List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

[George Kramer]

I know, it happening a bit lately with me too...is it a blue moon or something

A bit is an exaggeration, I have him at one

 

[spenze]

We would definitely have to reinvent and he would be an option among many to help fill the void

I mean it'd be better if we had a substitute ruck and not use him in that role...but I'd almost go him in front of Stawnie, unless Strawnie gets off the durries

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I mean it'd be better if we had a substitute ruck and not use him in that role...but I'd almost go him in front of Stawnie, unless Strawnie gets off the durries

No doubt he could do it , but it’s also best if he settles in defence and becomes a really elite defender so I hope it doesn’t come to that

He did well to fight thru the year , was clearly not at his best post acl but good grounding for next year

 

[fuic08]

they gave up that pick for injured old macadam who was 28 (as is ANB)

ANB is a premiership player and had his best ever year compared to macadam who will probably never play another AFL game

They only gave up that much because they gambled on a future pick and fell down the ladder.

 

[crow2crow]

They only gave up that much because they gambled on a future pick and fell down the ladder.

I know we would all rather give up 42 but its not a disaster.

what is a disaster is why would we be looking at sam draper? ffs. chuck F1 at GC for Moyle and Luko would be way better

 

[fuic08]

I know we would all rather give up 42 but its not a disaster.

what is a disaster is why would we be looking at sam draper? ffs. chuck F1 at GC for Moyle and Luko would be way better

Maybe not a disaster, but it's higher than we should pay for ANB. It's not like we chased him either.

We already missed Moyle, re-signed this year.

Draper would be a disaster though.

 

[conVINCEd]

Cal Twomey says we should be giving 25 for ANB while also claiming 22 (after Geelong’s first gets pushed backed for matched bids) should be enough for Bailey Smith

6

Bailey Smith

Age

23

Ht

185cm

Wt

86kg

Pos.

M/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

18.3

5star

K

8.5

3star

HB

9.8

5star

M

2.3

2star

T

3.8

5star

CL

2.7

4star

D

19.8

5star

K

9.6

4star

HB

10.2

5star

M

1.8

2star

T

3.2

4star

CL

3.2

4star

D

14.8

4star

K

7.6

3star

HB

7.2

5star

M

2.0

3star

T

3.4

5star

CL

1.6

4star

.

Utter garbage.

 

[BRL121]

Cal Twomey says we should be giving 25 for ANB while also claiming 22 (after Geelong’s first gets pushed backed for matched bids) should be enough for Bailey Smith.

Utter garbage.

No he didn't. He claimed that 22 wouldn't be enough for them and he was looking forward to the first round of the send them to the draft saga.

 

[Crow till I die]

Cal Twomey says we should be giving 25 for ANB while also claiming 22 (after Geelong’s first gets pushed backed for matched bids) should be enough for Bailey Smith.

Utter garbage.

Hey, lets tell Cam we will give 25 and a future 3rd for Bailey Smith and just completely forget about ANB

 

[latinoheat]

Ch7 saying Hugh Bond has signed a 1 year deal

 

[Tex Danger]

Trade bell on SEN with Edmund

Harry Perryman - certain to leave according to Edmund. Destination unknown. Port, Hawks, Coll in the mix. 6 year offer on the table from GWS who believe they've been priced out.

Isaac Cumming - Adelaide chasing. GWS max offer is 4 years.

Luko - no trade request or desire to leave. Crows 'really keen', has also got interest from Vic.

Caleb Daniel - now preferring to stay.

So pretty much nothing new.

So if luko has no desire to leave it means for that change it confirms he’s been forced out, likely needed out for salary and so the trade value should be low

 

[PeterSalt]

Ch7 saying Hugh Bond has signed a 1 year deal

Like Borlase the club hasn't posted anything

 

[hippyhippy]

they gave up that pick for injured old macadam who was 28 (as is ANB)

ANB is a premiership player and had his best ever year compared to macadam who will probably never play another AFL game

That's on them... Not us

 

[Tex Danger]

That screams of desperate "whatever it takes" sort of stuff.

That the club has been going on about all year wanting to be aggressive in the trade period, and the only player willing to look our way because of our inept, disfunctional footy department, gets traded for overs so we don't let one slip away.

“we said we’d be aggressive and we showed that by being willing to offer overs for a player whose club had already conceded they needed to let him go.”

 

[ABAB]

they gave up that pick for injured old macadam who was 28 (as is ANB)

ANB is a premiership player and had his best ever year compared to macadam who will probably never play another AFL game

They gamble a F2 thinking it would be around 34-36 and at most pick 30 so didn't value him as pick 25.

 

[Tex Danger]

25 for ANB and people are upset?

This appears win-win for all involved and I’m happy for Ned to get another go

 

[crow2crow]

25 for ANB and people are upset?

This appears win-win for all involved and I’m happy for Ned to get another go

excellent post

 

[spenze]

Maybe not a disaster, but it's higher than we should pay for ANB. It's not like we chased him either.

We already missed Moyle, re-signed this year.

Draper would be a disaster though.

If we had a choice between Draper and Goldstein from the Bombers, I'd go the latter

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

If we had a choice between Draper and Goldstein from the Bombers, I'd go the latter

I would go neither.

 

[1970crow]

I caught Cal Twomey say this morning very matter of factly, 'Adelaide will offer pick 25 for ANB and Melbourne will accept'.

That's so ****ed.

There’s every chance our list management group of dimwits will overpay for a hopeful immediate sugar hit.

 

[Gtowncrow]

There’s every chance our lust statement group of dimwits will overpay for a hopeful immediate sugar hit.

Well this is a stand alone comment which certainly puts some of our club operations into question.
Good job for identifying a new perspective...

 

[Glenny83]

they gave up that pick for injured old macadam who was 28 (as is ANB)

ANB is a premiership player and had his best ever year compared to macadam who will probably never play another AFL game

They gave up a future 2nd when they were expecting to be a top four team. Expected 35-40 range pick after compensation, academy/father son picks etc.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Trade bell on SEN with Edmund

Harry Perryman - certain to leave according to Edmund. Destination unknown. Port, Hawks, Coll in the mix. 6 year offer on the table from GWS who believe they've been priced out.

Isaac Cumming - Adelaide chasing. GWS max offer is 4 years.

Luko - no trade request or desire to leave. Crows 'really keen', has also got interest from Vic.

Caleb Daniel - now preferring to stay.

So pretty much nothing new.

Perryman isn’t worth that amount of money or years

 

[1970crow]

Yep. I just had a look, North could easily bid on welsh at 22 (slips to 25) as a prospective small KPF. So 25 is swallowed anyway. Sounds like an ok trade if we get something back. and get if done day 1 so we can focus on rest of trade period.

Nobody is bidding on Welsh at 22, he'll go in the 3rd round at best. We're talking about a player that has focussed on footy and being drafted for years, comes from a footy family and has flatlined badly.

 

[1970crow]

they gave up that pick for injured old macadam who was 28 (as is ANB)

ANB is a premiership player and had his best ever year compared to macadam who will probably never play another AFL game

When they gave it up it wasn't valued at 25, Melbourne were expected to finish around the top few again.