Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[Billyc]

At this point we're honestly not sure how or even IF the Massi/Gunner/Ginny trades go.
Our focus is settling the Chol/Kosi trades first and at this point we seem to be locked into a staring contest.
Someone will blink tomorrow, probably in the arvo.
It's already gone on far too long. We thought we had it done Monday morning until Suns changed their minds on the offers.

If Massimo can just be taken as a DFA, why bother with Dodoro?

 

[Sizzlesilk]

If Massimo can just be taken as a DFA, why bother with Dodoro?

Cos despite it being Dodo…
It’s nearly always the right thing to do.
We don’t know what favours we will need in the future.

 

[Dewnior]

We thought we had it done Monday morning until Suns changed their minds on the offers.

AFL got in their ear again ey?

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

At this point we're honestly not sure how or even IF the Massi/Gunner/Ginny trades go.
Our focus is settling the Chol/Kosi trades first and at this point we seem to be locked into a staring contest.
Someone will blink tomorrow, probably in the arvo.
It's already gone on far too long. We thought we had it done Monday morning until Suns changed their minds on the offers.

Tell the Suns to shove Chol where the Sun dont shine!

Massimo via delisted F/A

Wright will deal for Ginnivan he knows how get shit done

Kosi maybe done when the tigers ruck gets to the crows they have been offered pick 41 and a f2.

Gunston a late pick … or not at all.

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Cos despite it being Dodo…
It’s nearly always the right thing to do.
We don’t know what favours we will need in the future.

We tried up to them to accept the pick or we go via DFA

 

[Dewnior]

Cos despite it being Dodo…
It’s nearly always the right thing to do.
We don’t know what favours we will need in the future.

I feel dirty relying on future favours from *.

Feck em I say.

 

[TFFM]

Ginnivan deal could be done first of them all.

 

[Sizzlesilk]

At this point we're honestly not sure how or even IF the Massi/Gunner/Ginny trades go.
Our focus is settling the Chol/Kosi trades first and at this point we seem to be locked into a staring contest.
Someone will blink tomorrow, probably in the arvo.
It's already gone on far too long. We thought we had it done Monday morning until Suns changed their minds on the offers.

That’s incorrect.
We are absolutely working the Ginnivan and Mass deals.
Ginni has been in the pipeline for weeks. Gunston also.

It’s not a case of “we’ll think about it once we finish this”…

We are flat chat… and as I said weeks ago… we have not died wondering this trade period.
Some of our work this year will take effect next year.

 

[Elhawko]

I

Correct.

However, I agree with eveything else Kingy said. I may be in a minority here but I'd rather not have Jack, whom I love as much as any other Hawk, taking up a spot in the 23 - or on the list for that matter - at the expense of a young prospect.

That said, if Sam reckons otherwise, I'll back our coach in 100%.

agree.

View attachment 1833290

Future captain.

 

[killerspud]

View attachment 1833290

Well now that everyone knows it's Ginnivan who filmed it if it does get out Jack will be need to find a good lawyer

Remind me again why we are looking to bring this thing into our club

 

[KermitJagger]

Cos despite it being Dodo…
It’s nearly always the right thing to do.
We don’t know what favours we will need in the future.

Eh I don't buy this anymore. Carlton ****ed Gold Coast over with Martin a few years back, only for Gold Coast to be offering them an absolute sweetheart deal on Hollands now. Good will and favours rarely seem to pay off.

 

[asanque]

Cos despite it being Dodo…
It’s nearly always the right thing to do.
We don’t know what favours we will need in the future.

1. Dodoro is more treacherous than the Freys, no chance of ever getting a favour returned.

2. He is leaving anyway after this trade period.

Take Massimo as DFA and concentrate on other deals.

 

[Sizzlesilk]

Well now that everyone knows it's Ginnivan who filmed it if it does get out Jack will be need to find a good lawyer

Remind me again why we are looking to bring this thing into our club

I find it highly amusing what people complete ignored from our 08 group … just because they were ours and winning flags…

 

[Hawks2011]

It does make me laugh how people take whatever an apparent “ITK” says as gospel.

 

[James Colorado]

Weird that dodo is bothering playing hardball then, just to be a w***er? Or doesn’t genuinely know anything

Why would he change now?

 

[Luke_Hodgey_15]

That’s incorrect.
We are absolutely working the Ginnivan and Mass deals.
Ginni has been in the pipeline for weeks. Gunston also.

It’s not a case of “we’ll think about it once we finish this”…

We are flat chat… and as I said weeks ago… we have not died wondering this trade period.
Some of our work this year will take effect next year.

Smith and Houston?

 

[Sizzlesilk]

Smith and Houston?

Houston was on our radar.
Not sure if it progressed.
Discussions were had.

Smith we worked overtime on.

 

[Luke_Hodgey_15]

Houston was on our radar.
Not sure if it progressed.
Discussions were had.

Good mates with Karl Amon, maybe they want to play together again without the ferals yelling over the fence

 

[KeeperLeaguer]

It’s not a case of “we’ll think about it once we finish this”…

I didn't say this was the case, I said our main priority is Kosi/Chol. The other deals might get done before or maybe last or not at all but Kosi/Chol is where we're at firstly.

 

[Sizzlesilk]

I didn't say this was the case, I said our main priority is Kosi/Chol. The other deals might get done before or maybe last or not at all but Kosi/Chol is where we're at firstly.

Some might well be already done.

 

[HawksTHteam2beat]

Am surprised Breust for Ginnivan hasn’t been brought up yet. What an absolute joke it would be if Hawthorn did that deal. Breust should eventually retire a Hawk & then become part of our coaching staff

 

[asanque]

Assuming we get Gunston back.

Chol just seems a bit superfluous with Lewis, Gunston, Breust, Ryan (and ideally Meek/Reeves developing a good tandem).

Chol won't even get a game at GC under Hardwick, they have no leverage.

I thought Chol was great in the VFL grand final but no way he is worth paying anymore than a late 3rd rounder.

 

[Luke_Hodgey_15]

Am surprised Breust for Ginnivan hasn’t been brought up yet. What an absolute joke it would be if Hawthorn did that deal. Breust should eventually retire a Hawk & then become part of our coaching staff

David King is that you? Created a story and ripped into it as being rubbish in a single breath

 

[KermitJagger]

Assuming we get Gunston back.

Chol just seems a bit superfluous with Lewis, Gunston, Breust, Ryan (and ideally Meek/Reeves developing a good tandem).

Chol won't even get a game at GC under Hardwick, they have no leverage.

I thought Chol was great in the VFL grand final but no way he is worth paying anymore than a late 3rd rounder.

I think we see Chol being more of a ruck than forward. We tried with Meek and Reeves but neither had the nous to impact the goals, then we tried with Kosi who couldn't impact the ruck. Chol provides a better balance.

 

[Big Hotdog]

Assuming we get Gunston back.

Chol just seems a bit superfluous with Lewis, Gunston, Breust, Ryan (and ideally Meek/Reeves developing a good tandem).

Chol won't even get a game at GC under Hardwick, they have no leverage.

I thought Chol was great in the VFL grand final but no way he is worth paying anymore than a late 3rd rounder.

I agree. If GC are playing ball a little to hard then walk.
Focus on other deals.