Strapping Young Lad
Moderator
- Apr 19, 2006
- 101,008
- 253,788
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Storm, Spurs, Socceroos
- Moderator
- #18,956
2024 Picks
2025 Picks
2025 Picks
Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread
- Thread starter TylerDurden
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Sep 8, 2014
- 17,487
- 25,086
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- There are no other teams
Freo just have to dig in because no way Bolton goes back to the Tiggers, he has checked out.
We end up with pick 13, we get to draft night and tell Geelong we're taking him unless they send us their first this year and their first next.
We still end up with two firsts next year, we **** over Geelong, we find a pick around the worth of a Whitlock!
Oof, feeling this... 40 next year
- Jun 28, 2013
- 32,899
- 50,842
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Add ten and then stop whinging
To be fair both West Coast and Freo seem prepared to offer a top 15 pick for Liam Baker, and Gold Coast are begging to gift them pick 6 for Dan Rioli.
Richmond have hit the rebuild jackpot in terms of players wanting out when they need them to, and other clubs willing tp pay overs due to their own reasons.
Can’t wait for it to be called tanking..
- Jun 28, 2013
- 32,899
- 50,842
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Yeah it’s a shame we didn’t go down the same route in a way but of course some level of leadership/experience continuity helps. Hardwick going out the door earlier made this transition more likely
Sturty
Club Legend
- Sep 15, 2014
- 1,098
- 3,588
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Jesus the west coke board is FULL of brain rot
'Carlton F1 and Hawks F1 for Barrass'
'Carlton F1 and Hawks F1 for Barrass'
The most games Tom has ever played in a season is 19....he doesnt scream durability and is now is 29 years old
If WC dont think a F1 and a F2 is reasonable just walk away from the deal and say sorry Tom but you can thank your current club for the position you are in
If WC dont think a F1 and a F2 is reasonable just walk away from the deal and say sorry Tom but you can thank your current club for the position you are in
No thanks, I suspect, dispite what they are conveying, the Bulldogs are happy for Smith to depart.
Bit like a high maintenance partner, good for a while but wears you down over time.
Meh, it's called haggling all teams do it. They are just trying to see if they can squeeze just a bit more from Fremantle by demanding more than they think they will get.
Us supporters need to take our fan glasses off sometimes and recognise it's not always about what a team rates a player as when it comes to negotiations.
- Jul 13, 2015
- 38,640
- 43,790
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
If the Blues dont get Houston they have 12 and 14. There is no way they wouldnt use one of those on him. Geelong finished 3rd. The idea that Smith slips out all the way to their pick is crazy.
So if Geelong dont offer something proper to the Dogs, they then need to mess around with their picks to swap for a pick in the top 10.
Hell, would Essendon go for Smith with a top 10 pick?
This 'walk Smith to the Draft' nonsense will bite the Cats, and I would love to see that happen.
GWS currently have picks 15 and 16.
Once trade period is over, if Smith is still in Limbo MM would be in the ear of GWS to trade them a F1 and change for pick 16 to snipe Smith.
That would be delicious.
GWS currently have picks 15 and 16.
Once trade period is over, if Smith is still in Limbo MM would be in the ear of GWS to trade them a F1 and change for pick 16 to snipe Smith.
That would be delicious.
The Golden Glenferrie
Norm Smith Medallist
AFL would stop the draft, find a low first rounder out of thin air to gift Geelong for playing
There is no way that Smith will go to the draft. I don't believe it for a second. It's the only possible threat to get Geelong to increase their offer given every other club has dropped out.
- Jul 13, 2015
- 38,640
- 43,790
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Maybe a few years ago when Hocking was running the AFL and leaking GCS salary cap info to Geelong. These days I dont think they have as many tentacles on switches.
EFA
Lol sounds like our situation
Richmond will have probably 4 or 5 picks before Geelong.
They would be crazy not to use one of them on Smith.
They will easily have Salary Cap space to pay whatever he is asking, and his age profile actually suits their rebuild. Even if they take 4 or 5 years to become competitive again, Smith will still only be 28 and in his prime.
