Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. M

    Travis Cloke is not Chris Tarrant, stop turning him into Chris!

    At 19, Travis Cloke: Blazes away when he gets a kick, never looks up just wheels onto the left boot and tries to kick the cover off it. Too regularly doesn't play in front or provide enough of a contest. I know he is 19, but geez I hope he gets a lot better than what he is now. Can he...
  2. M

    Favourite Collingwood player???

    Tarrant, oops i mean Didak.
  3. M

    Is Chris Judd The Best Ever???

    I dont think he is as great as what everyone says he is. i so often see him get a clearance n kick it out to the wing wen embley is on a lead and the opposing player is right on his hammer . He panics wen he gets the ball under pressure. great Players like nathan buckley can find a loose target...
  4. M

    Top 5 since 1996

    Buckley is certainly not a reciever..... he won the hardball gets 4 the pies in 2003. thats a very big call........ buckleys skills are immaculate, harvey has won two brownlows, however, both of them were won due to suspension of in 96 chris grant and in 97 corey mckernan. Plenty people are...
  5. M

    Top 5 since 1996

    heres my opinion 1 Nathan Buckley 2 James Hird 3 Michael Voss 4 Robert Harvey 5 Simon Black Nathan Buckley coz the guy averages over 25 possesion a game, averages more ranking points than any of the others in the herald sun, most consistent, fantastic ball winner, can kick a goal...
  6. M

    2005 Melbourne Cup

    1. The Diva 2. Eye Popper 3. Strasbourg
  7. M

    Collingwood Magpies: Midseason Review 2005:

    Johnson#26 don't give Buckley an E. Give him an NA (Not Assessed)
  8. M

    Who to axe?

    This thread comes up every 2 or 3 weeks. Over it.
  9. M

    Are AFL Umpires the worst officials in the world?

    What leagues are these? Definitely not the Mornington Peninsula League.
  10. M

    Team vs Geelong

    In: Woewodin Out: Rusling Fanning gives a contest, give him a go. Cloke seems to do very little when on the ground, same with Tex, both just get in the way. They need plenty of time down at Willy to try and work out what a ruckman/ key position player is meant to do.
  11. M

    Is Caracella the suprise packet of 2005?

    Our recruiting has been first rate this year, all players showing some promise. I reckon Caracella will get worse as we get better. When Rocca, Tarrant and Didak are all firing, Caracella might be kicking 1 or 2 a game. Then again I've got no problems with him kicking 4 or 5 every week but...
  12. M

    New club crest?

    We've changed our logo about 10 times over the last 100 years. So don't worry about tradition.
  13. M

    Will Tarrant be traded?

    Deal.
  14. M

    Dane Swan

    Have to question that. Saw him back away from a couple of contests right in front of me against Richmond. You don't neccessarily have to be hard nut to be agood footballer but you need some sort of weapon if your going to be like that, he doesn't seem to have one.
  15. M

    What A Great Weekend

    And Rhyce Shaw won Lou's Handball on the Sunday Footy Show!!
  16. M

    Who should go at the end of the year?

    If these guys create such depth, then why are we sitting on the bottom of the ladder? From what I hear C.Cloke has caused a bit of trouble down there so I think it would be a good thing to see the back of his fat ****.
  17. M

    Who should go at the end of the year?

    Clearly this can't happen I'm just dreaming.
  18. M

    Who should go at the end of the year?

    Don't worry about contracts, list numbers salary caps, just who does everyone think shouldn't be playing for us next year? My thoughts- These should be certainties to leave: O'Bree, Walker, Lonie, J.Cloke, Cole, Davis,Swan, Lokan, Williams. Trade bait: Tarrant, Woewodin, Didak, C.Cloke...
  19. M

    Sean Russling

    Think that might be a little optimistic considering he hasn't even played a game, we don't even know for sure what position he will be playing and full forwards rarely kick massive bags of goals like the Dunstall, Ablett, Lockett days. I just hope when he gets to the top level he makes a contest.
  20. M

    make tarrant captain

    No way that Carlton would be stupid enough to do that. Fevola's much more damaging and also has a much better all round game than Tarrant. Fevola's a great kick and great mark- what a full forward should be.
  21. M

    Did Rivers get a Rising star Nomination??

    Worst topic ever.
  22. M

    Lovett>>Davey

    Clearly Davey is better. Although Lovett won the Anzac medal, Davey is better, knows how to kick goals, is lightning quick and puts more pressure on the opposition with tackling than Lovett. Davey also has the ability to do the freakish things when he gets the ball more than Lovett.
  23. M

    Can Collingwood beat Richmond?

    Richmond are widely known for getting way too ahead of themselves at about this stage of the season. In the past few years they have gotten off to flyers only to lose the plot at about this time of the year. There's nothing better than when all of their fair weather supporters come out of the...
  24. M

    has malthouse lost the players?

    I must admit that thought has crossed me many times. Maybe his thoeries are getting old and maybe he has lost a few of the players but how are we meant to know? A coach that has coached over 500 games must have a fair clue about how footy works. I think we've got to give him every chance. See...
  25. M

    Total Horror

    There should be some sort of written apology on the official website from either the president, the coach or one of the players after that performance. Get your act together Collingwood.
  26. M

    Chris Tarrant

    No side in the AFL would be able to win a Grand Final with a full forward that can't kick goals. I think Chris Tarrant is an excellent footballer but he just doesn't kick enough goals. I know alot of people will say he has two or three to beat at every contest but the good forwards can still put...
Back
Top