List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread III

Remove this Banner Ad

Reader mode
Snake_Baker said:
I need to see how they're going to structure first mate.

Lots of sides are only going with one true KPF & a swingman these days.
Click to expand...
I think Larkey needs another KPF to assist. We need to structure around this set up. Larkey has a high ceiling but also a maturing body. I still reckon we make a play for Tom McDonald.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Snake_Baker said:
Once the midfield gets fixed Larkey will be doing that. It could be as soon as next year. He's a ~35 goal a year player already in a very inefficient team.

A lot of folks aren't seeing the value in what we already have under our noses. Nick is already banging through 0.5 more goals a game than Petrie at the same age.
Click to expand...
Larkey is potentially a 35 goal a year forward, but he isn't one already. Whereas Brown is a proven 60 goal a year forward. And Petrie was a seven year AFL player who'd made the All-Australian squad as a ruckman/utility before he began playing key forward full time, so it isn't a great comparison. Perhaps Kent Kingsley or Aaron Black would be closer to the mark?
I really hope Larkey develops into a topline forward capable of holding together the forward line, but he ain't there yet. The irony is in your second paragraph. "A lot of folks aren't seeing the value in what we have under our noses." But it applies to Brown more so than Larkey.
 
1604965193383.png

Lewis Young.

FMD.

"Journalism"
 
B4Bear said:
Only the f’ed up AFL would allow trade week to occur before teams even know the list size for 2020.

Pay me 1/4 of the CEO's salary and I will sort it out quick smart.
Click to expand...

It's farcical, isn't it.

Yet somehow most of the football media haven't yet worked out what a farce it is. Go figure.

I suppose it's because they need to keep running with the big stories like "Battling* North won't appoint unqualified candidate due to gender."

* or cash-strapped , or basket-case, or cancerous, or failed, or easy target, or ...
 
The Gold Coast SUNS have traded Peter Wright to Essendon for its Future R4 Selection.
  • Index
    •  
  • Index
    • Star said:
    View attachment 1007657

    Lewis Young.

    FMD.

    "Journalism"
    Click to expand...

    For anyone heavily into soccer, basketball etc does this shit fly in other sports coverage?

    It's frequent enough to be regular in AFL coverage. Amateur hour.
     
    Star said:
    View attachment 1007657

    Lewis Young.

    FMD.

    "Journalism"
    Click to expand...
    Just out of interest, what is his name?
     
    I was dead against trading pick 2, but the more I think about it the more I can see it could benefit us. As long as we don't trade back too far and it is an overwhelmingly good deal for us. But do it live on draft night after we know who Adelaide has selected.

    The Suns pick 5 would be as far back as I'd go, noting there seems a fairly clear top 7 this year, but two of them are academy prospects. And it would have to include their 2021 1st pick too. Something like our pick 2 & 2021 2nd to Gold Coast for picks 5, 27, 37 & 2021 1st would be a good deal. Obviously hard to say, but at pick 7 I reckon we would end up with one of DGB, Phillips or Hollands, and any one of them would be great.

    * and their picks 6+ can bugger off.
     

    (Log in to remove this ad.)

    Star said:
    View attachment 1007657

    Lewis Young.

    FMD.

    "Journalism"
    Click to expand...

    Poor bloke hasn’t even got to North yet and they are already ****ing his name up. He’ll be called about a dozen different names during his time with us can guarantee that.
     
    Rooboys Rool said:
    I was dead against trading pick 2, but the more I think about it the more I can see it could benefit us. As long as we don't trade back too far and it is an overwhelmingly good deal for us. But do it live on draft night after we know who Adelaide has selected.

    The Suns pick 5 would be as far back as I'd go, noting there seems a fairly clear top 7 this year, but two of them are academy prospects. And it would have to include their 2021 1st pick too. Something like our pick 2 & 2021 2nd to Gold Coast for picks 5, 27, 37 & 2021 1st would be a good deal. Obviously hard to say, but at pick 7 I reckon we would end up with one of DGB, Phillips or Hollands, and any one of them would be great.

    * and their picks 6+ can bugger off.
    Click to expand...

    I like this, especially if the kid we really want will still be there at pick 5, it gives us a lot of flexibility in both this year and next years draft.
     
    Dirty_11 said:
    I think Larkey needs another KPF to assist. We need to structure around this set up. Larkey has a high ceiling but also a maturing body. I still reckon we make a play for Tom McDonald.
    Click to expand...

    I agree with wanting another.... maybe not so much TMac, that's why I was pushing mio but he signed on didn't he? Also is Mcstay keen to come home now with Daniher up there I wonder


    On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
     
    Rooboys Rool said:
    I was dead against trading pick 2, but the more I think about it the more I can see it could benefit us. As long as we don't trade back too far and it is an overwhelmingly good deal for us. But do it live on draft night after we know who Adelaide has selected.

    The Suns pick 5 would be as far back as I'd go, noting there seems a fairly clear top 7 this year, but two of them are academy prospects. And it would have to include their 2021 1st pick too. Something like our pick 2 & 2021 2nd to Gold Coast for picks 5, 27, 37 & 2021 1st would be a good deal. Obviously hard to say, but at pick 7 I reckon we would end up with one of DGB, Phillips or Hollands, and any one of them would be great.

    * and their picks 6+ can bugger off.
    Click to expand...
    Who is your clear 7? McDonald, JUH, Campbell, DGB, Hollands, Phillips and ????
     
    You can't write comedy this funny. Logged onto Trade Radio to see if there is anything happening. Their first caller is some bloke from Colac who appeared to be ignoring his screaming infant son to speak to Julian de Stoop and Brendon Goddard. When questioned about the absolutely beside-himself child in the background, the bloke said "yeah it's me son, he's cracked the shits" and kept asking about Geelong and Jeremy Cameron
     
    Brendon Goddard has about as much presence and charisma as a dead cat
     
    Flawed Genius said:
    You can't write comedy this funny. Logged onto Trade Radio to see if there is anything happening. Their first caller is some bloke from Colac who appeared to be ignoring his screaming infant son to speak to Julian de Stoop and Brendon Goddard. When questioned about the absolutely beside-himself child in the background, the bloke said "yeah it's me son, he's cracked the shits" and kept asking about Geelong and Jeremy Cameron
    Click to expand...

    He then abruptly ended the call saying "gotta get back to mi' mayoral duties now".
     
    Reader mode

    Remove this Banner Ad

    List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread III

    Similar threads

    giantroo
    List Mgmt. 2025 Trade & List Management Thread
    2 3
    Replies
    58
    Views
    3K
    The Nostradamus
    The Nostradamus
    Daniltchenko You Beauty
    • Locked
    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part 3
    407 408 409 410 411
    Replies
    10K
    Views
    466K
    DuckYeah
    DuckYeah
    Daniltchenko You Beauty
    • Locked
    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II
    396 397 398 399 400
    Replies
    10K
    Views
    479K
    Twangler
    T
    giantroo
    List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III
    139 140 141 142 143
    Replies
    4K
    Views
    213K
    The Nostradamus
    The Nostradamus
    giantroo
    • Locked
    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread
    397 398 399 400 401
    Replies
    10K
    Views
    516K
    King Hansen
    King Hansen
    scottywiper
    List management 101 (69?)
    8 9 10 11 12
    Replies
    277
    Views
    12K
    The Nostradamus
    The Nostradamus
    Blightys Barrel
    List Mgmt. 17 decisions required by EOY for the list management team
    Replies
    7
    Views
    925
    Flawed Genius
    Flawed Genius

    Remove this Banner Ad

    Back
    Top