2023 AFC Club Champion - Congratulations Jordan Dawson

[Scorpus]

So here's the players who played more than 20 games according to the coaches

Dawson - 23 games - winner
Keays - 23 games - equal 8th
O'Brien - 23 games - not top 10, horrendous year
Laird - 22 games - 2nd
Smith - 22 games - 7th
Milera - 22 games - 10th
Hinge - 22 games - equal 4th
Sloane - 22 games - not top 10, shit year
Murphy - 22 games - 6th
Walker - 22 games - 3rd
Michalanney - 22 games - not top 10 despite same games as Murphy, terrible
Soligo - 21 games - not top 10, coaches don't rate him
Rachele - 21 games - not top 10, SANFL for you
Pedlar - 21 games - not top 10, get in the bin
Fogarty - 21 games - not top 10, pathetic
Thilthorpe - 21 games, not top 10, waste of space
Rankine - 20 games, equal 4th
(Jones - 18 games - equal 8th)

 

[WetCrow1991]

It is obvious that Murphy at 6th got votes for trying hard because no one with a functioning brain would consider 6th truly reflective of his output.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Ah they did

The top 10 vote getters per game.

5.7 Dawson (23)
5.2 Laird (22)
4.6 Rankine (20)
4.6 Hinge (20)
4.5 Walker (22)
4.4 Jones (18)
4.1 Murphy (22)
4.0 Smith (22)
3.6 Milera (22)
3.5 Keays (23)

I gather the likes of Crouch & Worrell would have been top 10 based on average votes per game.

 

[Danger in Texas]

So here's the players who played more than 20 games according to the coaches

Dawson - 23 games - winner
Keays - 23 games - equal 8th
O'Brien - 23 games - not top 10, horrendous year
Laird - 22 games - 2nd
Smith - 22 games - 7th
Milera - 22 games - 10th
Hinge - 22 games - equal 4th
Sloane - 22 games - not top 10, s**t year
Murphy - 22 games - 6th
Walker - 22 games - 3rd
Michalanney - 22 games - not top 10 despite same games as Murphy, terrible
Soligo - 21 games - not top 10, coaches don't rate him
Rachele - 21 games - not top 10, SANFL for you
Pedlar - 21 games - not top 10, get in the bin
Fogarty - 21 games - not top 10, pathetic
Thilthorpe - 21 games, not top 10, waste of space
Rankine - 20 games, equal 4th
(Jones - 18 games - equal 8th)

???

 

[cleanhands]

So here's the players who played more than 20 games according to the coaches

Dawson - 23 games - winner
Keays - 23 games - equal 8th
O'Brien - 23 games - not top 10, horrendous year
Laird - 22 games - 2nd
Smith - 22 games - 7th
Milera - 22 games - 10th
Hinge - 22 games - equal 4th
Sloane - 22 games - not top 10, s**t year
Murphy - 22 games - 6th
Walker - 22 games - 3rd
Michalanney - 22 games - not top 10 despite same games as Murphy, terrible
Soligo - 21 games - not top 10, coaches don't rate him
Rachele - 21 games - not top 10, SANFL for you
Pedlar - 21 games - not top 10, get in the bin
Fogarty - 21 games - not top 10, pathetic
Thilthorpe - 21 games, not top 10, waste of space
Rankine - 20 games, equal 4th
(Jones - 18 games - equal 8th)

Agree with MM

 

[Scorpus]

???

We just have to accept our young players are no good. Not even close to the level of Murphy or Smith

 

[WetCrow1991]

We just have to accept our young players are no good. Not even close to the level of Murphy or Smith

Murphy just needs to up his game a little and he'll be an AA lock for sure!

 

[Scorpus]

Murphy just needs to up his game a little and he'll be an AA lock for sure!

3rd best forward in the best forward line in the league. Would be a shot for AA and probably get a nice big contract at any club that came asking

 

[Danger in Texas]

We just have to accept our young players are no good. Not even close to the level of Murphy or Smith

Moreso not getting what the gist of your post is, bagging Sloane/ROB + a bunch of our young guys in the same post

 

[George Kramer]

Really annoying they don’t release game by game voting, what are they afraid of?

