News 2019 Rumour File - discuss rumours here! (Part 2)

[hey shorty]

Keith and Bruce to Bulldogs should make them top 4.

Fitness permitting I think.

That said I can't see anyone sliding too far.

 

[Crouch#44]

Keith and Bruce to Bulldogs should make them top 4.

Can't agree on this as it will take more than that... list is good but coaching is stale

 

[hey shorty]

I agree with this. He's turn key go and instantly becomes their best defender.

It will be 14 after downgrades which sounds spot on to me.

The only thing that pushes him into that territory is the reported size of the deal.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Nick Robertson?

Vomit

So far I've seen us linked to Robertson and Lewis Taylor. If we add Neal-Bullen and that Clarke guy from Sydney to that target list we'll have assembled the four biggest DUDS in the universe

 

[Scorpus]

Nick Robertson?

Vomit

So far I've seen us linked to Robertson and Lewis Taylor. If we add Neal-Bullen and that Clarke guy from Sydney to that target list we'll have assembled the four biggest DUDS in the universe

Ryan Clarke I'll give you. But the other three top DUDS are Wylie Buzza, George Horlin-Smith, and Cameron Polson

 

[nightchook]

Nick Robertson?

Vomit

So far I've seen us linked to Robertson and Lewis Taylor. If we add Neal-Bullen and that Clarke guy from Sydney to that target list we'll have assembled the four biggest DUDS in the universe

this... you don't offload duds to bring in more duds

 

[Mego Red]

Well you won't get 12 for a 3rd tall who will be 28 next season, not without giving something more than Alex Keath

What did the Subs get for Steven May? How old was he when traded?

Keath was better this year than May has maybe ever been.

 

[On The Crouch]

Nick Robertson?

Vomit

So far I've seen us linked to Robertson and Lewis Taylor. If we add Neal-Bullen and that Clarke guy from Sydney to that target list we'll have assembled the four biggest DUDS in the universe

I would think if we are targeting Robertson it would be as a tagger.

Bringing in a tagger isn’t a sexy trade but maybe the coaches watched the Brownlow this week and noticed all the elite midfielders receiving 3 votes against us. This might have been our coaches light bulb moment.

I would have been underwhelmed if we brought in De Boer but he has turned himself into arguably the best tagger.

 

[Mutineer]

Ryan Clarke I'll give you. But the other three top DUDS are Wylie Buzza, George Horlin-Smith, and Cameron Polson

And if Ryan Clarke could kick [he can't] he wouldn't be a dud at all, he's hard, tough and can find the pill in bunches but his kicking is atrocious. Why the Swans play him down back I can't fathom, he's an inside mid with great endurance.....did I mention he can't kick....

 

[ManInTheArena]

I don't think anyone is giving away a pick between 10 and 15 for Keath or Greenwood, no matter how many later rounds picks are bundled with it.

Think about what you'd pay to trade them to Adelaide. You'd all be saying a pick in the 30's, at best.

 

[hey shorty]

I don't think anyone is giving away a pick between 10 and 15 for Keath or Greenwood, no matter how many later rounds picks are bundled with it.

Think about what you'd pay to trade them to Adelaide. You'd all be saying a pick in the 30's, at best.

We paid somewhere in the 20s for Seedsman didn't we ??

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

We paid somewhere in the 20s for Seedsman didn't we ??

Pick 32

I think in 2015 Seedsman was in and out of Collingwood line up (ie fringe player).

 

[skittlebrew]

Well you won't get 12 for a 3rd tall who will be 28 next season, not without giving something more than Alex Keath

The only team dumb enough to pay a first rounder for a 28 year old is us unfortunately.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Heard a few things from a mate who is close to somebody inside the club. Not all groundbreaking but interesting nonetheless
-Smith wants to stay. GOOD
-Betts gone (obviously) FINE
-B Crouch requested to look at other options and the club said no. GOOD
-M Crouch requested to look at other options and the club said ‘maybe’. Getting back to him in the next few days. WHAT THE
-We are chasing a ruck from Freo to back up O’Brien. Didn’t say who though. SEAN DARCY?

 

[Mutineer]

Most of it sounds like bullshit but.

Sean Darcy ain't backing up ROB, it would be the other way round...

Lloyd Meek would make more sense if there's any essence at all to any of that..

 

[Sanders]

Sean Darcy ain't backing up ROB, it would be the other way round...

Hearty Lol’s

 

[hey shorty]

Most of it sounds like bulls**t but.

Sean Darcy ain't backing up ROB, it would be the other way round...

Lloyd Meek would make more sense if there's any essence at all to any of that..

Really ?? ROB proved himself this year, Darcy hasn't yet

 

[BACCS]

Nick Robertson?

Vomit

So far I've seen us linked to Robertson and Lewis Taylor. If we add Neal-Bullen and that Clarke guy from Sydney to that target list we'll have assembled the four biggest DUDS in the universe

What’s wrong with Taylor? Clearly has talent

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

So are we likely to get any compensation for Sauce?

 

[Glenny83]

The only team dumb enough to pay a first rounder for a 28 year old is us unfortunately.

We’re also be the team dumb enough to trade Dangerfield for less than two firsts.

We are ****ing suck hole traders!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Thetrader15]

I don't think anyone is giving away a pick between 10 and 15 for Keath or Greenwood, no matter how many later rounds picks are bundled with it.

Think about what you'd pay to trade them to Adelaide. You'd all be saying a pick in the 30's, at best.

Ssshhhhh

 

[Thetrader15]

I suspect the freo ruck will be Jones who is a DFA

 

[Thetrader15]

So are we likely to get any compensation for Sauce?

No

 

[SaltPeter]

Burton is now on coach selection panel.
Good possibility all reviews will amount to nix and he will keep his job. The only casualty may well just be Don Pyke as the rest are sure they are on the right track.

campaigner .. you too

 

[Pea Nut]

What’s wrong with Taylor? Clearly has talent

Downhill skiier that looks lazy and is very selfish the way he plays. Always reminded me of a mini Josh Green.