Prediction 2017 Free Agency & Trading - go to the Gibbs thread if you wish to discuss Gibbs!!!

Who do you think the Crows will get during the 2017 trade period?


  • Total voters
    111
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's a match made in heaven for Port. Will kick goals when they're pantsing a dud team at home. Awol the rest of the time.

I'd actually put a sneaky wager on both Menzels being at Port next year.
Troy is Contracted next season right? Yeah I would trade him to Port. I like Riley Bonner, although he will likely be sitting behind Smith and Laird as attacking defenders just like Wigg. I used to like Toumpass in his draft year, but he seems like a poormans Mackay these days.... And that's not the player you want to be the poorman's version of
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Funny you say that I've heard both Montagna today and Reiwoldt a few weeks ago on AFL Nation with Pete Donegan both speak in glowing terms of Ross Lyon in his time at the Saints, I think it might just be a public perception thing.
Montagna & Riewoldt weren't getting started under Lyon. They were already well established players when he was appointed. Lyon loves senior players, and will select a senior player over a kid every day of the week.
 
Montagna & Riewoldt weren't getting started under Lyon. They were already well established players when he was appointed. Lyon loves senior players, and will select a senior player over a kid every day of the week.
Haven't been watching Freo this year??
 
Why not post it, we know its a rumour you have heard, it's not like you have said it's concrete from a source, that is understandable to leave out but in the case you may as well post it? If it turns out to be in the news you posted a relevant rumour and if not then nothing lost.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Have you seen the way people with info get treated around here? If I ever had info I'd be keeping it to myself just in case it didnt come to fruition.
Post it as a rumour you've heard, not stating that it's fact, and it's treated accordingly.

Post it as something you've heard from a connection with the club, and you get treated much more harshly if it turns out to be false.

Then there are ****wits like Sanders and Brentmeister...
 
As unlikely as it is I would take Sidebottom every day of the week, beautiful skills, strong hands and tough as well, would slip in to our midfield straight away.
 
He's been forced to play the kids this year, dragged kicking & screaming to the selection table, where a gun was (proverbially) pointed at his head.


What a load of tosh, Played 1st year Ruckman Sean Darcy when he could have played Johno Griffin, played 1st year defenders Brennan Cox and Griffin Logue when he could have played Zac Dawson and Garrick Ibbotson, played Harley Balic when he could have played Nick Suban, blooded Ryan Nyhuis, Brady Grey, Josh Deluca, Ethan Hughes etc.

Players that would have been locks in previous Lyon's sides Danyle Pearce, Cameron Sutcliffe, Matt Taberner, Tom Sheridan etc have had serious WAFL time when fit for AFL selection.

Ross Lyon "dragged kicking and screaming to the selection table with a gun pointed at his head" is just plain stupidity.
 
What a load of tosh, Played 1st year Ruckman Sean Darcy when he could have played Johno Griffin, played 1st year defenders Brennan Cox and Griffin Logue when he could have played Zac Dawson and Garrick Ibbotson, played Harley Balic when he could have played Nick Suban, blooded Ryan Nyhuis, Brady Grey, Josh Deluca, Ethan Hughes etc.

Players that would have been locks in previous Lyon's sides Danyle Pearce, Cameron Sutcliffe, Matt Taberner, Tom Sheridan etc have had serious WAFL time when fit for AFL selection.

Ross Lyon "dragged kicking and screaming to the selection table with a gun pointed at his head" is just plain stupidity.
You can call it stupidity if you like. It's also an accurate description of the situation Freo found itself in at the start of the season.
 
Out of interest which set of brothers do we think have the highest chance of playing together in 2018? (FYI, i pulled this list off a 2016 article so forgive me if there are any player movements/retirements/delistings I wasn't aware off)

  • Brendon Ah Chee (Port Adelaide) and Callum Ah Chee (Gold Coast)
  • Mitchell Brown (West Coast) and Nathan Brown (Collingwood)
  • Cameron Delaney (Geelong) and Luke Delaney (St Kilda)
  • Jack Frost (Collingwood) and Sam Frost (Melbourne)
  • Cameron Hewett (Port Adelaide) and George Hewett (Sydney Swans)
  • Nathan Jones (Melbourne) and Zak Jones (Sydney Swans)
  • Jake Kolodjashnij (Geelong) and Kade Kolodjashnij (Gold Coast)
  • Ed Langdon (Fremantle) and Tom Langdon (Collingwood)
  • Harry Marsh (Sydney Swans) and Jonathon Marsh (Collingwood)
  • Jeremy McGovern (West Coast) and Mitch McGovern (Adelaide)
  • Ben McKay (North Melbourne) and Harry Mckay (Carlton)
  • Daniel Menzel (Geelong) and Troy Menzel (Adelaide)
  • Brodie Murdoch (St Kilda) and Jordan Murdoch (Geelong)
  • Ben Reid (Collingwood) and Sam Reid (Sydney Swans)
  • Andrew Swallow (North Melbourne) and David Swallow (Gold Coast)
  • Daniel Talia (Adelaide) and Michael Talia (Sydney Swans)
  • Corey Wagner (North Melbourne) and Josh Wagner (Melbourne)
  • Jimmy Webster (St Kilda) and Zac Webster (Hawthorn)
  • Lachie Weller (Fremantle) and Maverick Weller (St Kilda)
 
Out of interest which set of brothers do we think have the highest chance of playing together in 2018? (FYI, i pulled this list off a 2016 article so forgive me if there are any player movements/retirements/delistings I wasn't aware off)

  • Brendon Ah Chee (Port Adelaide) and Callum Ah Chee (Gold Coast)
  • Mitchell Brown (West Coast) and Nathan Brown (Collingwood)
  • Cameron Delaney (Geelong) and Luke Delaney (St Kilda)
  • Jack Frost (Collingwood) and Sam Frost (Melbourne)
  • Cameron Hewett (Port Adelaide) and George Hewett (Sydney Swans)
  • Nathan Jones (Melbourne) and Zak Jones (Sydney Swans)
  • Jake Kolodjashnij (Geelong) and Kade Kolodjashnij (Gold Coast)
  • Ed Langdon (Fremantle) and Tom Langdon (Collingwood)
  • Harry Marsh (Sydney Swans) and Jonathon Marsh (Collingwood)
  • Jeremy McGovern (West Coast) and Mitch McGovern (Adelaide)
  • Ben McKay (North Melbourne) and Harry Mckay (Carlton)
  • Daniel Menzel (Geelong) and Troy Menzel (Adelaide)
  • Brodie Murdoch (St Kilda) and Jordan Murdoch (Geelong)
  • Ben Reid (Collingwood) and Sam Reid (Sydney Swans)
  • Andrew Swallow (North Melbourne) and David Swallow (Gold Coast)
  • Daniel Talia (Adelaide) and Michael Talia (Sydney Swans)
  • Corey Wagner (North Melbourne) and Josh Wagner (Melbourne)
  • Jimmy Webster (St Kilda) and Zac Webster (Hawthorn)
  • Lachie Weller (Fremantle) and Maverick Weller (St Kilda)
Probably the McGovern brothers.

There was a rumour that Geelong haven't offered Menzel a contract for next year, so I guess he's a sneaky chance. Probably a better fit for Port though.

Think there's a chance Andrew Swallow ends up at the Gold Coast too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top