 

[WetCrow1991]

3rd best forward in the best forward line in the league. Would be a shot for AA and probably get a nice big contract at any club that came asking

Oh and they will be banging down the door to sign him up! What would we do with out him!

 

[Danger in Texas]

Really annoying they don’t release game by game voting, what are they afraid of?

Do any other clubs do that?

 

[Danger in Texas]

Re: the young guys, twas sarcasm. ROB and Sloane deserve the lashing though

Ahh I see

Sarcasm wasn’t quite obvious enough lol

 

[Scorpus]

Moreso not getting what the gist of your post is, bagging Sloane/ROB + a bunch of our young guys in the same post

Well ROB didn't manage top 10 despite playing every game while the other players couldn't beat Murphy for a top 10 spot despite playing similar games. So it's clear the coaches thought they were not very good.

The stuff about young players was mostly joking but it is disappointing the coaches didn't rate a single one of them

 

[dylan123]

When a s**t role player finishes 6th in the B&F our list is ****ed

Don't coaches vote based on playing roles rather than BOG etc? If so and Murphy playing the entire season pretty much indicates they believe he played the role they wanted him to.

Don't agree with the results but can see how it happens with that method.

 

[George Kramer]

Do any other clubs do that?

Don’t know, we used to

 

[crow2crow]

Not sure of already posted, confirmation Doods was the there

of course because he wanted to stay

its us releasing him

 

[Danger in Texas]

Not sure of already posted, confirmation Doods was the there

No ill will towards Doods, for mine

I know there’s a group on social media which will always call him a Judas, but I don’t think that’s deserving

 

[AusTerran]

Don't coaches vote based on playing roles rather than BOG etc? If so and Murphy playing the entire season pretty much indicates they believe he played the role they wanted him to.

Don't agree with the results but can see how it happens with that method.

So the expectations on Murphy was so low he got points for not being so shit is the only way I can see it lol

 

[Sanders]

Milera? Murphy and Sloane played better than Milera????

Milera was ass though

 

[dylan123]

So the expectations on Murphy was so low he got points for not being so s**t is the only way I can see it lol

In some ways, I'd say so.

Murphy's role is to just be a maniac that attacks/adds pressure. So as long as he's out there putting in the effort to chase, I dare say he gets the pass mark.

 

[Scorpus]

In some ways, I'd say so.

Murphy's role is to just be a maniac that attacks/adds pressure. So as long as he's out there putting in the effort to chase, I dare say he gets the pass mark.

I'd love to know what Michalanney's role was and how he failed to do it to a better standard than Murphy with his role

 

[ABAB]

I'd love to know what Michalanney's role was and how he failed to do it to a better standard than Murphy with his role

MM polled very well early in the season but faded late in the season which is understandable given his 1st year.

 

[jackster83]

Well done Dawson. Will go down as one of our best trades.

Again though, it's worrying that no Hamish draftees polled highly. Enough is enough surely.

 

[jackster83]

So here's the players who played more than 20 games according to the coaches

Dawson - 23 games - winner
Keays - 23 games - equal 8th
O'Brien - 23 games - not top 10, horrendous year
Laird - 22 games - 2nd
Smith - 22 games - 7th
Milera - 22 games - 10th
Hinge - 22 games - equal 4th
Sloane - 22 games - not top 10, s**t year
Murphy - 22 games - 6th
Walker - 22 games - 3rd
Michalanney - 22 games - not top 10 despite same games as Murphy, terrible
Soligo - 21 games - not top 10, coaches don't rate him
Rachele - 21 games - not top 10, SANFL for you
Pedlar - 21 games - not top 10, get in the bin
Fogarty - 21 games - not top 10, pathetic
Thilthorpe - 21 games, not top 10, waste of space
Rankine - 20 games, equal 4th
(Jones - 18 games - equal 8th)

That's two years in a row that ROB doesn't make the top ten.

Makes it even more confusing that we don't bother trying to find an upgrade or long term replacement.