Game Day 2022 Trade Period Match Thread

[Snuffaluphagus]

Thanks for making this an awesome trade period peeps. Will be locking this thread later tonight

 

[rgauci]

I was thinking about this point yesterday. The fact they used pick 11 in 2020 to get sharp at 27 in 2019 was their own stupid fault. Of course Geelong were the winner again from that transaction, what’s new.
The simple fact is that Sharp was regarded by the 18 club recruiters at the 27th best player in his draft.
Just because those dumb fools at GC used pick 11 - not our problem.

GC used it, because the afl left it open to remove this compensation at their own will. Obviously if it’s traded they wouldn’t have the opportunity to take it away. It was GC who then offered it to Geelong late in the draft. Presumably up until that point no one had wanted the future pick.

 

[JammoMonty]

Logue was clearly an athlete, ok footballer projected to become an above average footballer - hindsight- Tim English at pick 9 and more so Shai Bolton at pick 29 - if you are considering WA boys only would have fitted in perfectly …. Big year 2016 for busts and under achievers.

Athlete, not a footballer. He was a pick 8 bust.

 

[FreoBulldog]

Logue was clearly an athlete, ok footballer projected to become an above average footballer - hindsight- Tim English at pick 9 and more so Shai Bolton at pick 29 - if you are considering WA boys only would have fitted in perfectly …. Big year 2016 for busts and under achievers.

Logue used to be a rower from memory, I think The Worst reported that. I remember the big reason we shouldn’t pick up English on these boards at the time was ‘ he can’t hold a mark’…which is ironic considering we ended up with Logue instead.

 

[Madas]

Would be content with pick 21. Still next years first would be epic.

Just not sure about not having any picks in this draft. I know it’s shallow, but doesn’t feel right. Rather keep 21 than trade to GC for Sharp. Back in Fredstar or Worner to take on the wing spot.

Don’t forget Drizzle

 

[King Huskii]

Logue used to be a rower from memory, I think The Worst reported that. I remember the big reason we shouldn’t pick up English on these boards at the time was ‘ he can’t hold a mark’…which is ironic considering we ended up with Logue instead.

Yes both can't hold marks however Darcey when he's playing at his best is a very good mark and for a ruck is an accurate kick for goal.

I have no problem picking up Logue instead of English with Luke Ryan and Darcey coming after those picks.

 

[dominguez]

If Meek is traded we’ll get a pick.

What we receive from Lobb will go to GC for Sharp.

Possibly no ND players coming in??

The draft has unlimited rounds. Even if we don't have a pick in the first 4 rounds we'll use a 5th, 6th and 7th round picks.

Probably back to back in the 60's.

 

[Scham]

Logue used to be a rower from memory, I think The Worst reported that. I remember the big reason we shouldn’t pick up English on these boards at the time was ‘ he can’t hold a mark’…which is ironic considering we ended up with Logue instead.

My memory of the knocks on English on this board were exclusively that he was skinny and would take too long to become a top level player, which should never be a reason not to draft a talent, and I'm sure it wasn't for our recruiters.

 

[Cobbler]

My memory of the knocks on English on this board were exclusively that he was skinny and would take too long to become a top level player, which should never be a reason not to draft a talent, and I'm sure it wasn't for our recruiters.

I recall it being ‘a reach’ to take English at 8. Quite a few wanted him.

 

[rgauci]

My memory of the knocks on English on this board were exclusively that he was skinny and would take too long to become a top level player, which should never be a reason not to draft a talent, and I'm sure it wasn't for our recruiters.

Our recruiters targeted Darcy instead of English. I don’t mind that at all.

 

[JammoMonty]

Yes both can't hold marks however Darcey when he's playing at his best is a very good mark and for a ruck is an accurate kick for goal.

I have no problem picking up Logue instead of English with Luke Ryan and Darcey coming after those picks.

Darcy, Cox and Ryan all ahead of Logue in that draft and all drafted outside of the top 30. Logue a bust imo

 

[King Huskii]

Darcy, Cox and Ryan all ahead of Logue in that draft and all drafted outside of the top 30. Logue a bust imo

I don't think he's a bust. If he was played as 3rd talll half back he's pretty solid. Making him part time ruck and pushing him forward wasn't his strength. He was average at best.

 

[malpaso]

Don’t forget Drizzle

There is two wings..

 

[rgauci]

Darcy, Cox and Ryan all ahead of Logue in that draft and all drafted outside of the top 30. Logue a bust imo

We were apparently interested in Tom Stewart, both Geelong and ourselves wanted Darcy / Stewart in the 2nd round. Had we gone English, we might have got Stewart 2nd. Sliding doors.

 

[tonygeeks]

Geez, if you think the Luke Jackson

9

Luke Jackson

Age

23

Ht

199cm

Wt

102kg

Pos.

F/R

Career

Season

Last 5

D

8.3

2star

K

3.3

1star

HB

5.0

4star

M

1.5

2star

T

1.0

3star

G

0.3

3star

D

8.3

2star

K

3.3

1star

HB

5.0

3star

M

1.5

2star

T

1.0

2star

G

0.3

3star

D

8.3

3star

K

3.3

2star

HB

5.0

4star

M

1.5

2star

T

1.0

3star

G

0.3

3star

thread is bad, get a load of the JHF ones. **** me dead.

The Norfies are broken and just want to take their pain out on the world

 

[Purpletown]

The AFL has ruled that Port can't trade their future first and future second round selections, well so ends the super humongous mega trade.

