List Mgmt. 2017 Trade & Free Agency Watch Part 2

[THE THIN MAN]

Would love Salem. Our lastest first is the absolute most I'd pay for him. Probably need their mid third in return as well.

CG = Clangers

 

[Gosha]

No to Salem. He's a liability in defence and there's no room for him anywhere else.

 

[pebblestone]

We have players that can do that easily backwards move

Second tall who can backup ruck, elite kick, very good athlete, good mark, good smarts. would not cost much in trade or cap. Haven't we been screaming for a second tall? He's on the table cheap and easy. Make chase and pressure a non negotiable and there you go. Better than any other mid size to tall option currently on the list bar jack (including griff).

 

[NimFromSudan]

CG = Clangers
View attachment 416706

2.4 clangers is not awful from a young half back.

 

[RichoLedio]

tiger71 said that ages ago papers finally catching up

So much crap gets posted in here it takes em a while to read it all

 

[Charlie Pannam]

Pretty sure Salem struggled in the endurance testing at the draft combine back in 2013 and I think that continues to be the nock on him. His kicking is good but very one sided and without the running ability he can turn it over

 

[Underarm]

What is Batchelor worth? Seems to dominate at vfl, shpild be playing afl somewhere i think.

 

[Wacky Tiger]

What is Batchelor worth? Seems to dominate at vfl, shpild be playing afl somewhere i think.

1.5mil at lolnorf

 

[Calcium Man]

Do we even need anyone our VFL team is keeping out 7 or 8 a-graders

C. Moore > Stringer
Markov/Short > Salem
CEllis > Rockliff
Menadue > JKelly
Stengle and Bolton > Then everyone else
Garthwaite > Lever

Plus Naish, Derek Smith and picks 15 & 17 are all going to be guns

Pretty sure Salem struggled in the endurance testing at the draft combine back in 2013 and I think that continues to be the nock on him. His kicking is good but very one sided and without the running ability he can turn it over

14.5 beep test so pretty decent

 

[Cevap_Roll]

Do we even need anyone our VFL team is keeping out 7 or 8 a-graders

C. Moore > Stringer
Markov/Short > Salem
CEllis > Rockliff
Menadue > JKelly
Stengle and Bolton > Then everyone else
Garthwaite > Lever

Plus Naish, Derek Smith and picks 15 & 17 are all going to be guns



14.5 beep test so pretty decent

If not I hope we look at upgrading our picks some how. Maybe even what someone else suggested. Turn our 2 picks into 3 picks in the 20s

 

[Calcium Man]

If not I hope we look at upgrading our picks some how. Maybe even what someone else suggested. Turn our 2 picks into 3 picks in the 20s

Nah i think we either go up the order, move to next years draft or don't move. The talent in this draft is thin by all accounts and runs out early.

Honestly I'd still take Stringer (just) but if C.Moore keeps improving can't see why he cannot play a similar role he is 193cm and ran 2.91 20m at draft camp.

Its weird our biggest hole on our list, KPF/Ruck has become our greatest advantage and i'm starting to think unless its a can't miss player like T.Lynch or Shuey wants to come home maybe we shouldn't bother with trading for players. Although we will lose Miles and probably Bachelor and Lloyd who have all been very important for our VFL side.

 

[prodigy]

Stuff Salem. Markov is our man to replace Bachar when the time comes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Danog]

Stuff Salem. Markov is our man to replace Bachar when the time comes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Need some sort of depth, and I'd prefer it to be youthful depth. Batch isn't young anymore.

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Stuff Salem. Markov is our man to replace Bachar when the time comes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

needs to get more of it in the ones and can panic a bit but at vfl level **** he looks good. anyway need more then one good kick off the hbf

 

[tigernsw]

Big no from me on Salem

 

[guruisatiger]

If batch , hunt and morris, dont get offers from other afl clubs
And more than likely they wont, hope all 3 stay at punt rd as
Permanent vfl players , , Morro would be handy part time dev
Coach as well so would the big mullet

 

[TiggerMan22]

Our depth covers most areas.
Just look to being in a tall forward, other than that no thanks to anyone.

 

[Charlie Pannam]

Tall forward/s of any quality are going to be tough to land unless we are willing to pay overs. FA cupboard is looking bare
Shache and Watts don't excite me. I suppose Schache has had his reasons for underperforming but from afar looks soft and a sook.
Then there's lesser likes such as
Close
Lycett
Harry Dear
TaBerner
Apeness,
That we could look at.
Lycett was looking like being a very good player and Eagles have a lot of talls so may be willing to trade. But injury issues are a concern.

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Tall forward/s of any quality are going to be tough to land unless we are willing to pay overs. FA cupboard is looking bare
Shache and Watts don't excite me. I suppose Schache has had his reasons for underperforming but from afar looks soft and a sook.
Then there's lesser likes such as
Close
Lycett
Harry Dear
TaBerner
Apeness,
That we could look at.
Lycett was looking like being a very good player and Eagles have a lot of talls so may be willing to trade. But injury issues are a concern.

That line-up would only look good compared to a Clint's Bargain Basement Store!

 

[Charlie Pannam]

That line-up would only look good compared to a Clint's Bargain Basement Store!

Agreed not an inspiring list. Probably State players that are superior to that list.
Callum Moore may very well end up a better AFL player than any of those names.

 

[TigerTime88]

Aaron Hall available from GC.

Seems a bit of a selfish player but definitely has ability.

Then again I would probably prefer to put time into Menaue, Markov, Bolton who are the speed demons.

 

[prodigy]

Aaron Hall available from GC.

Seems a bit of a selfish player but definitely has ability.

Then again I would probably prefer to put time into Menaue, Markov, Bolton who are the speed demons.

We were into him like last year or the year before. That may have changed though. We don't need him.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[matt_y106]

Delist:
Hunt
Morris
Yarran
Elton

Trade out 2 of:
Miles
Lloyd
Lennon

Retire:
Ivan

Trade in:
Schache/Watts
Hopper/M.Kennedy/Stringer


Upgrade:
Soldo
Moore
Stengle

Draft:
Naish
(lloyd Pick)
(Lennon Pick)

 

[Joey longshadow]

Forget trading for overs
Bring Cal Moore in next season as the second tall
Draft Noah Balta
Draft a Ruck with potential with our other first

Only trade I would look to entertain is Nichols from GC as a ruck man

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Give away to whoever will take him:
Lennon