Position 2023 Rookies

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Yes ....I'm easily scared

There are valid reasons for not taking JvR, but ONLY kicking 3 vs WC isn't one of them

 

[Silky23]

There are valid reasons for not taking JvR, but ONLY kicking 3 vs WC isn't one of them

I think he means he only had 3 kicks of the footy. Kicked 2.1

Week before he had 5 kicks and 9 touches, but also 6 tackles for his 3 goals.

Gotta remember WaynesWorld19, the game was very open flowing after quarter time and the others were able to feast instead

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I think he means he only had 3 kicks of the footy. Kicked 2.1

My bad, one thousand apologies.

 

[54Dogs]

JVR feels like a super quick cash grab that lasts 2 weeks max, but scarily is still close to the best option with bench cash so scarce. Ryan obvs the better medium term option but a slower burn

 

[WaynesWorld19]

My bad, one thousand apologies.

I just got off the phone to my therapist .....she's saying you were mean

 

[swindle]

Man there are no rookies coming in, feel like I need to make a downgrade like Jones > Young to guaranteed $ for a premo next week

 

[THECHIEFTON]

I was gonna get JVR but only have players like Greene, Ratagolea, Phillapou, Mackenzie and Baker to trade out.

Greene and Ratagolea just had decent games. Might even trade donut Madden to JVR just incised he ends up a decent cash cow.

 

[Gold Rocks]

Is it to late to go max michalanney? I have Liam Jones

19

Liam Jones

Age

33

Ht

199cm

Wt

98kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

9.4

2star

K

6.5

3star

HB

2.9

3star

M

4.3

4star

T

2.0

4star

MG

134.5

2star

D

7.6

2star

K

6.1

3star

HB

1.4

1star

M

4.1

4star

T

1.4

2star

MG

116.3

2star

D

9.4

3star

K

7.4

3star

HB

2.0

2star

M

4.0

4star

T

2.2

4star

on field and goater on bench . Or do I grab Sampson Ryan instead of van roo?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Man there are no rookies coming in, feel like I need to make a downgrade like Jones > Young to guaranteed $ for a premo next week

Roberts and Johnson options this week.

 

[timbo3195]

If you had to trade Hollands or Mackenzie, who do you trade?
It was Hollands all week until I realised I can loop him tonight.. and Mackenzie is on the extended bench.

 

[jdwood]

I’m going early on D Williams.

What could go wrong?

Edit: decided to go JVR for the quick cash instead. With DPP next week there is still an opportunity to grab Williams next week if he shines.

 

[King_Steele]

Who do I take then?

I already have Greene, Caminiti and Chandler. If I get van Rooyen, I can't get Williams next week (another FWD only rookie). Also if I take van Rooyen, it means he's on field, and Mackenzie goes to the bench. Also I can't loop my D6.
Same goes with Ryan (and I already have Esava at R3).
A DEF rookie is perfect for me, I can get Young, but he is a KPD, so won't score more than 60.

All crap options in my eyes

Young vs van Rooyen vs Ryan vs take a punt and go early on somebody

I don't think any of van Rooyen, Ryan and Young make me more than $100k

I’m passing on JVR mate

 

[Kadog]

Who do I take then?

I already have Greene, Caminiti and Chandler. If I get van Rooyen, I can't get Williams next week (another FWD only rookie). Also if I take van Rooyen, it means he's on field, and Mackenzie goes to the bench. Also I can't loop my D6.
Same goes with Ryan (and I already have Esava at R3).
A DEF rookie is perfect for me, I can get Young, but he is a KPD, so won't score more than 60.

All crap options in my eyes

Young vs van Rooyen vs Ryan vs take a punt and go early on somebody

I don't think any of van Rooyen, Ryan and Young make me more than $100k

I’m kinda in the same boat. Upgraded Doc>Dawson but have to trade in a rookie. Don’t like any on offer. JVR doesn’t really appeal with Fritz BB TMac all demanding the ball. Gawn incoming. Too many question marks but might be the only option at this point. Moyle is another I’m considering with Witts mystery injury. Could get a decent run and a quick cash grab.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Is it to late to go max michalanney? I have Liam Jones on field and goater on bench . Or do I grab Sampson Ryan instead of van roo?

Last week to get Michalanney .....goes up min $50K this week

 

[stevebbb]

I took van Rooyen to fund my Doch trade, but I can still make changes.

Petty and TMac named in the backline, van Rooyen named on the bench. I just can't shake the feeling JVR is going to get dropped next week. Just the way Goodwin talks about Brown and McDonald, he loves them.

This is going to burn me up. Inevitably I'll make the wrong decision lol.

 

[stevebbb]

Roberts and Johnson options this week.

Good catch.

Roberts is $110k and has a BE 49, you can definitely wait a week for him.

Johnson has a BE of 33, so you'd expect him to rise this week, so he's an option this week. I need to do some research, I know nothing about him. I might take him.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Good catch.

Roberts is $110k and has a BE 49, you can definitely wait a week for him.

Johnson has a BE of 33, so you'd expect him to rise this week, so he's an option this week. I need to do some research, I know nothing about him. I might take him.

Both can probably wait a week. Might be the sub most weeks.

 

[king43]

Will constable be sub?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Will constable be sub?

Possible ....could destroy his cash gen ....nervous times

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Possible ....could destroy his cash gen ....nervous times

I ****ing hope he's sub, I need the extra cash, could help me get into the 108,000's ...... eventually.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Huge cheer went up at Essendon training today. I’d say either a Voss or Montgomerie debut, Voss the more likely but Montgomerie would be better from an SC perspective.

Idk what the cheer was for unless Voss is the sub.

 

[swindle]

Both can probably wait a week. Might be the sub most weeks.

Think I'll take a punt on Johnson, a quick look on the freo board suggests they are happy he is getting a run. Could backfire but need the $.

 

[stevebbb]

Think I'll take a punt on Johnson, a quick look on the freo board suggests they are happy he is getting a run. Could backfire but need the $.

I'm tempted to take Johnson too.

He had 38 touches for Peel a couple of weeks ago.

He managed to find a fair bit of the ball in both AFL games coming on as the sub.

6 touches in a quarter in rd3
5 touches in a quarter in rd4 (he had 6 CBAs too)

BE of 33. Even with a score of 60, he'll only go up to $135k-$140k. So you can definitely wait week.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I'm tempted to take Johnson too.

He had 38 touches for Peel a couple of weeks ago.

He managed to find a fair bit of the ball in both AFL games coming on as the sub.

6 touches in a quarter in rd3
5 touches in a quarter in rd4 (he had 6 CBAs too)

BE of 33. Even with a score of 60, he'll only go up to $135k-$140k. So you can definitely wait week.

It's probably worth paying a bit more to see if he is the sub again next week.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Williams @ Port named for his second match. Let's hope he goes well and becomes a good rookie.