Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[Flamin Joe]

I'd be super excited to get Ginnivan. It would save an otherwise terrible trade period for us.

Terrible? Is this your first trade period? Things generally don't happen until the last day of trade week.

 

[TylerDurden]

How on earth are we still talking about getting the Chol/ Kosi deal over the line. Both B/C graders. Had to be done earlier. Now we scramble.

 

[perrdan86]

I'd be super excited to get Ginnivan. It would save an otherwise terrible trade period for us.

Coming from someone who has worked as a list manager and been involved in so many deals that went through quickly and seamlessly.

 

[Hawks_Footy]

Give the suns our final offer tomorrow morning with a 6pm deadline.. if not accepted we move on and get the other deals done!

 

[Rocket72]

Mitch Cleary saying Ginnivan is exploring his options and it is down to staying at Collingwood or asking for a trade to Hawthorn who have offered him a 4 year deal

Pies confirmed that he's asked to be traded.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Least if we get Ginnevan, wingard can teach him the ropes with the umpires or lack thereof

And moore

 

[Rocket72]

Give the suns our final offer tomorrow morning with a 6pm deadline.. if not accepted we move on and get the other deals done!

The only deal potentially holding up Chol is Kosi, don't see why the deal would be holding up anything else.

 

[TylerDurden]

 

[Dewnior]

How on earth are we still talking about getting the Chol/ Kosi deal over the line. Both B/C graders. Had to be done earlier. Now we scramble.

There's worse spuds wanting to be traded that aren't getting where they wanna go

 

[HedgeFund]

I'd be super excited to get Ginnivan. It would save an otherwise terrible trade period for us.

You rating it a D - thus far?

I’m outraged!

 

[butlers hawks]

Pies confirmed that he's asked to be traded.

That was run back from the reports

 

[The Generals Helmet]

4 years means Collingwood will ask for heaps

 

[Rocket72]

I really thought we were going to have a trade to announce this afternoon. How naive of me.

Big last day of trade period, as usual!

 

[Burtman]

Is anyone else worried about the 4+1 year deal we’ve offered chol? Doesn’t seem like a move you make if you have a good kpf lined up for the next trade period. I’m guessing we haven’t made too many inroads with next years free agents

 

[burger09]

4 years for Ginnivan.....

 

[Rocket72]

That was run back from the reports

I wonder if the original report was correct and the Pies told Ginnivan to calm down, and that if we don't offer them a decent trade he will be playing with them next year....

 

[daniel23]

Looks like we have finally got with the times in offering enticing contracts to get players across. No one else would be willing to offer chol and ginnavin 4 years each.

 

[CHUBBSS]

I wonder if the original report was correct and the Pies told Ginnivan to calm down, and that if we don't offer them a decent trade he will be playing with them next year....

This should be treated as a fire sale, GW just pretending it’s not

 

[Dazza the Viking]

Suns asking too much for Chol, hope we don’t cave

 

[Fluro Boots]

Is anyone else worried about the 4+1 year deal we’ve offered chol? Doesn’t seem like a move you make if you have a good kpf lined up for the next trade period. I’m guessing we haven’t made too many inroads with next years free agents

Dont mond it as he can play as a ruckman as well. David Hale style role perhaps

 

[suburb whispers]

Hope we were all buckled up today…

 

[hawkmang]

Hope we were all buckled up today…

Hopefully Mark doesn’t fall asleep at the wheel tomorrow

 

[BobHawk]

Looks like we have finally got with the times in offering enticing contracts to get players across. No one else would be willing to offer chol and ginnavin 4 years each.

Suggest that no other club would offer those contracts for a reason. The risk for us is that we get stuck with players that don't deliver. Need to assume some risk but IMO, both Chol and Ginnivan are fringe.

 

[AlwaysHawks15]

Thing is he probably has a top like that stashed away at his folks place

 

[Since 2001]

Sleepy mark, has taken playing hardball to the next level