Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Collingwood

    Votes: 60 59.4%
  • Carlton

    Votes: 41 40.6%

  • Total voters
    101

Remove this Banner Ad

Just a reminder you've been shit for the entire 21st century. I think we know what we're doing
Meanwhile at Carlton it's : "well if we have no injuries and pick 4 is another Nick Daicos and our spud small forwards suddenly stop being spuds, then we could get better. Oh and don't forget our big acquisition Nick Haynes" Get excited people!
Examples why compulsory voting in elections should be scrapped.

These people should be shipped off to Van Diemen's land.

Edit. Add that Vadge guy onto the boat also.
 
Just a reminder you've been shit for the entire 21st century. I think we know what we're doing
I hear whispers that some of the smarter dudes at Collingwood are leaving or gone already - am I Wright?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I hear whispers that some of the smarter dudes at Collingwood are leaving or gone already - am I Wright?
Frankly you could send a rat from Collingwood to Carlton and it would raise the average IQ of both. ;)

Come on Blues, you played a final last year, trolling us should be EZ. Just gotta say "we won more games and at least we played finals".

Instead you're falling over yourselves with logic fails, mucking up trying to say you'll finish higher again in 2025. We've got weird maths, and deflection, and embarrassment.

Cheer up you lot!

Wright is an excellent get. Given the power he makes smart changes. If he and Voss don't get knifed they can hammer this list of pretty boys, small game specialists and ****kickers into a team. Cripps is there, the rest can follow.

Thats the best case. The worst case is Voss (as he did at Brisbane) loves up the stars and crushes the mugs. Aside from the one leader, the rest seem emotionally volatile, or weak if you like. Only Owies dgaf, and you traded him.

We just grabbed three tough skilled warhorses. We add them to a list that has done it before. If the old blokes hobble through (and we're talking absolute professionals like Sidey and Pendles) we're top 4 and probably make the Grand Final.

Worst case? Even hurt we're a horrible ****ing prospect for any opponent, H&A or finals. Brisbane, Geelong, Melbourne, Sydney, GWS and you do not want to face us. Most of those are likely finalists.

Its undeniable: Pies look a lot better right now.
 
Don't like vadge?
not that there's anything wrong with that seinfeld GIF by myLAB Box
 
Sounds like you think they were good trades.
I don't think i gave an opinion mate but i loved a 1st and 2nd for Shultz and i can't be bothered looking up the other goose.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I didn't say i didn't have one mate i just said i didn't give one, try and keep up.
Mate. You just admitted you don't even know what the Ginnivan trade was mate. 🤡. But knowing you you'd still have an opinion on it mate.
So mate, tell us all what your opinion of Wright's decision making and negotiation skills on the Schultz trade made. Give us your opinion mate. Then we can have some kind of normal discussion about it mate.
See how that works mate?
 
Mate. You just admitted you don't even know what the Ginnivan trade was mate. 🤡. But knowing you you'd still have an opinion on it mate.
So mate, tell us all what your opinion of Wright's decision making and negotiation skills on the Schultz trade made. Give us your opinion mate. Then we can have some kind of normal discussion about it mate.
See how that works mate?
They're getting a tad feisty, don't ya reckon mate?

The new season is approaching, and I guess they realise it will be yet another year of disappointment...
 
Last edited:
Mate. You just admitted you don't even know what the Ginnivan trade was mate. 🤡. But knowing you you'd still have an opinion on it mate.
So mate, tell us all what your opinion of Wright's decision making and negotiation skills on the Schultz trade made. Give us your opinion mate. Then we can have some kind of normal discussion about it mate.
See how that works mate?
Weak comeback mate, you would've been smarter to just give up but you weren't.
 
They're getting a tad feisty, don't ya reckon mate?

The new season is approaching, and I guess the realise it will be yet another year of disappointment...
Here's uncle Fadge to the rescue.
 
Weak comeback mate, you would've been smarter to just give up but you weren't.
Mate.. you've just literally posted the weakest comeback of all time mate.

Mate if you have an opinion on the Ginnivan and Schultz trades give it to us mate. Otherwise stfu mate. You're boring everybody with pointless attempts at point scoring mate.
 
Frankly you could send a rat from Collingwood to Carlton and it would raise the average IQ of both. ;)

Come on Blues, you played a final last year, trolling us should be EZ. Just gotta say "we won more games and at least we played finals".

blah blah blah
 
Mate.. you've just literally posted the weakest comeback of all time mate.

Mate if you have an opinion on the Ginnivan and Schultz trades give it to us mate. Otherwise stfu mate. You're boring everybody with pointless attempts at point scoring mate.
Rattled lol.
 
but but but coooolingwood never eva gat anyfink wrong
Oh we do, and we have. Many times.

But our good decisions outweigh our bad ones, and we just get on with the job of regularly contending for premierships.

Unlike Carlton, who sit there and the end of each season and can never quite understand how it all went so wrong...
 
Oh we do, and we have. Many times.

But our good decisions outweigh our bad ones, and we just get on with the job of regularly contending for premierships.

Unlike Carlton, who sit there and the end of each season and can never quite understand how it all went so wrong...

get some new lines Mexican.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Back
Top