List Mgmt. 2015 Trade, Draft, Rookie Draft and FA Megathread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
1. Parkin asking BS about Rice

2. Parkin asking BS about update on Treloar. In which BS didn't screenshot any response!

There, done, no need for a PM. You're welcome
 

Log in to remove this ad.

From JD06 on Blitz

Richmond and Carlton at loggerheads over Yarran.

On that, could we see a successful 4 club trade:

Saints Trade Pick 5 + 24, Get Carlisle + Pick 12
Carlton Trade Yarran, Get Pick 24
Richmond Trade Pick 12 + 31, Get Pick 23 and Yarran
Essendon Trade Pick 23 + Carlisle, Get Pick 5 + 31
 
From JD06 on Blitz

Richmond and Carlton at loggerheads over Yarran.

On that, could we see a successful 4 club trade:

Saints Trade Pick 5 + 24, Get Carlisle + Pick 12
Carlton Trade Yarran, Get Pick 24
Richmond Trade Pick 12 + 31, Get Pick 23 and Yarran
Essendon Trade Pick 23 + Carlisle, Get Pick 5 + 31
Your not getting pick 5 thank you come again
 
From JD06 on Blitz

Richmond and Carlton at loggerheads over Yarran.

On that, could we see a successful 4 club trade:

Saints Trade Pick 5 + 24, Get Carlisle + Pick 12
Carlton Trade Yarran, Get Pick 24
Richmond Trade Pick 12 + 31, Get Pick 23 and Yarran
Essendon Trade Pick 23 + Carlisle, Get Pick 5 + 31
Carlton would be screaming murder and so would we.
 
Last edited:
Is it worth trying to weasel our way into the Aish deal while Collingwood are at loggerheads with GWS? If Collingwood have to give up 2 first round picks they don't have a lot to throw at Brisbane.

Matthews has stated Aish won't be traded, but he'd be silly not to take pick 5 for him.

Pick 5 for Aish and 17. 17 then used in a deal with Carlisle. Of course Aish has to agree to it but surely he's rather the Saint over Carlton...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

He's walking around Thailand for a month, literally, as we speak. Good bloke old mate Spence.

I don't know if you are being sarcastic but I like young Spence. I hope he finds something that makes him happy in life.
 
Treloar eh?


How about:

Ess get - Plowman, Pick 16,
Ess give - Carlisle, Pick 25

GWS get - Pick 5, 2016 1st (St Kilda), Pick 24, Pick 25
GWS give - Treloar, Pick 16 (via Freo - McCarthy), Plowman, Pick 47

St K get - Treloar, Carlisle, Pick 47
St K give - Pick 5, Pick 24, 2016 1st

GWS lose 3 players who all want out...still go to the draft with 5, 8, 24, 25, 27 plus 2016 1st Round (St Kilda)
Essendon lose Carlisle (who could go via PSD) and get Pick 16 & Plowman for Pick 25
We give away 2 x 1st rounders & 25, but get Treloar & Carlisle.

Means we'd definitely need to trade out a player or 2, to secure both Rice & Freeman & make 2 selections at the draft.
 
Treloar eh?


How about:

Ess get - Plowman, Pick 16,
Ess give - Carlisle, Pick 25

GWS get - Pick 5, 2016 1st (St Kilda), Pick 24, Pick 25
GWS give - Treloar, Pick 16 (via Freo - McCarthy), Plowman, Pick 47

St K get - Treloar, Carlisle, Pick 47
St K give - Pick 5, Pick 24, 2016 1st

GWS lose 3 players who all want out...still go to the draft with 5, 8, 24, 25, 27 plus 2016 1st Round (St Kilda)
Essendon lose Carlisle (who could go via PSD) and get Pick 16 & Plowman for Pick 25
We give away 2 x 1st rounders & 25, but get Treloar & Carlisle.

Means we'd definitely need to trade out a player or 2, to secure both Rice & Freeman & make 2 selections at the draft.
If we could give up next years second instead I would be all over that, but I think it would still be worth doing even if it was 2 firsts.
 
First ive heard of the the treloar rumours and tbh don't think there is too many legs to it. Wouldn't get too excited yet.

His preference from my understanding coming from people very close to him is collingwood then carlton, can't stand richmond. I would be very surprised if we managed to land him. But anything could happen I guess.
 
I think the club will not be wasting there time on players we have no hope of getting like Treloar. We need to spend all our time on players we think we can get like Freeman and Carlisle. Those 2 would be a great trading period. Not to fussed about Rice. Seems like a normal third round pick who like most picks around that number have less than 50% chance to make it.
 
I'm all for Rice nominating us but i think someone needs to sit him down first and have an honest chat.
tumblr_inline_n2nnt9cDBy1rvpdg2.gif
 
not sure whats happening any more, so Rice Has chosen us.... Whos the other person that we are excited about, that everyone wants a pm over.... PM me if needed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top