Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[JustaBattler]

"Con" - tenders , abacuses, and references to self serving historical periods - "modern" game -

so much spin from the dirty birders refusing to embrace their obvious mediocrity and Mexico.

oh well - they can look forward to chest puffing about a flukey win in a couple of games against an injury plagued team and Club as the high point of their reigning premiers defense

"but but but we beeach yaz"

what a comedy routine I am reading..

oh and the "we just mizzed out by a few percentages as if teh dirty birders just invented - just missing out by a few percentages as a thing...


oh and if Carlton have some injoorieeez they will lose some games and be bottom 4 for sure...from teh same bloke who reckons injooreeez are irrelevant ...

LOL

 

[JustaBattler]

LoL

The Carlton team that went 0-2 to Collingwood in 2024 would have been embarassed by even more.

Carlton under Crippa can only beat Collingwood if it is a dead rubber for the Pies.

And to help out Bagger fans, a final aint a dead rubber.

dead rubber abacus and modern game...
lol at you dirty birds and your "limited" vocab.

 

[Robertio]

Yep.

I rate the St. Kilda 2009/10 team as comfortably in the top 10 teams since the turn of the century.

Carlton's best team since the turn of the century is this current one - back to back finals qualifiers, with 2 finals wins in 2023! But this team wouldn't be in the top 150 teams we've seen since the turn of the century.

St Kilda and Collingwood down south in 2024, that's how the current situation stands.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Yep.

I rate the St. Kilda 2009/10 team as comfortably in the top 10 teams since the turn of the century.

Carlton's best team since the turn of the century is this current one - back to back finals qualifiers, with 2 finals wins in 2023! But this team wouldn't be in the top 150 teams we've seen since the turn of the century.

Imagine punching down on the Saints as desperate as it gets

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Imagine punching down on the Saints as desperate as it gets

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Ironic too considering Carlton have been the Saints bitches this century.

 

[Arr0w]

All im trying to say is, last time you won a gf, eptos wasnt invented. Only brown paper bags. With the introduction of electronic money transfers and monitoring, why havent you won a gf... brown paper bags still exist

8 to 3 still has a wonderful tone, just saying

 

[Arr0w]

The 21st century is still current.

Probability that Carlton doesn't win a premiership in the 21st century?

Let me check my abacus...

But I'll tell you as a start.... it's infinitely more probable than Collingwood not winning a premiership in the 21st century.

Ned Guys abacus?

Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton?

Until then, enjoy the tacos

 

[Fadge]

Ironic too considering Carlton have been the Saints bitches this century.

Oh no.

Carlton's record against St. Kilda since the turn of the century:
11 wins
25 losses

This includes a 12 game losing streak.

Finals Played:
Carlton - 11
St Kilda - 20

So basically St. Kilda - the team that Carlton supporters have been trying to punch down on in this thread - have been twice as good as them this century.

Oh boy.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Oh no.

Carlton's record against St. Kilda since the turn of the century:
11 wins
25 losses

This includes a 12 game losing streak.

Finals Played:
Carlton - 11
St Kilda - 20

So basically St. Kilda - the team that Carlton supporters have been trying to punch down on in this thread - have been twice as good as them this century.

Oh boy.

Didn't they win NINETEEN games in a row or something? Blues can't even finish top 4 just once

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Fadge what is the probability of a team not finishing top 4 for 24 years?

 

[Fadge]

Didn't they win NINETEEN games in a row or something? Blues can't even finish top 4 just once

Yes - 19 games in a row in 2009.

Carlton's longest winning streak this century - 9 games.

Yet another statistic that sees St. Kilda TWICE as good as Carlton since the turn of the century.

 

[Fadge]

Fadge what is the probability of a team not finishing top 4 for 24 years?

That is a very good question you ask there, Corny.

It's so unlikely, it's actually barely possible to do, particularly in this era of equalisation.

If every team starts each season with an equal chance of making top 4, there is actually less than 0.2% probability of a team not making the top 4.

