Player Watch #11: Jason Castagna - signed to 2023

Should Castagna be dropped for the Port game after his 2 disposal effort vs the Swans?

  • Yes - for Cumberland

  • Yes - for anyone

  • No

  • Make him Sub


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Because he has been a butcher for 10 years and is a selfish player.
He causes stress to supporters and his constant goal misses demoralise the team.
Doesnt matter what he does on the field its not him selecting himself to play in the seniors
We have 5 coaches that form the match committee tht select the club and are responsible for the Role any player plays and if he is doing whats asked then they select him and if he is not he gets dropped.

But i do believe there is way too much personal insults on some players both at the ground and also on forums
If Castagna's kicking was not so shocking he would have clubs chasing him as a free agent but looks like impossible to improve after this time and will most likely be finished at AFL level after his contract is finished in 2023 with Sonsie , Clarke , MRj , Cumberland and possibly Stack developing and taking over his position.

So lets just keep our cool and stay classy to a player thats represented the club nearly 150 times and has been apart of our dynasty
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I’m anonymous.. you’re anonymous. Jason Castanga isn’t . He got booed on the weekend but you still felt the need to have a cheap nasty crack at him on here .
Why ?

Great thing this internet.
You can be anonymous.
You can even be someone, tell everyone who you are, and then deny it later on ;);):D:D
The web is amazing and fulfils wishes and dreams.

PS People pointing out JC's flaws and shortcomings on here has as much relevance to him getting booed at a game as those pumping his tyres up have in people choosing to cheer him.
The longest of bows.
 
This thread is a ******* disgrace. Shame on the mods for allowing this to happen.

Sterge

Report posts that break the rules we dont read every thread. Especially ones about sub standard players

Side note saying a player is not good doesnt break the rules.

Side side note we have 4 mods.....
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Guess we know where the mods stand on bagging out our players then 👍 awesome.

As long as it is a discussion and you arent abusing each other or going over the top then play on.

Its a discussion forum not everyone will agree with you. Not everything in life is sunshine and rainbows.

But once again report anything you think is over the top and we will deal with it.

Or as others suggested use the ignore function.
 
I always have a bit of a giggle at the overcritical posters, who bag out their own players...just check out there join dates. someting fishy for sure. :D
View attachment 1479849
I joined way before that, I had to get a new user name. Don't waste your time scrolling through other people's info old timer.
 
When you look at the all thr small forwards in histry
I joined way before that, I had to get a new user name. Don't waste your time scrolling through other people's info old timer.

Let him do it .... if he spent half his time developing an argument on why Castagna was good, we'd all be enlightened.
 
I always have a bit of a giggle at the overcritical posters, who bag out their own players...just check out there join dates. someting fishy for sure. :D
View attachment 1479849
Maybe you should harrass people on the 'life after Hardwick' thread who want a new coach.
Jase is a spud champ.
 
Maybe you should harrass people on the 'life after Hardwick' thread who want a new coach.
Jase is a spud champ.
i took your advice and flicked thru it the other day. good for you sticking fat with dimma but he's the coach and he has jase in our best 25 at the moment so thats good enough for me. you need to let a man who breathes the same air, sees their effort and commitment and smells his players sweat for up to 20/30 hours a week before you think you know better than him champ.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch #11: Jason Castagna - signed to 2023

Back
Top