2009 Trade Discussion Part 9

[footycool]

Get the guns in footycool!! You can do it!

I reckon only NGB could outscore Pav for the price. What a risk that would be lol

Sip>Pav DONE!!

 

[Drummond]

Trading out Higgins and Chapman.

Which two should I get...

Brown, Didak or Davis?

 

[hedgehog]

Why not get Callum Wilson and Swan?

Already got him. I'm going to do it anyway.

 

[Pumbi]

Just traded in Brad Johnson for Chapman. Sigh, zero trades left.

 

[samwise]

gonna go purgoyne to wilson and lovett to didak
next week suban to enright then 1 trade left with the worst player being haselby/mundy instead of worst player being just mundy..i hate injuries they always ruin your plans. ah well at least im only 0/1 this week...with suban, wilson, anthony and pearce in so more like 0/2.5

 

[Michael Scarn]

higgins for stevie j, john brown or leon. i'm leaning towards stevie. thoughts?

 

[bones25]

Gee its rather quiet in here, 5 days without a post, guess everyone has run out of trades

I have 1 left and I am going to hang on to it until it gets ripped out of my hands by a threatening donut.

 

[LemmingMaster]

higgins for stevie j, john brown or leon. i'm leaning towards stevie. thoughts?

I'm not 100% sure that SJ is fit at the moment and could be rested before the finals. I would probably lean towards the other two options, just for a little more safety.

 

[Oscarman]

Gee its rather quiet in here, 5 days without a post, guess everyone has run out of trades

I have 1 left and I am going to hang on to it until it gets ripped out of my hands by a threatening donut.

I reckon last week would have put plenty right out of 'em. I've got 2 and will be using 1 for the prelim, and should I get through, 1 for the GF. That being said, my priority for this year was and still is overall position. I'm at 1074 ATM and pretty keen to finish in 3 figures.

 

[Narkee]

Yeh I have 2 left also.

Made the prelim in the league that counts so going to wait until next week to make my last forward upgrade of Brown to Voldt!

 

[Cynic]

Two left buck Bock may cost me one

(On another note not trading Bock instead of Fisher last week is looking really bad )

 

[thommus]

If you could pick any midfielder (bar Tuck, Sewell, Swan, Kornes, Gibbs, Anthony) who would it be? It's tougher than you may think.

Also same question for defenders (bar Goddard, Mundy, Carazzo, Grimes, Hill, Lockyer, Houlihan, Broughton)?

 

[hedgehog]

If you could pick any midfielder (bar Tuck, Sewell, Swan, Kornes, Gibbs, Anthony) who would it be? It's tougher than you may think.

Also same question for defenders (bar Goddard, Mundy, Carazzo, Grimes, Hill, Lockyer, Houlihan)?

Ablett and Broughton.

 

[thommus]

Oops sorry forgot to mention I already have Broughton. Who would it be after him? And really Ablett? Got sydney to play this week and hasn't been in the best of form as of late..

 

[Decipher]

Selwood - Been in solid form.
Backs - Why are you trading? Goddard, Mundy, Carazzo, Broughton, Lockyer, Houlian and hill seems a fairly solid backline to me IMO. But if your looking to trade out ol Grimesy then I would look at probably Enright or Embley

 

[thommus]

Cheers Decipher. I would only trade Grimes out if Goddard doesn't play this week, going for a league win. I too was thinking Embley. What can you tell me about his form of late being a West Coast supporter?

Also, you wouldn't prefer Montagna over Selwood? Selwood is undoubtedly a good pick, however Montagna's form before his refreshing week off is nuts! Thoughts?

 

[footycool]

No one really commenting, NO TRADES!

 

[strung_out7]

1 trade left which will most like be used to go cross to swandive.

if cross is only a 1 weeker then maybe anthony to scot thompson and play sheldon for a week.

then there is sj tho so i might need it there.

 

[rOdGe]

Hey guys which combo sounds better here...

Mcglynn
Duffield

or

Ar.Davey
Newman

 

[Notorious_29]

Hey guys which combo sounds better here...

Mcglynn
Duffield

or

Ar.Davey
Newman

Mcglynn and Duffield for me. Especially in finals, they can both pull out big 100's, newman and davey are the more consistent types of players who would also be good options.

 

[rOdGe]

Mcglynn and Duffield for me. Especially in finals, they can both pull out big 100's, newman and davey are the more consistent types of players who would also be good options.

Cheers mate. Sorry to be annoying but would Lecras be a better option than mcglynn?

 

[bombers own]

Using my last 2 trades

Mid-Swan, Ablett, Bartel, Gibbs, Cross, Stanton
Def-Goddard, Fisher, Mackie, Milburn, Newman, Drummond, Grimes

Option 1
Grimes-->Any back
Cross-->Montagna
Keep Milburn

Option 2
Milburn-->Any Back
Cross-->Hayes/Corey
Keep Grimes

Which one should i take? And which players should i bring in?

 

[bones25]

Using my last 2 trades

Mid-Swan, Ablett, Bartel, Gibbs, Cross, Stanton
Def-Goddard, Fisher, Mackie, Milburn, Newman, Drummond, Grimes

Option 1
Grimes-->Any back
Cross-->Montagna
Keep Milburn

Option 2
Milburn-->Any Back
Cross-->Hayes/Corey
Keep Grimes

Which one should i take? And which players should i bring in?

You have no backup for Cross? Also it depends if your going for overall position finish or league.
I personally wouldn't be blowing you last 2 trades just yet, unless you are going to cop a donut this week.

 

[Jars458]

need to trade Bock as already have Grimes on the outer.

Probably go Lockyear or maybe Duffield?

 

[bombers own]

You have no backup for Cross? Also it depends if your going for overall position finish or league.
I personally wouldn't be blowing you last 2 trades just yet, unless you are going to cop a donut this week.

Oh yeah, i have DeBoer and Swift as mid cover, Cheney and Petrenko backs, but i thought Cross was out for the rest of the home and away season?

Ill almost definitely cop a back zero, so ill have no choice there, and Hayes and Montagna are so damn tempting, given the quality of their opposition over the next three rounds.

So who will be out for the longest out of Milburn and Grimes?