But if we consider Carlton's perennial incompetence, that probability increases to 5.3%.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Oh no.

Carlton's record against St. Kilda since the turn of the century:
11 wins
25 losses

This includes a 12 game losing streak.

Finals Played:
Carlton - 11
St Kilda - 20

So basically St. Kilda - the team that Carlton supporters have been trying to punch down on in this thread - have been twice as good as them this century.

Oh boy.

So this century it's:
Head to head: Saints 25, Carlton 11
Grand finals played: Saints 2; Carlton 0
Top 4 finishes Saints 5, Carlton 0
Wooden spoons collected: Saints 1, Carlton 5.
Yeah I can see why Carlton fans feel superior to the Saints.

 

[Fadge]

So this century it's:
Head to head: Saints 25, Carlton 11
Grand finals played: Saints 2; Carlton 0
Top 4 finishes Saints 5, Carlton 1
Wooden spoons collected: Saints 1, Carlton 5.
Yeah I can see why Carlton fans feel superior to the Saints.

Correction:
Top 4 finishes Saints 5, Carlton 0

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Fadge what is the probability of a team not finishing top 4 for 24 years?

I think that level of shitness might be outside the safety parameters of Fadge's Abacus. It could lead to an explosion if he tries to run those numbers

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Correction:
Top 4 finishes Saints 5, Carlton 0

Carlton finished top 4 in 2000. Although with the salary cap roering it probably shouldn't count.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I think that level of shitness might be outside the safety parameters of Fadge's Abacus. It could lead to an explosion if he tries to run those numbers

Mining a Bitcoin would use less power

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Carlton finished top 4 in 2000. Although with the salary cap roering it probably shouldn't count.

Yes but the century began in 2001

 

[Fadge]

I think that level of shitness might be outside the safety parameters of Fadge's Abacus. It could lead to an explosion if he tries to run those numbers

Nah. My abacus can calculate anything and everything. Even that highly improbable scenario that surely couldn't possibly occur in this era of equalisation.

 

[Robertio]

Nah. My abacus can calculate anything and everything. Even that highly improbable scenario that surely couldn't possibly occur in this era of equalisation.

Who finished the highest in 2024 mate, Carlton, St Kilda or Collingwood?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Who finished the highest in 2024 mate, Carlton, St Kilda or Collingwood?

H2H?

1. Saints
2. Pies
3. Blues

 

[Fadge]

Who finished the highest in 2024 mate, Carlton, St Kilda or Collingwood?

Oh no, yet another fail for Robertio

Let's check out the teams in question respective records against one another:
1. St Kilda v Collingwood/Carlton - 2 wins, 0 losses
2. Collingwood v. St. Kilda/Carlton - 2 wins, 1 loss
3. Carlton v. Collingwood/St. Kilda - 0 wins, 3 losses

But I expect we'll get a response about moral victories, injuries, and the standard drivel.

You're not very good at this, are you?

 

[Fadge]

H2H?

1. Saints
2. Pies
3. Blues

Great minds.

Saints better than both teams in 2024.

How could we as Collingwood supporters in all good faith suggest we were better than St. Kilda, when they only finished marginally behind us, and beat us in the only match we played against them?

 

[Robertio]

H2H?

1. Saints
2. Pies
3. Blues

Only one of them made the eight but you go dream about the 21st Century and 2023 and Tim Membrey lol.

 

[Robertio]

Oh no, yet another fail for Robertio

Let's check out the teams in question respective records against one another:
1. St Kilda v Collingwood/Carlton - 2 wins, 0 losses
2. Collingwood v. St. Kilda/Carlton - 2 wins, 1 loss
3. Carlton v. Collingwood/St. Kilda - 0 wins, 3 losses

But I expect we'll get a response about moral victories, injuries, and the standard drivel.

You're not very good at this, are you?

You completely ignored my question and went your own way again, you're are crap at this and everytime you change the subject is a victory to us the underdogs.