Your Club's Best 22: 1990 - 2010

[SouthSwans]

Selection can only be based within these years,
ie. For us; Gerard Healy or Kieren Jack wouldn't be available for selection as Healy finished in 1990 and Jack has just started.

Someone like Greg Williams - who only had a couple of seasons with us in the time period - would be lucky to score a spot, despite how good he was for us in the 80s.

Fire away

 

[SouthSwans]

B: Jared Crouch - Andrew Dunkley - Leo Barry
HB: Tadhg Kennelly - Craig Bolton - Mark Bayes
C: Daryn Cresswell - Brett Kirk - Stuart Maxfield
HF: Jude Bolton - Barry Hall - Wayne Schwass
F: Ryan O'Keefe - Tony Lockett - Michael O'Loughlin
Foll: Jason Ball - Adam Goodes - Paul Kelly
I/C: Darren Jolly, Greg Williams, Paul Roos, Paul Williams..

EMG: Ben Mathews, Nick Davis, Barry Mitchell.

Stiff: Nick Malceski, Nic Fosdike, Dale Lewis, Andrew Schauble, Adam Schneider, Greg Stafford, Jarrad McVeigh, Amon Buchanan, Matthew Nicks, Troy Luff, Lewis Roberts-Thomson, Brad Seymour, Peter Filandia, Daniel McPherson.

Capt: Paul Kelly
VCs: Brett Kirk & Stuart Maxfield
Coach: Paul Roos

 

[Glenno23]

B: Hart, Rutten, Bassett
HB: Goodwin, Caven, Smart
C: K.Johnson, Thompson, Bickley (VC)
HF: A.Jarman, Robran, Edwards
F: D.Jarman, Modra, Vardy
Foll: Rehn, Ricciuto (C), McLeod
Int: McGuinness, Bock, Pittman, Johncock

Might have a few players slightly out of possie, but not a bad team

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

FB: Collins - Langford - Ayres
HB: Brown - Mew - Hodge
Ce: Crawford - Mitchell - Dipper
HF: Jarman - Brereton - Buckenara
FF: Franklin - Dunstall - Hudson

Ru: Salmon
RR: Tuck
Ro: Platten

I/C: Everitt, Croad, Allan and Chick

 

[MF]

B: Hart, Rutten, Bassett
HB: Goodwin, Caven, Smart
C: K.Johnson, Thompson, Bickley (VC)
HF: A.Jarman, Robran, Edwards
F: D.Jarman, Modra, Vardy
Foll: Rehn, Ricciuto (C), McLeod
Int: McGuinness, Bock, Pittman, Johncock

Might have a few players slightly out of possie, but not a bad team

lol.

 

[MF]

FB: Collins - Langford - Ayres
HB: Brown - Mew - Hodge
Ce: Crawford - Mitchell - Dipper
HF: Jarman - Brereton - Buckenara
FF: Franklin - Dunstall - Hudson

Ru: Salmon
RR: Tuck
Ro: Platten

I/C: Everitt, Croad, Allan and Chick

That's a bloody decent team.

 

[Spider Eater]

I was thinking about the best Saints team over this time frame just the other day... should go something like this:

B: M Hudghton, J Shanahan, J Peckett
HB: A Jones, D Frawley, B Goddard
C: L Montagna, L Hayes, N Winmar
HF: N Dal Santo, S Loewe, N Riewodt
F: S Milne, T Lockett, A Hammill
Foll: P Everitt, R Harvey, N Burke
Int: F Gehrig, A Thompson, B Hall, L Ball

Emg: D Grant, G McAdam, J Smith, M Lappin

 

[mailman4]

I was thinking about the best Saints team over this time frame just the other day... should go something like this:

B: M Hudghton, J Shanahan, J Peckett
HB: A Jones, D Frawley, D Grant
C: L Montagna, L Hayes, N Winmar
HF: N Dal Santo, S Loewe, N Riewodt
F: S Milne, T Lockett, A Hammill
Foll: P Everitt, R Harvey, N Burke
Int: F Gehrig, A Thompson, L Ball, B Hall

pretty spot on but i would have thought goddard would get a gig, maybe over grant (bit young to know who he is) or ball

 

[Spider Eater]

pretty spot on but i would have thought goddard would get a gig, maybe over grant (bit young to know who he is) or ball

Your 100% right
I was bound to forget someone!
Editing will be required

 

[stmookeyj]

B: Matthew Croft, Brian Lake, Jarrod Harbrow
HB: Leon Cameron, Dale Morris, Lindsay Gilbee
C: Brad Johnson, Scott West, Rohan Smith
HF: Robert Murphy, Chris Grant, Simon Garlick
F: Paul Hudson, Luke Darcy, Nathan G Brown
R: Ben Hudson, Jose Romero, Tony Liberatore
INT: Scott Wynd, Adam Cooney, Paul Dimattina, Brett Montgomery
EM: Steven Kretiuk, Daniel Giansiracusa, Doug Hawkins

Also in the mix: Simon Atkins, Adam Cooney, Ryan Griffen, Matthew Boyd, Daniel Cross, Craig Ellis, Todd Curley, James Cook, Steve Wallis
Considered for anti-team of period: Peter Quill, Sedat Sir
Not considered due to length of time with club: Barry Hall, Tony McGuinness, Nicky Winmar, Terry Wallace
Not considered due to injury: Mark West
Not considered for reasons beyond my control: Jason Akermanis

 

[Glenno23]

lol.

Caven was an excellent CHB, just as Bock was. Could swap and be happy.

