List Mgmt. 2024 List Management Part 2 📃

[Soapy V]

My early call. I'm not fussed on Petracca or Houston. Cost and age worry me

If we get roughly

Haynes FA
Aleer for F2
Garcia for Pick 40
First round pick (Berry - sml fwd)
2 more good draft picks
Campo twins for 3rd round pick and rookie
Pick 30 for Owies
Pick 40 for Carroll

I will be very happy

Key for 2025 is internal development and fitness

 

[yibbida]

Thanks for sharing.

I can't see why we're chasing Haynes. Honestly did anyone see him on the weekend? He was horrendous and he'll be another year older. Makes no sense

Sam Durdin can't get on the park and is very average when he does play AFL. Haynes would be an upgrade.

 

[Opium]

Sam Durdin can't get on the park and is very average when he does play AFL. Haynes would be an upgrade.

Completely different players. Haynes will be 33

 

[BigFrizz36]

Personally I'm not fussed on him either

Possible reasoning is depth for a year or so, development/coaching role within VFL (keeping it oustide of soft cap), he's a free hit and should be cheap. Obvious replacement for Marchbank and back up for McGovern while we bring in some young talent

Haynes was once a very good player. He isn't any more. Another year for him is just his pension plan. I understand the concept but hope that we can do better.

 

[Opium]

My early call. I'm not fussed on Petracca or Houston. Cost and age worry me

If we get roughly

Haynes FA
Aleer for F2
Garcia for Pick 40
First round pick (Berry - sml fwd)
2 more good draft picks
Campo twins for 3rd round pick and rookie
Pick 30 for Owies
Pick 40 for Carroll

I will be very happy

Key for 2025 is internal development and fitness

Garcia is the one. Get him and Berry via the draft and we're alot more dynamic.

 

[Blue__Balls]

Im assuming they dont and its just a case of Owies has offers at so many years and $$$$ and at this stage we aren’t in the same ballpark.

I can only assume this is why we have said he will have to wait until after the season to get an offer.

May also just be that there are a few players on the market, we're not sure who we might get and what contract requirements will be involved, so Owies needs to wait until the dust settles before we can determine what money is left in the kitty for him.

In the meantime, if he gets good offers elsewhere and decides to take one, we lose a handy but certainly not untouchable player, we hopefully get a reasonable deal for him, and we can then use that return at the draft or in our pursuit of other players of need.

It's probably a win/win for us. He's keen to stay and takes what we can afford later, or he moves on and we improve our hand for other deals.

 

[Wickzki]

Haynes happening
Deep into Leek Aleer

If anything is happening around Petracca no one is talking about it

Focus is mostly on draft and some cheap trades (apparently we have targeted someone) as it has been all year

I'm glad you were able to Leek this, Soapy.

Good news.

 

[Blue__Balls]

Enough of the Petracca and Harry chat. Let’s bring it back!!!

How good is Lord going to be

Love his work by hand, and the kid seems to have a good handle on where to run after he gives it off. Sometimes it's a block to give his teammate more time, sometimes it's into space so he can provide another handball outlet himself. Think he'll be a great understudy to Hewett.

 

[Stamos]

Love his work by hand, and the kid seems to have a good handle on where to run after he gives it off. Sometimes it's a block to give his teammate more time, sometimes it's into space so he can provide another handball outlet himself. Think he'll be a great understudy to Hewett.

Wait till he does a preseason!

 

[Soapy V]

Hmmmmm

B: Docherty Aleer McGovern
HB: Cowan Weitering Saad
C: Acres Cripps Ollie
HF: Elijah McKay Williams
F: Kemp Charlie Moir
Foll: TDK Cerra Walsh
Int from: Lord Newman Kennedy C.Durdin Silvagni Hewett Garcia Haynes B.Camporeale Binns Motlop Cincotta Boyd O'Keefe Pittonet Wilson Berry

That is a heck of line up with NO real weaknesses

Kemp, McKay share second ruck role
Elijah more midfield
Doc back in defence
Heaps of improvement in nearly every player from 2024
Youth stepping up and making a difference

FIT and in form that side can beat anyone!

 

[Blue1980]

Sam Durdin can't get on the park and is very average when he does play AFL. Haynes would be an upgrade.

Haynes an upgrade on Marchy and Durdin by virtue of him actually being available most weeks.

 

[Soapy V]

Wait till he does a preseason!

