The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #1
Changes:
-
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Preview 2022 Rd 17 Carlton vs West Coast Sunday July 10 @ 4:40PM - Team Post #655
- Thread starter The Old Dark Navy's
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Changes:
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
OUT: Motlop (rest), Durdin (rest), Kennedy (rest), Newnes
IN: Weitering, Owies, Dow, Setterfield
FB: Plowman Weitering Newman
HB: Docherty Young Saad
C: Walsh Cerra O'Brien
HF: Honey C.Curnow Fisher
FF: JSOS McKay Owies
R: TDK Cripps Hewett
Int: Dow, Setterfield, Cottrell, Kemp
Kemp FP/HF/stoppages
Dow at a lot of centre bounces
Setterfield on ball, Walsh further out
Too many players playing way below 75% minutes.
IN: Weitering, Owies, Dow, Setterfield
FB: Plowman Weitering Newman
HB: Docherty Young Saad
C: Walsh Cerra O'Brien
HF: Honey C.Curnow Fisher
FF: JSOS McKay Owies
R: TDK Cripps Hewett
Int: Dow, Setterfield, Cottrell, Kemp
Kemp FP/HF/stoppages
Dow at a lot of centre bounces
Setterfield on ball, Walsh further out
Too many players playing way below 75% minutes.
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #4
West Coast are getting their best team together and it is over there. Do you really think a team battling to make the 8, let alone the top 4, is in a position to rest players? Especially Motlop and Kennedy who were two of our best tonight. Mots also playing in his home state.
Why are we resting players coming off a poor loss with an 8 day break? Particularly 2 who were amongst our best. We deserve to lose if we do that.
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #6
Jimmae just graduated from the Eddie McGuire school of weekly ideas.
ferrisb
Brownlow Medallist
Shame we didn't get to play WCE when they needed COVID topups...
Out: Newnes Honey Durdin
In: Weitering Owies Martin
Martin is lucky but Honey has provided very little and don't feel we can play all of Durdin, Motlop, Owies and Fisher as none are good above their head.
In: Weitering Owies Martin
Martin is lucky but Honey has provided very little and don't feel we can play all of Durdin, Motlop, Owies and Fisher as none are good above their head.
Motlop? good luck with that. Durdin will stays in, same as Kennedy. Newnes wasn't one of our worst
Weitering comes in, Dow won't
Can’t see Kennedy being rested he was good tonight. There’s no way Honey will stay in for Owies unless Durdin isn’t right.
Could see Weitering coming in for the Plow who moves to the sub spot.
Motlop has earned his next game. Two okay ones in a row. Plays hard too the little man.
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
Maybe, maybe you can use that to justify Motlop, but we need to shake things up so that we can come home strong.
I'll back that my suggested line-up gives us an outside spark that Dow and Setterfield can feed off at the stoppages. Durdin will come straight back in.
3 players missing 40-45 minutes of the game is not acceptable. Call it a rest, call it sending a message that we can't carry players who don't average less than 75% game time.
Has to change.
he was the only small forward who looked likely tonight, did about all he could and finished with 3.
With Owies and Martins likely to get up for next week, I’d be nervous if I was Honey and Durdin
You haven't been close in any week with your suggested changes
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
Because none of them could even hit 70% game time while the opposition was almost 3 down on the bench in the last quarter.
I think you are way over thinking the TOG stats. Every team has guys that have lower TOG. In the case of Kennedy it is clearly tactical.
- Moderator
- #18
Are we now resting players.
Why, are they tired
Why, are they tired
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
When we run out of gas in final quarters against better endurance teams, the tactics should be re-thought.
Durdin fell out of the game and needs a rest, Motlop should not be carried if he's going to be on the pine for 45 minutes a game playing as a forward.
- Feb 19, 2018
- 1,468
- 2,082
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Yer Honey your toast
Sunday 4:40, pffft, might as well just make it Monday morning. FMD I hate those late Sunday games.
I thought the group had come of age last week. A few regressed today.
