Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

[extractasam]

City boy, Hawthorn supporter, Mackenzie being one of the best list managers, Roughy probably in his ear already, all things point to Hawthorn if he decides to move.

Re Bailey Smith 12 months ago.

Stop letting Geelong live rent free in your head. This board has some real issues in that department.

Are you guys talking about the same person or am I confused as anything.

Harley’s a country boy and fairly sure he was a Geelong supporter

Surely Barrass gets done for the F1 and F2 and that’s that. No picks going back and forth just move on. I’d be interested to know what our exact stance is on it all. Wouldn’t be upset if we are willing to let the trade slide but I wonder how much it affects future dealings with players

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

7:30.

For the full minute when all the trades are settled in the special room that gets the door closed a few seconds before 7.30

 

[matey]

Imagine lining up round 1 next year with Sheezel, Reid and Finn O'Sullivan.

I reckon year after next Day, Reid and Newk would look better

 

[theiaofseed]

Bailey Smith, Clayton Oliver, Bowes. No point living in denial. Best to acknowledge the best and learn from them to get better.

All 3 players aren't wanted by their clubs, can you really call Geelong masters when they just accept anyone regardless of the baggage they bring?

 

[Geead]

 

[hawkmang]

I present to you, my one eyed eagle brother…



The eagles could shit in his hands and he’d tell you it was chocolate pudding

 

[Mashy]

Are you guys talking about the same person or am I confused as anything.

Harley’s a country boy and fairly sure he was a Geelong supporter

Surely Barrass gets done for the F1 and F2 and that’s that. No picks going back and forth just move on. I’d be interested to know what our exact stance is on it all. Wouldn’t be upset if we are willing to let the trade slide but I wonder how much it affects future dealings with players

Those comments were about Bailey Smith, just to show how Harley is not necessary heading to Geelong

 

[MasterSamurai]

Does the GWS want to offload some players or maybe some players want to distance themselves from some bad apples

‘Up to 10’ Giants involved as AFL bans loom amid fresh details of ‘distasteful’ player acts

‘Up to 10’ Giants involved as AFL bans loom amid fresh details of ‘distasteful’ player acts

www.foxsports.com.au

I don't get it . If it wasn't in public and just between themselves then, who the **** is offended? Who's the loose mouth that ran off crying to the AFL? Just ****ing move on and give them a quiet warning to be careful next time to not cross boundaries from here on in.

 

[Brant]

I don't get it . If it wasn't in public and just between themselves then, who the **** is offended? Who's the loose mouth that ran off crying to the AFL? Just ****ing move on and give them a quiet warning to be careful next time to not cross boundaries from here on in.

Yes & no. I wanna think this way as well, but it may not be the case.

It seems someone(s) present were genuinely offender or are cry-baby/dobber(s), who may (or not) have an axe to grind or benefit from the drama.

We can't really speculate without knowing more.

 

[Nugett]

I don't get it . If it wasn't in public and just between themselves then, who the **** is offended? Who's the loose mouth that ran off crying to the AFL? Just ****ing move on and give them a quiet warning to be careful next time to not cross boundaries from here on in.

Sounds as if Karen went to the manager

 

[Nugett]

Yes & no. I wanna think this way as well, but it may not be the case.

It seems someone(s) present were genuinely offender or are cry-baby/dobber(s), who may (or not) have an axe to grind or benefit from the drama.

We can't really speculate without knowing more.

That’s the problem with society today. All it takes is just one person to be offended.

By the sounds of things, no laws were broken, which means most likely some crude behaviour and or language. Which some one has taken offence to.

 

[Brant]

That’s the problem with society today. All it takes is just one person to be offended.

By the sounds of things, no laws were broken, which means most likely some crude behaviour and or language. Which some one has taken offence to.

That's not necessarily a problem - that could be creating a safe place for all*. It's a blurry line (to me) as it's often hard to distinguish between "just a bit of fun" & "that really upset me", but it's all progress.

May have been degrading or racist/sexist, without being illegal.

Not saying that's befitting of AFL interaction - but also not acceptable within a professional environment.


*when I say for all, I don't mean that I think it's OK when a 14yr old can't sit a maths test because they suddenly associate as a wolf or a work colleague can't sit in an office cubicle because it offends them as a part of <XYZ group based on sexual preference> - but maybe accepting that garbage is my next evolution...