The Jet From Poowong
Mr September
- Sep 15, 2009
- 5,355
- 11,626
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Death riding Carlton in 2025
Quoting Tom Morris
The SydneySwans are in a similar position to GC. They have elite 2025 academy talent, so are more interested in next year's draft than other clubs.
So I wonder how strong the Swans desire is to release their 2024 - 2 x R1 this year?
What would they consider reasonable or enticing? I will give it a go
2024 - 19 (index 948) & 22 (index 845) = 1,793
2025 - 1 x R1 (18) - (index current 985)
2025 - 2 x R2 (36) - (index current 2 x 502 - likely more)
= 1,989 total current index
Would the Eagles then accept
IN - 19, 22 & 33
OUT - 26 & F3 to Hawthorn
Value = 948 + 845 + 563 - 729 - 483 = 1,144 equivalent to pick 14
The SydneySwans are in a similar position to GC. They have elite 2025 academy talent, so are more interested in next year's draft than other clubs.
So I wonder how strong the Swans desire is to release their 2024 - 2 x R1 this year?
What would they consider reasonable or enticing? I will give it a go
2024 - 19 (index 948) & 22 (index 845) = 1,793
2025 - 1 x R1 (18) - (index current 985)
2025 - 2 x R2 (36) - (index current 2 x 502 - likely more)
= 1,989 total current index
Would the Eagles then accept
IN - 19, 22 & 33
OUT - 26 & F3 to Hawthorn
Value = 948 + 845 + 563 - 729 - 483 = 1,144 equivalent to pick 14
That is way more than we've previously offered. Two firsts and a second this year?Quoting Tom Morris
The SydneySwans are in a similar position to GC. They have elite 2025 academy talent, so are more interested in next year's draft than other clubs.
So I wonder how strong the Swans desire is to release their 2024 - 2 x R1 this year?
What would they consider reasonable or enticing? I will give it a go
2024 - 19 (index 948) & 22 (index 845) = 1,793
2025 - 1 x R1 (18) - (index current 985)
2025 - 2 x R2 (36) - (index current 2 x 502 - likely more)
= 1,989 total current index
Would the Eagles then accept
IN - 19, 22 & 33
OUT - 26 & F3 to Hawthorn
Value = 948 + 845 + 563 - 729 - 483 = 1,144 equivalent to pick 14
- Nov 21, 2010
- 13,834
- 18,352
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, Detroit Pistons
Quoting Tom Morris
The SydneySwans are in a similar position to GC. They have elite 2025 academy talent, so are more interested in next year's draft than other clubs.
So I wonder how strong the Swans desire is to release their 2024 - 2 x R1 this year?
What would they consider reasonable or enticing? I will give it a go
2024 - 19 (index 948) & 22 (index 845) = 1,793
2025 - 1 x R1 (18) - (index current 985)
2025 - 2 x R2 (36) - (index current 2 x 502 - likely more)
= 1,989 total current index
Would the Eagles then accept
IN - 19, 22 & 33
OUT - 26 & F3 to Hawthorn
Value = 948 + 845 + 563 - 729 - 483 = 1,144 equivalent to pick 14
Gotta remember that the curve for draft points tails off sooner, starting next year.
Picks lose about 25% of their current value by pick 30, 50% of their current value by pick 43.
Second round picks lose a lot of value from next year for matching purposes. Thirds are almost worthless unless they're right at the start of the round.
Barrass is barely worth a straight F1. I’ll be very surprised if he gets through all games next season and the season after that. We’ll be nursing him just as we’re doing with Mitch Lewis. That’s the reality of it.
I want to eat my words. I’m not saying walk away but geewiz a 29year old with back problems. Hawks MUST have a lot of faith in his body holding up.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
I want to eat my words. I’m not saying walk away but geewiz a 29year old with back problems. Hawks MUST have a lot of faith in his body holding up.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Ned Ryerson
Future Captain
- Status
Similar threads