Newnes just about had me, does not absorb real pressure well enough. On current availability, Stocker in for mine. Newnes LOB and Cotts are all flawed. Cotts and LOB do a job using their “wheels” and are viable for the future. All three do not survive in the one team for mine. We have seen the best of Newnes, Cotts and LOB still have upside.
Kemp > Plowman. Therefore Weiters for Plow. I want more proactive than reactive defenders, with Kemp third tall, give me Stocker in front of Plowman for the small/mediums.
Fisher worries me, great last week. A bit of hot potato today again, can be muscled out of the game. Cerra was poor tonight, but needs to be in the guts creating space with his kicks. Was a fish out of water tonight, creating a role for the other Fish. That was ordinary coaching. Both survive, but roles modified and on notice.
Small forwards all did some good things. Great cameos from Honey, but drifted out on occasion, Durds good bar poor composure around goal, which he has to address. Motlop stepped up dramatically going better in the ones than he did in the twos. Keeper. Owies comes back if fit, Honey the unlucky one for mine.
Bam Bam and JSOS both playing sore. Unfortunately Jack needs to soldier on with no relief in sight unless we prematurely blood big Mirkov. Sooner or later Kennedy will need a blow, with a toss up between Dow and Carroll to replace him unless we want to give Cerra and Fisher the inside minutes and include Hayes in the wing rotations.
Weitering, Stocker and Owies for Plowman, Newnes and (unlucky) Honey. (With a long flight, happy if this is Bam Bam/Chugga’s managed game) If he has done the work, don’t mind if Martin is the sub, otherwise Plow.
Newnes just about had me, does not absorb real pressure well enough. On current availability, Stocker in for mine. Newnes LOB and Cotts are all flawed. Cotts and LOB do a job using their “wheels” and are viable for the future. All three do not survive in the one team for mine. We have seen the best of Newnes, Cotts and LOB still have upside.
Kemp > Plowman. Therefore Weiters for Plow. I want more proactive than reactive defenders, with Kemp third tall, give me Stocker in front of Plowman for the small/mediums.
Fisher worries me, great last week. A bit of hot potato today again, can be muscled out of the game. Cerra was poor tonight, but needs to be in the guts creating space with his kicks. Was a fish out of water tonight, creating a role for the other Fish. That was ordinary coaching. Both survive, but roles modified and on notice.
Small forwards all did some good things. Great cameos from Honey, but drifted out on occasion, Durds good bar poor composure around goal, which he has to address. Motlop stepped up dramatically going better in the ones than he did in the twos. Keeper. Owies comes back if fit, Honey the unlucky one for mine.
Bam Bam and JSOS both playing sore. Unfortunately Jack needs to soldier on with no relief in sight unless we prematurely blood big Mirkov. Sooner or later Kennedy will need a blow, with a toss up between Dow and Carroll to replace him unless we want to give Cerra and Fisher the inside minutes and include Hayes in the wing rotations.
Weitering, Stocker and Owies for Plowman, Newnes and (unlucky) Honey. (With a long flight, happy if this is Bam Bam/Chugga’s managed game) If he has done the work, don’t mind if Martin is the sub, otherwise Plow.
That's because Cerra has played 6-8 games this year better then Dow has in his whole career. He has runs on the board. Cant be dropping your guns if they have the odd bad game. He looked underdone snd shouldn't have played.Owies back 100%, no doubts about it. Durdin has been quiet for a while and honey has done sfa. Id keep honey (as much to keep Martin out) and give durdin a spell and see how he responds
Amazing cerra plays such a s**t game but those who would demand dow be dropped for a similar performance won't want cerra dropped.....
Still waiting for him to hit a target by foot.....at least 50% of the time.....
Think we need stocker in as a replacement for boyd and Newnes back to wing or vfl.
Weitering back for plowman.
Sent from my CPH2005 using Tapatalk
) and give durdin a spell and see how he responds
ITCHY EYEBALLS
I see you watching me watching you
Im more concerned about Flyin Ryan, and Willie “Doobie” Rioli this week.
Time for Stocker to shine, there’s a spot there waiting son
Time for Stocker to shine, there’s a spot there waiting son
Nonsense.
- Status