 

[Rocket72]

I don't get it . If it wasn't in public and just between themselves then, who the **** is offended? Who's the loose mouth that ran off crying to the AFL? Just ****ing move on and give them a quiet warning to be careful next time to not cross boundaries from here on in.

I’m guessing a staff member at the hotel complained

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

Harley is not a city boy ??
Anyways I’m not saying Mackenzie hasn’t been great, his track record has been fantastic, it’s just that when Geelong get a sit down with a player and put their case forward, it seems more often than not other clubs don’t stand a chance.
Plenty of examples Bailey Smith, Clayton Oliver, Bowes. Our list management is really good no doubt but we also shouldn’t be living in denial that we can’t get better. Best to acknowledge the best and learn from them to improve.

I didn't say harley was a city boy ffs. Bailey is. Read it again but slower


Plenty of examples? You've listed 3 players. 3. One who probably won't go to Geelong and another who is not there yet and prefered Hawthorn until we cooled.

Lake, Gibson, Frawley, Wingard, Omeara, Amon, Battle, Barrass... all highly sought after players who chose Hawthorn, and that's just off the top of my head.

They aren't the best at all. Piss off with this rubbish.

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

Are you guys talking about the same person or am I confused as anything.

Harley’s a country boy and fairly sure he was a Geelong supporter

Surely Barrass gets done for the F1 and F2 and that’s that. No picks going back and forth just move on. I’d be interested to know what our exact stance is on it all. Wouldn’t be upset if we are willing to let the trade slide but I wonder how much it affects future dealings with players

"Re Bailey Smith 12 months ago"

It's right there in my reply.

I can't believe I'm explaining this. I've edited my post to make it clearer

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

That’s the problem with society today. All it takes is just one person to be offended.

Big deal.

Society changes. Always has.

I'm a straight, white, middle class male in my 40s, (and im a hawthorn supporter!). Life has been pretty easy for me.

I don't get some of it, but if a 'woke' society makes it easier for marginalised kids who have always been bullied, to get by with some equality, I'm fine with it

'When you are used to privilege, equality can feel like oppression'

 

[Luke_Hodgey_15]

Big deal.

Society changes. Always has.

I'm in my 40s and I don't get some of it, but the world does and should belong to the youth.

If a 'woke' society makes it easier for marginalised kids who have always been bullied, to get by with some equality, I'm fine with it

Sent from my SM-A156E using Tapatalk

This.

Complaining that someone pulled some idiot into line is crazy weird

 

[I got the outside word]

Country boy, Geelong supporter, Mackie being one of the best list managers, danger probably in his ear already, all things point to Geelong unfortunately if he decides to move!

Hanging out with Roughy and Barrass just after the season ended. Allegedly.

 

[Mercy Seat]

Country boy, Geelong supporter, Mackie being one of the best list managers, danger probably in his ear already, all things point to Geelong unfortunately if he decides to move!

Coming directly from someone that knows him pretty well, he wants to come back to Victoria, but isn’t that sentimental about Geelong. Wants to play big games at the G every week and wants $$$

 

[I got the outside word]

Coming directly from someone that knows him pretty well, he wants to come back to Victoria, but isn’t that sentimental about Geelong. Wants to play big games at the G every week and wants $$$

I know all the super serious people that are heaps of fun at parties will say it’s a pipe dream, but, thinking about Wiz, Ginni and Harley in the same team living under the enemies skin but also backing it up means I can’t stand up for 20 minutes. There are some ingredients being stirred up in a cauldron here that makes me think we are a genuine shot at Harley in the coming years.

 

[RobHawk]

If any of Breust, Gunston or Frost retire at end of next season we will have plenty of salary cap space to accommodate Harley.
Just depends on the trade assets we possess and the eagles willingness to play ball

 

[LRobbo]

Hypothetically if Harley were to request a trade to Hawthorn whether it be next year or year after, I can’t fathom the asking price.

If the Eagles are all high and mighty on a bloke that’s 29, allegedly has a crook back and they’ve once reneged on a hand shake agreement to pay him more, what will they be like with the hottest property to move clubs since Judd?

Will be a boatload of picks and a good player at minimum.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

I know all the super serious people that are heaps of fun at parties will say it’s a pipe dream, but, thinking about Wiz, Ginni and Harley in the same team living under the enemies skin but also backing it up means I can’t stand up for 20 minutes. There are some ingredients being stirred up in a cauldron here that makes me think we are a genuine shot at Harley in the coming years.

It's not safe to think about these things when out in public or on public transport. That's how you end up on certain lists.