Yep. There are kids you watch and they just look AFL ready. Lord is one of those. Since being drafted he has looked likely. How he wasn't drafted defies logic. Kids just has it all

Just needs a bit more strength and a better engine for role he plays. Only 19

 

[Soapy V]

Garcia is the one. Get him and Berry via the draft and we're alot more dynamic.

Garcia Berry along with Wilson Lord Binns Oliie Cincotta Cowan stepping up and a fit Cerra C.Durdin Williams Boyd & Docherty really addresses our run and ball use issues

Look within

 

[SolGoodman]

Anyone have knowledge of this kid?

Has been interviewed by almost every club but his preference is Carlton.

Happy to give the source to the mods.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Accidental genius]

I was never moved by Haynes rumour and based on some posts during their game last week against the dogs it doesnt sound like hes going to be of too much value.

Another nothing type trade

But the Aleer trade sounds very promising

 

[Beer n Skittles]

Hmmmmm

B: Docherty Aleer McGovern
HB: Cowan Weitering Saad
C: Acres Cripps Ollie
HF: Elijah McKay Williams
F: Kemp Charlie Moir
Foll: TDK Cerra Walsh
Int from: Lord Newman Kennedy C.Durdin Silvagni Hewett Garcia Haynes B.Camporeale Binns Motlop Cincotta Boyd O'Keefe Pittonet Wilson Berry

That is a heck of line up with NO real weaknesses

Kemp, McKay share second ruck role
Elijah more midfield
Doc back in defence
Heaps of improvement in nearly every player from 2024
Youth stepping up and making a difference

FIT and in form that side can beat anyone!

Might struggle a bit when the ball hits the deck in the front half.

I know everyone is keen to see Weitering move to CHB but I think if we bring Aleer in we'll still need Weiters at full back directing everyone in front of him.

 

[Ciccio]

My early call. I'm not fussed on Petracca or Houston. Cost and age worry me

If we get roughly

Haynes FA
Aleer for F2
Garcia for Pick 40
First round pick (Berry - sml fwd)
2 more good draft picks
Campo twins for 3rd round pick and rookie
Pick 30 for Owies
Pick 40 for Carroll

I will be very happy

Key for 2025 is internal development and fitness

Soapy Is that Garcia from the doggies you are referring to?

 

[Beer n Skittles]

I was never moved by Haynes rumour and based on some posts during their game last week against the dogs it doesnt sound like hes going to be of too much value.

Another nothing type trade

Not a trade he'll be a free agent. We're already light on for players in that position and will be losing Marchbank at a minimum. When bringing multiple players in to fill one position at least one of them is going to have to be a journeyman type

 

[carlton_99]

Haynes happening
Deep into Leek Aleer

If anything is happening around Petracca no one is talking about it

Focus is mostly on draft and some cheap trades (apparently we have targeted someone) as it has been all year

So you think GWS are willing to trade him?

 

[Soapy V]

So you think GWS are willing to trade him?

I don't know anymore than this. Just message I got

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

Haynes happening
Deep into Leek Aleer

If anything is happening around Petracca no one is talking about it

Focus is mostly on draft and some cheap trades (apparently we have targeted someone) as it has been all year

Nick Haynes? He'll be 33yo early next season and played 8 games this year (presumably from injury?).

 

[carlton_99]

I don't know anymore than this. Just message I got

Thanks for the info mate. Would be a great get

 

[Accidental genius]

Not a trade he'll be a free agent. We're already light on for players in that position and will be losing Marchbank at a minimum. When bringing multiple players in to fill one position at least one of them is going to have to be a journeyman type

it’s a position of need because as you say Marchy hopefully gone

McGovern is injured too often

Kemp is more of a forward and may stay up front in future

So a 2nd KPD through aleer makes sense …

Between McGovern and Haynes hopefully get by for another 2 years.

In the meantime perhaps a draftee to step up into 3rd tall defender in a couple of years.

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Just a theory, but I'm wondering if we can strike a 'deal' with GWS to offer a short term salary for Haynes that would give them a satisfactory compensation pick. In return, we acquire Aleer at a slightly reduced price.

 

[jooce8891]

Anyone have knowledge of this kid?

Has been interviewed by almost every club but his preference is Carlton.

Happy to give the source to the mods.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

someone in the 2024 draft discussion thread said we were keen on him a while ago