 

[manpurple]

So in the hypothetical situation where we need to trade Lobb before Jackson gets done do we
a - Trade in a late round 1 pick, which Melb tries to make part the Lobb trade
b - Take the same or more value in F2's and F3's so that Melb don't ask for them and then trade them later for a round 1 pick

 

[Dockeroo]

Darcy, Cox and Ryan all ahead of Logue in that draft and all drafted outside of the top 30. Logue a bust imo

Lol - a bust. He’s going to play 200 AFL games at least over his career and has just signed a $3.5m deal over 5 years but you think he’s a “bust”

Gallucci at 15 is a bust - now a part time footballer at south Fremantle. Some fall from grace after 6 years.
SPS at 6 will probably be delisted next year - bust.
Setterfield at 5 scraping around OOC at Carlton and trying to get to Essendon on base wages - bust.

 

[Dockernut]

There is two wings..

Can that Phillips who the Hawks recently delisted play wing? Decent runner from memory.

 

[Silencer83]

Darcy, Cox and Ryan all ahead of Logue in that draft and all drafted outside of the top 30. Logue a bust imo

It's hard to argue, especially when he was supposed to be the safe pick as the WA born player and the argument is that our group drafted was good and he would still rang last in that group and was taken earliest.

2016 is actually a pretty disappointing first round in terms of any star quality.

1​	1​	Bombers​	Andrew McGrath - solid 200+ game player​
1​	2​	Giants​	Tim Taranto - traded - solid 200+ game player​
1​	3​	Lions​	Hugh McCluggage -solid 200+ game player​
1​	4​	Suns​	Ben Ainsworth - solid 150+ game player​
1​	5​	Giants​	Will Setterfield - Academy - possibly about to be traded to his 3rd club as a bust​
1​	6​	Blues​	Sam Petrevski-Seton - traded - bust​
1​	7​	Suns​	Jack Scrimshaw - bust at GC - solid at Hawthorn​
1​	8​	Dockers​	Griffin Logue - solid 150+ game player - traded​
1​	9​	Suns​	Will Brodie - solid 150+ game player - traded - has his limitations but we love him ​
1​	10​	Suns​	Jack Bowes - about to be traded - struggling for opportunities​
1​	11​	Swans​	Oliver Florent - probably the closest to a star to this point in the draft - Best 22​
1​	12​	Kangaroos​	Jy Simpkin - Best 22 at North​
1​	13​	Eagles​	Daniel Venables - retired with concussion issues​
1​	14​	Giants​	Harry Perryman​
1​	15​	Crows​	Jordan Gallucci - delisted after 2019​
1​	16​	Power​	Todd Marshall - fringe​
1​	17​	Lions​	Jarrod Berry - best 22 at Bris​
1​	18​	Power​	Sam Powell-Pepper - started on fire - fringe​
1​	19​	Bulldogs​	Timothy English - Best 22 at Bulldogs​
1​	20​	Giants​	Isaac Cumming​
1​	21​	Swans​	Will Hayward - Best 22 at Sydney​
2​	22​	Bombers​	Jordan Ridley​
2​	25​	Saints​	Ben Long​
2​	26​	Cats​	Brandan Parfitt​
2​	27​	Blues​	Zac Fisher​
2​	28​	Bulldogs​	Patrick Lipinski​
2​	29​	Tigers​	Shai Bolton​
2​	38​	Dockers​	Sean Darcy​
2​	39​	Saints​	Josh Battle​
2​	40​	Cats​	Thomas Stewart​
2​	41​	Dockers​	Brennan Cox​
3​	48​	Swans​	Darcy Cameron​
3​	51​	Crows​	Elliott Himmelberg​
3​	52​	Eagles​	Willie Rioli​
3​	53​	Tigers​	Jack Graham​
4​	57​	Magpies​	Josh Daicos​
4​	58​	Giants​	Matthew De Boer​
4​	66​	Dockers​	Luke Ryan​
5​	73​	Kangaroos​	Nick Larkey​
5​	76​	Hawks​	Mitch Lewis​

 

[Cobbler]

Lol - a bust. He’s going to play 200 AFL games at least over his career and has just signed a $3.5m deal over 5 years but you think he’s a “bust”

Gallucci at 15 is a bust - now a part time footballer at south Fremantle. Some fall from grace after 6 years.
SPS at 6 will probably be delisted next year - bust.
Setterfield at 5 scraping around OOC at Carlton and trying to get to Essendon on base wages - bust.

He was 100% a bust for Freo.

Who cares what he does from here, it’s just speculation on your behalf anyway.

 

[Docker82]

Can that Phillips who the Hawks recently delisted play wing? Decent runner from memory.

He’s not the worst but if you think Acres was a bad kick wait until you see this guy. My gut feel is we stay well away.

 

[freo1997]

With Drizz, Freddy, Aish and the possibility of even Walker going on the wing. Is Sharp even a need? If he’s expensive to get maybe just wait a year?

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Logue was clearly an athlete, ok footballer projected to become an above average footballer - hindsight- Tim English at pick 9 and more so Shai Bolton at pick 29 - if you are considering WA boys only would have fitted in perfectly …. Big year 2016 for busts and under achievers.

It’s a pretty uninspiring list. Darcy, Cox and Ryan are all easily outperforming most of the top 20 from 2016.
Just goes to show that draft picks can be over valued, especially in a weak draft

 

[Scham]

I don't think he's a bust. If he was played as 3rd talll half back he's pretty solid. Making him part time ruck and pushing him forward wasn't his strength. He was average at best.

Correct. He'll be very solid for a long time for North as a defender.

 

[Joao]

The Norfies are broken and just want to take their pain out on the world

Sure and the Port fans happy to let them know it to.