Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[LunchboxLegend]

Ooops - I think someone may have accidentally dildo-ed themself!!!

 

[Rocket72]

No need to trade for D’Ambrosio.
Chol trade values at 27 too high would add 54 but get 38 back and the late picks and 74. Move 74 for Gunston.
38,62,63,66,71 is about pick 18 after discount for McCabe and once matches occur prior which I guess will take 38 in 3 and the late ones in about 6 picks then it will be more like the equivalent of pick 10.

It'g going to be tight if McCabe goes top 10 (I don't think he will, my guess would be 15 - 20). Can we use future picks to generate the points?

 

[DrkNyt]

The Batman calls upon you Mark. God speed

 

[DogDaySonny]

We better not give up 2nd rounders (current or future) for Ginnivan. FRINGE PLAYERS ARE NOT WORTH 2ND ROUND PICKS

Also if we do bring in Ginnivan, it's gonna be Breust, Moore, Ginnivan (and Butler) as small forwards. Seems unlikely we'll follow that by drafting the Wiz

So it could be: Chol, Ginnivan, Gunston, Massimo
Draftees: Curtin, McCabe, Dear +/- someone else

Bramble + Fergus delisted

Further, he's the guy who recorded McStay... I don't think Collingwood wants to keep him. Note to Hawks if we get him: Do your celebrating in private.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

I'm pretty sure MM, being the astute operator he is, knew the rule all along.

Mark doesn't sleep, he absorbs

 

[DrAbs]

Played 14 games and in the GF side, at 20. Fringe player might be a tad harsh.

Sure. If McStay & Adams were playing, he wouldn't have that GF medal. Also I'm curious as to how many games he was the sub? We'd make more use of him with Brocky leaving. He's got the talent but he wasn't in their best 22 if we're being real.

 

[Rocket72]

I'm pretty sure MM, being the astute operator he is, knew the rule all along.

It's not an obscure rule, so you'd hope so. He might not have known that he was offered a third year as rookie, I figured that the bombers were offering him one year on their main list.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

It's not an obscure rule, so you'd hope so. He might not have known that he was offered a third year as rookie, I figured that the bombers were offering him one year on their main list.

I assume Dodo knew it and tried it on, thinking we'd get sucked into accepting.

 

[Holy Rioli]

Further, he's the guy who recorded McStay... I don't think Collingwood wants to keep him. Note to Hawks if we get him: Do your celebrating in private.

recorded McStay doing what?

 

[Tall poppy Syndrome]

Like Ginnivan's work, and we'd likely play him as a full time small forward where I think his best footy has been played. Hope we don't pay much though, not a good history of collingwood players improving when they come to us. Wonder what Tony Woods is up to these days...

Ian Bremner says Hi.

 

[DrAbs]

It'g going to be tight if McCabe goes top 10 (I don't think he will, my guess would be 15 - 20). Can we use future picks to generate the points?

Wouldn't sweat on McCabe if he goes top 10. We land Ginnivan, unless WCE trade Pick 1, we can get Curtin. Would be less worry abt draft points and we could make use of our later picks.

 

[Tall poppy Syndrome]

Ian Bremner says Hi.

From 1967.

 

[Iceman!]

 

[Rocket72]

Sure. If McStay & Adams were playing, he wouldn't have that GF medal. Also I'm curious as to how many games he was the sub? We'd make more use of him with Brocky leaving. He's got the talent but he wasn't in their best 22 if we're being real.

Good points. Hoping we are offering around a third round pick or equiv. Wouldn't be outrageous to offer a bit more, being so young we deserve to back ourselves to improve his deficiencies.

 

[butlers hawks]

Something that hasnt been spoken about in here but absolutely should be is the effort that DrkNyt has put into his brand and I for one respect it. Has done well to keep it up

 

[ralphwiggum]

Only time I've ever agreed with Chad, way overs for a guy who has played a handful of good games.

Besides how good or bad this could potentially be for the scum, it makes me seethe that we've had to pay for it as well in-kind

 

[Lickmesocks]

Sleepy will be up all night tonight.

 

[Billyc]

Further, he's the guy who recorded McStay... I don't think Collingwood wants to keep him. Note to Hawks if we get him: Do your celebrating in private.

If true, that has Paton written all over it, so hopefully untrue.

 

[Rocket72]

Wouldn't sweat on McCabe if he goes top 10. We land Ginnivan, unless WCE trade Pick 1, we can get Curtin. Would be less worry abt draft points and we could make use of our later picks.

??

 

[PenAndPaper]

We better not give up 2nd rounders (current or future) for Ginnivan. FRINGE PLAYERS ARE NOT WORTH 2ND ROUND PICKS

Also if we do bring in Ginnivan, it's gonna be Breust, Moore, Ginnivan (and Butler) as small forwards. Seems unlikely we'll follow that by drafting the Wiz

So it could be: Chol, Ginnivan, Gunston, Massimo
Draftees: Curtin, McCabe, Dear +/- someone else

Bramble + Fergus delisted

He just won a flag

 

[Kuuz]

Always knew Phil was the brains of this operation

 

[kirbatron]

yes Phil!!

 

[f4zz]

Of all our targets. We must land Chol. lewis needs a partner in crime for next year. Period.

 

[MadDawg]

recorded McStay doing what?

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

Ooops - I think someone may have accidentally dildo-ed themself!!!

And wasnt Twomey playing his duffle coat wearing part the other day with a suggestion on what pick the hawks should give up to Ess in a trade.