-defining 'act'.

 

[beerbandit]

maybe lay off the beers then and get your eyes tested whilst at it.

Nothing wrong with a good honest type, and especially nothing wrong with a nice beer, especially on an afternoon like today.

 

[beerbandit]

He holds the backline together and he has great leadership skills and rarely gets beaten one on one,

Hence, Darryl Wakelin

 

[adammania9]

naaah his biggest impact was the late sideways knee into the ribcage of Petracca - that was a career-defining 'act'.

Not the premiership winning captain bit?

 

[Robertio]

Hence, Darryl Wakelin

Maybe, i never saw much of him so can't comment.

 

[Fadge]

I'm not announcing anything - just posting a nuffie statement from a rag of paper only Collingwood posters would read- because of the "pichas"

Carlton has always and will always be THE POWERHOUSE CLUB- everyone knows this - it is why we are so hated and despised and envied

That's hilarious.

Miles off being an on-field powerhouse, given they've been THE worst performed team in the competition for the last quarter of a century, and finally being grouped with Collingwood and a few others in relation to the minimal handouts required from the AFL.

Minnow club.

 

[Fadge]

Not the premiership winning captain bit?

Doubt they'd even realise that fact, given they usually stop watching footy in August.

 

[Fadge]

it is why we are so hated and despised and envied

I think you forgot 'pitied'.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

End careers now, and Moore has been the superior player. Fact.

One can defend, the other can dye his hair and sleeps in a different bed to his Mrs.

Do a poll of who neutrals would rather build a back line around and I'd put the house on majority saying Weitering.

 

[Fadge]

One can defend, the other can dye his hair and sleeps in a different bed to his Mrs.

Do a poll of who neutrals would rather build a back line around and I'd put the house on majority saying Weitering.

As usual....

It's not about what they've done, it's about what they're going to do in the FUTURE...

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

As usual....

It's not about what they've done, it's about what they're going to do in the FUTURE...

Weitering has been a better player of late and will continue to be.

He's 2 years younger than Daisy and doesn't rely on a recently retired Nathan Murphy to actually defend his man. He just gets it done himself.

 

[adammania9]

Doubt they'd even realise that fact, given they usually stop watching footy in August.

I believe they lasted until half time in that year’s preliminary final. A phenomenal achievement that was for the Blues

 

[Fadge]

Weitering has been a better player of late and will continue to be.

He's 2 years younger than Daisy and doesn't rely on a recently retired Nathan Murphy to actually defend his man. He just gets it done himself.

One draft year apart and have been in the system for nearly 10 years....

 

[adammania9]

The better player should have no issue catching up in AA’s and captaining a premiership in that time

 

[beerbandit]

One can defend, the other can dye his hair and sleeps in a different bed to his Mrs.

Do a poll of who neutrals would rather build a back line around and I'd put the house on majority saying Weitering.

Do a poll on who has more AA’s, and why we are at it we may as well do a poll on who has more Premierships, heck whilst we’re at it we may as well do a poll on who has hoisted more premiership cups aloft on the dias.

 

[carlton_99]

What would Pies fans talk about if it wasn't for AAs?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

One draft year apart and have been in the system for nearly 10 years....

And Daisy 'different beds' Moore still can't defend an opponent?