After I posted that I checked and you're correct. For sure some will survive. It will be a nerve wracking time.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Traded #18 Jacob Konstanty
- Thread starter SwansProudly
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Konstanty's manager, Dave Trotter from Hemisphere Management Group, said this to Gettable:
"We'll sit down with the club after the season. He doesn’t know his future at the moment. He might still have a spot at Sydney. Sydney's got a very strong list and they don't have a lot of list spots, in terms of they want to bring a few players in through the draft and they don't have many guys out of contract.
"I think if it wasn't Sydney, he's got a couple of clubs that really liked him in his draft year. There's not many players who are pick No.20, a great kid, super competitive … if you've got those traits, I'd hope that if it wasn't at the Swans – which he hopes it is – then I'd hope he ends up somewhere."
Giant lands new deal, Dees eye delisted Saint, in-demand Dog gets offer
Check out all the latest trade news from around the Leaguewww.afl.com.au
Being Pick 20 doesn't mean a lot.
Especially when you consider that Pick 20 over the past decade has included names such as Sam Philp, Riley Collier-Dawkins, Callum Coleman-Jones and Jack Leslie.
- Mar 29, 2019
- 3,462
- 10,170
- AFL Club
- Sydney
He sure made an impression on one person…
I've never believed the "best available" story. It has so many caveats attached as to be fairly meaningless. Pretty sure we had decided that Ronke had hit his ceiling and we needed a replacement and Konstanty looked a good bet at our pick. And he did look a good bet. Just hasn't worked out. Could have kept Ronke and taken Weddle or even Jones. Sliding doors moment.
Callipygian
Team Player
- May 18, 2021
- 2,077
- 4,769
- AFL Club
- Sydney
I agree that they overstate the best available and needs are taken into account.
However, not all players are equally available to all clubs. Some players make it clear they don't want to go interstate etc - GWS were quite clear about this after the draft (last year, I think). Who knows what the deal was with Weddle. In hindsight though it's clear he was the better pick (but so was Darcy Jones who fit the same need and played small forward).
Just on Jones, there was talk that we knew the Giants were interested in Konstanty and so swept in the pick before them and nabbed him before they could get to him. But GWS denied that and said Jones was their guy all along. They have been vindicated because, despite also having his last year wiped out by injury, Jones has been an absolute ripper.
[Incidentally, after we faced them in the QF I was thinking which Giants players I would want to have and, in order, I came up with: 1. Taylor 2. Green 3. Jones 4. Callahan. Not saying they're their best players, I have weighted for age and need. But it gives you some indication how much I would value having Jones in our team.]
However, not all players are equally available to all clubs. Some players make it clear they don't want to go interstate etc - GWS were quite clear about this after the draft (last year, I think). Who knows what the deal was with Weddle. In hindsight though it's clear he was the better pick (but so was Darcy Jones who fit the same need and played small forward).
Just on Jones, there was talk that we knew the Giants were interested in Konstanty and so swept in the pick before them and nabbed him before they could get to him. But GWS denied that and said Jones was their guy all along. They have been vindicated because, despite also having his last year wiped out by injury, Jones has been an absolute ripper.
[Incidentally, after we faced them in the QF I was thinking which Giants players I would want to have and, in order, I came up with: 1. Taylor 2. Green 3. Jones 4. Callahan. Not saying they're their best players, I have weighted for age and need. But it gives you some indication how much I would value having Jones in our team.]
Jones is a perfect complement to Papley in age and development. Konstanty would have and may yet be. It ain't science.
grimlock
Hall of Famer
Farewell Jacob. We'll always have Mad Monday wrestling.
The King!
Chosen One
Had an impact on our leadership
Ashes to ashes
Round 1 to Steak Knives
Round 1 to Steak Knives
How many Birds did we lose in that trade?
better steak than crap south market dimmies
Move over Lingy & Dylan - there’s a new king of first round busts.
Are you still here?
Tried not to , i hate those so called dimmies and so does Jacob
TheGoatBaron
Bigfooty’s Head Shake Officer
- Jan 4, 2010
- 18,059
- 9,156
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Port Melb, Eintracht Frankfurt.
They are shit , rather get the Chin Wahs at Andrews Hamburgers
- Oct 14, 2016
- 3,011
- 3,753
- AFL Club
- Sydney
It was flocks of them.
That hurts
Konstanty was not the Dawson pick. It was our own pick for 2022. The Dawson trade tree is still active in Grundy and the future first round pick we got from North last year for this years draft. Only Vickery is no longer active from that pick.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
