List Mgmt. 2017 GC Draft/Trade Thread/FA - National Draft Pick 19

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Scotty Clayton must have something up he's sleeve. We've delisted a lot of player and don't have a lot of picks. Looks unlikely we will get Swallow atleast on the senior list. He's got a good strike rate with rookies and likes a delisted free agent so i think we will pick up someone.
Apart from Saad and maybe Joyce - Do you really think he has? I think he's picked up a lot of junk in rookie drafts overall.
 
Apart from Saad and maybe Joyce - Do you really think he has? I think he's picked up a lot of junk in rookie drafts overall.
The rookie draft is junk that's why they slipped that far. Wasn't Hall in the rookie draft as well? Spencer another one who even though was an academy player wasn't obvious. Even Davis played some games, Macpherson is still around. Most don't even get 1 game at other clubs and considering how many top picks we've had to hold off until the rookie draft would be difficult i think that's where he's done his best work.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Yeah I’m hoping someone gives you. Sensible reply too. It’s a good question.
The point was players like being here on the Coast but its the lure of 3rd party sponsorship- sportsmanship nights, appearances, media etc that often drives players back to Melbourne.
You need to re-read the post
Davis is happy to be here because no-one's slipping him 10k for opening a chicken shop in Altona Meadows if he goes back to Melbourne
Probably on better money at Southport than the VFL too
 
The point was players like being here on the Coast but its the lure of 3rd party sponsorship- sportsmanship nights, appearances, media etc that often drives players back to Melbourne.
You need to re-read the post
Davis is happy to be here because no-one's slipping him 10k for opening a chicken shop in Altona Meadows if he goes back to Melbourne
Probably on better money at Southport than the VFL too

Thanks I now totally understand. It reinforces how unreal it is up here that’s many stay rather than get better money in the VFL.

I wonder what Southport pays its players though out of curiosity. Does anyone know?
 
The point was players like being here on the Coast but its the lure of 3rd party sponsorship- sportsmanship nights, appearances, media etc that often drives players back to Melbourne.
You need to re-read the post
Davis is happy to be here because no-one's slipping him 10k for opening a chicken shop in Altona Meadows if he goes back to Melbourne
Probably on better money at Southport than the VFL too
Thanks.
I thought he was saying there were 3rd party sponsorships keeping the players on the Coast. Got me wondering what they could be.
Daniel getting the gig at Southport no doubt was a big reason Davis also headed there (but the $$ another).
Think he may have gotten more at quite a few Vic country clubs though, so may be enjoying the GC lifestyle too!
 
2001 pick 2 - Luke Ball - 1x AA midfielder, 1x CLub B&F, Club Captain 2006 - 07, 1x Premiership player
2002 pick 2 - Daniel Wells - 2x Club B&F

2003 pick 2 - Andrew Walker - Good player without being exceptional. did have a 56 goal season in 2011
2004 pick 2 - Jarryd Roughhead - 4x Premiership player, Club Captain, 2x AA Forward, 1x Coleman medal
2005 pick 2 - Dale Thomas - 1x Premiership player, 1x AA Winger
2006 pick 2 - Scott Gumbleton - ruined by injury
2007 pick 2 - Trent Cotchin - 1x Brownlow Medal, 1x Premiership player, 1x AA midfielder, 1x AFLCA player of the year, 3x Club B&F. Club Captain
2008 pick 2 - Nic Naitanui - 1x AA Ruckman, rising star nominee 2009. injury prone

2009 pick 2 - Jack Trengove - Melbourne Co-Captain 2012 - 13. Career derailed by multiple navicular fractures
2010 pick 2 - Harley Bennell - Off field issues and calf problems have seen him miss too much playing time. Still one of the most talented players in the AFL.
2011 pick 2 - Stephen Coniglio - A Grade mid. Gets a lot less hype because of who else plays in that team.
2012 pick 2 - Jonathon O'Rourke - Only genuinely poor choice of the lot so far
2013 pick 2 - Josh Kelly - 1x AA Midfielder, 1x Club B&F, Rising star nomination
2014 pick 2 - Christian Petracca - Rising Star nomination

2015 pick 2 - Josh Schache - too early to tell. Looks good but obviously struggled playing in Queensland
2016 pick 2 - Tim Taranto - Looks the goods, 1x rising star nomination

So in 16 pick 2's that's 9 great players, 4 decent players, and 3 that haven't made the cut.
a combined 7x AA's, 7x Club B&F's, 7x Premierships, and 4 past or present club captains

Nice reply. A lot of effort went in so I'll retract my earlier claim of 1 in 3 as far as this list is concerned, although we could go back further to find some horrible washouts. But let be honest here, Schache and Bennell belong in the failure basket because they didn't work out for the club that spent the pick, while I think you're being too generous with others.

Walker was good without being #2 exceptional
Thomas was great, but only at Collingwood for about 6 seasons.
Petracca and Taranto are too early to tell, but in Timmy's case the Giants paid a higher price than just #2 to trade up.

Kelly, Coniglio, Natanui, Cotchin, Roughead and Wells were worth it as elite players

You have 8 players worth the price and 8 that clearly weren't despite mitigating circumstances. Those are good odds, but I prefer the Weller trade, which did actually come with pick #40 so it is more like trading pick #4 in points index terms.
 
$200-300.... $300-500.... a few $500+
Gee that's cheap.
I remember back In about 2005 we were flying down about 5 ntfl players from Darwin to play footy in the Wimmera league in western victoria. They were on about $500 a game + free accommodation & travel
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2017 GC Draft/Trade Thread/FA - National Draft Pick 19

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top