Resource 2024 AFL Draft discussion thread (Wed Nov 20 to Fri Nov 22)

Which realistically available player SHOULD we pick at #4?

  • Sid Draper

  • Jagga Smith

  • Harvey Langford


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Want him. I can’t see any weakness in his game, only speed, evasiveness, ball winning, clean hands, good decision making, poise, good disposal, puts the ball to his team mates advantage.

I don’t get this lack of hurt factor. Surely if you’re effectively and consistently getting the ball to your teammates that’s hurt factor?
I like all of the suggested possibilities at our pick. They all have great potential.

Add any one of them on top of Curtin and our midfield has a real chance of breaking new ground in the coming seasons.
 
Last edited:
Want him. I can’t see any weakness in his game, only speed, evasiveness, ball winning, clean hands, good decision making, poise, good disposal, puts the ball to his team mates advantage.

I don’t get this lack of hurt factor. Surely if you’re effectively and consistently getting the ball to your teammates that’s hurt factor?
disclaimer : I have only watched his highlights but love what I see.

People throw around the term hurt factor too loosely imo and only see it with meters gained, loving
a lad kicking it 50 m breaking a line.
I read somewhere Jagga’s kicks averaged under 20m , but at 82 % de and half contested, thirty odd times a game.
To me that’s is hurt factor.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

disclaimer : I have only watched his highlights but love what I see.

People throw around the term hurt factor too loosely imo and only see it with meters gained, loving
a lad kicking it 50 m breaking a line.
I read somewhere Jagga’s kicks averaged under 20m , but at 82 % de and half contested, thirty odd times a game.
To me that’s is hurt factor.
Yep

There's death by a thousand cuts players (Pendlebury, Sam Mitchell)

Then there's explosive, splash play guys (Petracca, Dangerfield, Dusty)

Jagga appears to be in the former category. I like him because we have never really had this type. We've had the crash n bash bulls. Not a lot of nuance or thought. He seems like a smart footballer and I'd love to have him.
 
Yep

There's death by a thousand cuts players (Pendlebury, Sam Mitchell)

Then there's explosive, splash play guys (Petracca, Dangerfield, Dusty)

Jagga appears to be in the former category. I like him because we have never really had this type. We've had the crash n bash bulls. Not a lot of nuance or thought. He seems like a smart footballer and I'd love to have him.
You could argue Soligo has quite a bit of the former about him, too

Jagga’s more dynamic than Jake, though
 
I like all of the suggested possibilities at our pick. They all have great potential.

Add any one of them on top of Curtin and our midfield has a real chance of breaking new ground in the coming seasons.
Couldn't agree more.

Just feel constantly on edge that we will over complicate this.

Any of the top 4 are great for us. Just take whoever is there! PLEASE
 
Jagga Smith potentially sliding to pick 4 would be peak recruiters overthinking it... What's the knock? He attracts the footy too much in the contest and uses a 1-2 to get out? I'd be more than happy with the lad at 4....
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remove this Banner Ad

Resource 2024 AFL Draft discussion thread (Wed Nov 20 to Fri Nov 22)

Back
Top