 

[Claude Balls]

This will be out of Geelong and West Coast

 

[liam_13]

b: blakey, martyn, archer
hb: king, colbert
c: harvey, stevens, bell
hf: grant, carey, pickett
f: c.sholl, longmire
foll: mckernan, simpson, rawlings
bench: allison, wells, petrie,

coach: denis pagan

late so i cant think or decide of the last 2

 

[el nino]

FB: G. Wanganeen - D. Fletcher - M. Harvey
HB: D. Hardwick - S. Wellman - M. Thompson
Ce: M. Long - J. Misiti - C. Heffernan
HF: J. Hird - S. Lucas - T. Watson
FF: D. Berwick - M. Lloyd - M. Mercuri

Ru: P. Salmon
RR: J. Johnson
Ro: G. O'Donnell

Int: S. Alessio, J . Watson, M. Johnson, B. Carracella

Pretty much a combination of the 90-93 & 99-01 sides.

 

[Sin City]

B: McKay Silvagni Ratten
HB: Gibbs Sexton Dean
C: Murphy Williams Camporeale
HF: Koutoufides Kernahan Lappin
F: Betts Fevola Whitnall
FOLL: Madden Bradley Judd
INT: Hanna Brown Stevens Kreuzer/Allan
EMG: Scotland Carrazzo Christou

 

[roomachine]

B: Archer, Martyn, Blakey
HB: King, Petrie, Pickett
C: Schwass, Simpson, Scholl
HF: Grant, Carey, Crocker
F: McAdam, Longmire, Harvey
R: McKernan, Stevens, Bell

Int: Rawlings, Smith, Allison, Abraham

That side would beat most sides of the last 20 years.

 

[omit]

B: S Febey, Frawley, Whelan
HB: Lovett ,Ingerson, Rivers
C: Tingay, J Mcdonald, Bruce
HF: Yze, Schwartz, Jackovich
F: Farmer, Nietz, Lyon

R: Stynes, Viney (c), Leoncelli
I: Wowoedin, Green , White, Robertson


rather weak down back. there's some serious power up front though. I couldn't find a place for Robbo or Green on the field. and no surprise that most players are from the 98 & 00 sides.

 

[MF]

b: blakey, martyn, archer
hb: king, colbert
c: harvey, stevens, bell
hf: grant, carey, pickett
f: c.sholl, longmire
foll: mckernan, simpson, rawlings
bench: allison, wells, petrie,

coach: denis pagan

late so i cant think or decide of the last 2

Schwatta has to in there.

 

[SouthSwans]

B: S Febey, Frawley, Whelan
HB: Lovett ,Ingerson, Walsh

Jesus, is that really the Dees' best backline in 20 years?

 

[omit]

Jesus, is that really the Dees' best backline in 20 years?

my knowledge of the early 90's Dees isn't that great so it's possible I'm forgetting a player or two but yeah.

I guess Bizzell and Rivers could probably get in there... doesn't make things look much better though.

Edit: will change to include Rivers and/or Bizzell

 

[HugeJohnson]

B: Michael Wilson, Darryl Wakelin, Gavin Wanganeen
HB: Adam Kingsley, Chad Cornes, Brett Montgomery
C: Nick Stevens, Domenic Cassisi, Stuart Dew
HF: Peter Burgoyne, Warren Tredrea, Shaun Burgoyne
F: Brett Ebert, Scott Hodges, Byron Pickett
R: Matthew Primus, Roger James, Tim Ginever
Int: Brendan Lade, Josh Francou, Kane Cornes, Stephen Paxman

 

[SouthSwans]

my knowledge of the early 90's Dees isn't that great so it's possible I'm forgetting a player or two but yeah.

I guess Bizzell and Rivers could probably get in there... doesn't make things look much better though.

This would be my team;

B: G.Yeats - A.Ingerson - M.Whelan
HB: C.Bruce - J.Frawley - S.Febey
C: B.Green - J.McDonald - S.Woewodin
HF: J.Farmer - D.Schwartz - A.Jackovich
F: R.Robertson - D.Neitz - G.Lyon
Foll: J.Stynes - A.Leoncelli - Viney
I/C: J.White, S.Tingay, A.Yze, B.Lovett

 

[SouthSwans]

B: Michael Wilson, Darryl Wakelin, Gavin Wanganeen
HB: Adam Kingsley, Chad Cornes, Brett Montgomery
C: Domenic Cassisi, Josh Carr, Stuart Dew
HF: Peter Burgoyne, Warren Tredrea, Shaun Burgoyne
F: Brett Ebert, Scott Hodges, Byron Pickett
R: Matthew Primus, Roger James, Kane Cornes
Int: Brendan Lade, Josh Francou, Damien Hardwick, Stephen Paxman

No Roger James? No Nick Stevens? No Scotty Cummings?

 

[HugeJohnson]

No Roger James? No Nick Stevens? No Scotty Cummings?

Roger James is in there, forgot Nick Stevens, Probably replace him with Carr, and I don't think Scott Cummings did enough at Port to warrant selection. Scott Hodges was far better than him anyway.

 

[Quinz]

FB: Wirrpanda - McIntosh - Brennan
HB: McKenna - Jakovich - Worsfold (C)
C: Mainwaring - Kemp - Matera
HF: Heady - White - Lewis
FF: Evans - Sumich - Matera
R: Cox - Judd - Cousins
IC: Waterman - Banfield - Pyke - Lamb

That was the offical Team 20 picked in 2006.

Not too many changes I would think from that side. LeCras in the forward line, maybe hasn't played enough games. Kerr would be pushing a spot on the bench at least, Embley, Glass, Braun unlucky.

Super team though, HB line and midfield especially.