2015 Draft, Trade & Free Agent Discussion & Speculation Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
We are more unlikely than likely given our strong preference towards a 'no dickheads' policy. If we didn't touch darling or dayle garlett we won't touch Bennell. I can imagine hawthorn or Richmond going for him though

We don't have a "no dickheads" policy. No club does. And Lyon is on record saying he'd love to have Bennell at Freo.
 
Probably a bit late but why exactly are we in a rebuild if Pav and McPharlin retire? We just finished first on the ladder. If we get Schultz and find another key defender we may even be better next year. Let's remember Schultz kicked more goals than Pav and had worse supply...

Exactly. Pav is not the powerhouse he once was, and we are still top of the ladder. If we can acquire a decent enough key forward for next season then there's no reason we couldn't finish on top again.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Ideal trade period:

Bennell for next years 1st pick + Duffield

McCarthy for 1st pick this year + Clarke

Schulz for 3rd round pick

Puts us in the place for another real crack next year:
 
Would be stoked if this happened.

1st rounder - Draft best available
2nd rounder - Jetta
3rd rounder - Schulz
Upgrade - Ballard
Rookie - Bootsma
Wouldn't have thought we draft bootsma if you want to waste a rookie spot miles well get Brendon's jones as reward for service or I've heard Garrick McLaughlin has been tearing it up in the reserves
 
Would be stoked if this happened.

1st rounder - Draft best available
2nd rounder - Jetta
3rd rounder - Schulz
Upgrade - Ballard
Rookie - Bootsma

Cannot see us rookie listing Bootsma but that is just my opinion, rookie to someone like Marcus Adams as a backup forward seems better.
Also we need to take three in the draft so that would mean picking up a 4th rounder as well.

I am mixed about Schulz. We get him it allows Pav and McPharlin to play bit parts next year or not at all if they retire/get injured. We have coverage in defence with Silvagni and AP and Shculz would play up forward with Tabs if Pav is not around or rested. I just would not like to see Tabs's development hindered and obviously Schulz is only going to be a two year prospect. Also Schulz is a great kick for goal - how does he go in contested marking with our tendency to bomb it in hope versus hitting up the leading forward?
 
Ideal trade period:

Bennell for next years 1st pick + Duffield

McCarthy for 1st pick this year + Clarke

Schulz for 3rd round pick

Puts us in the place for another real crack next year:
Problem would be too good of a draft period. I swear everytime a club "kills it" during trade week they end up not meeting expectations the following year. It's like the players read the paper too and think it's just going to happen now the calvary has arrived.
 
Would also really like hooker, I think there is going to a mass exit from the Essendon players so would come cheap or even for free if bombers fold which I see as an outside chance of happening
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Emotional, physical or both?
I'd like to arrange for Freo's mental health medical officer (or whoever is filling that role) to talk to Gold Coast's matching pair, with Harley's blessing, to discuss in confidence what Harley has been working through and what needs to be done to continue that care if he would like to come to Freo.

Then without putting his issues on the table for everyone to see the mental health officer can give the thumbs up or down on whether we can work with him.
 
I
I'd like to arrange for Freo's mental health medical officer (or whoever is filling that role) to talk to Gold Coast's matching pair, with Harley's blessing, to discuss in confidence what Harley has been working through and what needs to be done to continue that care if he would like to come to Freo.

Then without putting his issues on the table for everyone to see the mental health officer can give the thumbs up or down on whether we can work with him.

I think the few months between now and November are important for Harley. Was about 12 weeks that Walters was banished to sort himself out wasn't it? How many weeks til the draft?
 
I think the few months between now and November are important for Harley. Was about 12 weeks that Walters was banished to sort himself out wasn't it? How many weeks til the draft?

It's the 27th November so about that time.
 
I think we suffer from a general perception in the AFL that our window is closing after this year, which is why some players spurn us. That and perhaps some prefer the more open, high scoring, style of play that WC and Port go for (as a forward you would probably prefer it).

Not sure how Bennell will go out West. He is likely to have more bad seeds around him over in Perth always nagging him to head out on the town, snuff a few lines etc. Frustrating to see all these players go to competitors though.

Just win the bloody premiership Ross. Then we will be so drunk for the next year we won´t care.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top