List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

[Eagleboy2011]

We should be offering F2 for ANB IMO

especially when that will be Pick 36

or 19

 

[Floating Doughnut]

If that is the case with ANB I will be really disappointed.
I figured a late 2nd or 3rd the way Melbourne had gone public claiming
it was a benevolent act.

 

[Mutineer]

If that is the case with ANB I will be really disappointed.
I figured a late 2nd or 3rd the way Melbourne had gone public claiming
it was a benevolent act.

Might get the Dees 38 or 45 back in the deal?

 

[crow2crow]

Might get the Dees 38 or 45 back in the deal?

Yep. I just had a look, North could easily bid on welsh at 22 (slips to 25) as a prospective small KPF. So 25 is swallowed anyway. Sounds like an ok trade if we get something back. and get if done day 1 so we can focus on rest of trade period.

 

[Peter Doherty]

Yep. I just had a look, North could easily bid on welsh at 22 (slips to 25) as a prospective small KPF. So 25 is swallowed anyway. Sounds like an ok trade if we get something back. and get if done day 1 so we can focus on rest of trade period.

IF there are concerns over a bid, I'd prefer to move this pick into next year's draft. There will be team's who would want it.

 

[GreyCrow]

25 is going to be close to 30 by the time it gets there is the point and somebody may well.

Doubt it

We will see hey

 

[GreyCrow]

On ANB - understand his desire to continue to play football and support his family member - but not at the expense of 25

3rd rounder or next year P3

 

[DJ75]

makes no difference seriously that pick will get swallowed in an early welsh bid anyway. might get something back.

Early Welsh bid? Why would anyone pick early on him? There is nothing for clubs to look at say we must have him. He showed a few glimpses and not much else.

 

[crow2crow]

On ANB - understand his desire to continue to play football and support his family member - but not at the expense of 25

3rd rounder or next year P3

youre wrong. pick is fair and it will be swallowed anyway.

 

[Crow till I die]

If Luko says he wants to come to us, then we had better work out a deal using pick 25 in any deal for him so it completely removes that pick and then its a future pick or pick 42 for ANB. It will be hard to swallow us giving up pick 25 in this draft for ANB..really hard

 

[crow2crow]

Early Welsh bid? Why would anyone pick early on him? There is nothing for clubs to look at say we must have him. He showed a few glimpses and not much else.

name another player who has kicked 5 goals in mens sanfl vfl wafl this year (not u18s).

you're kidding yourself

 

[DJ75]

Might get the Dees 38 or 45 back in the deal?

I we got Oliver back I'd consider it. Otherwise no.

 

[DJ75]

name another player who has kicked 5 goals in mens sanfl vfl wafl this year (not u18s).

you're kidding yourself

He kicked 5 goals against the bottom team in a thrashing. He's a 'tweener' height and has shown not to have much of an engine.

In 10 games, he averaged 8.4 disposals and 1 goal a game, and had 5 games where he kicked zero goals.

I'm optimistic on him, but there is little about his form that suggests teams should be rushing to put a bid in on him.

If it was use that pick to select Dodson, or use it on Welsh, I'm taking Dodson.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

On ANB - understand his desire to continue to play football and support his family member - but not at the expense of 25

3rd rounder or next year P3

would give them pick 42 and our F3 instead of 25

 

[crow2crow]

He kicked 5 goals against the bottom team in a thrashing. He's a 'tweener' height and has shown not to have much of an engine.

In 10 games, he averaged 8.4 disposals and 1 goal a game, and had 5 games where he kicked zero goals.

I'm optimistic on him, but there is little about his form that suggests teams should be rushing to put a bid in on him.

If it was use that pick to select Dodson, or use it on Welsh, I'm taking Dodson.

dodson is going around 15 ish (slides to 17) so that pick isnt useful for that anyway

 

[crow2crow]

He kicked 5 goals against the bottom team in a thrashing. He's a 'tweener' height and has shown not to have much of an engine.

In 10 games, he averaged 8.4 disposals and 1 goal a game, and had 5 games where he kicked zero goals.

I'm optimistic on him, but there is little about his form that suggests teams should be rushing to put a bid in on him.

If it was use that pick to select Dodson, or use it on Welsh, I'm taking Dodson.

talls take longer. he showed a lot of tricks and agility up the wings
i can see him debuting quite early which is why we must be looking at lukosius for a wing if he even leaves GC

interestingly jay clark just said he think its adelaide pursuing luko moreso than port

 

[GreyCrow]

youre wrong. pick is fair and it will be swallowed anyway.

View attachment 2107627

You can say Im wrong all you like. It wont change my mind

Again we will see

 

[crow2crow]

You can say Im wrong all you like. It wont change my mind

Again we will see

thats cool. i like data and i like what I see data wise with ANB. if it gets murphy out of the team its a massive win.

 

[GreyCrow]

name another player who has kicked 5 goals in mens sanfl vfl wafl this year (not u18s).

Keep leading with your chin

2 minutes research

Aiden Grace Centrals v Adelaide
Mitch Harvey North - Twice 1 v Centrals 1 v Glenelg

 

[GreyCrow]

thats cool. i like data and i like what I see data wise with ANB. if it gets murphy out of the team its a massive win.

Thats not the argument

Goalposts

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

There is a player there for sure, but he will be a slow burn and will need to drop some weight and get to AFL fitness. But as a mid sized power forward, he could be good. But this is a strong draft it seems and there are plenty of good prospects available

I thought that was the purpose of him dropping out of school and playing for our reserves side this year.

 

[Mutineer]

talls take longer. he showed a lot of tricks and agility up the wings
i can see him debuting quite early which is why we must be looking at lukosius for a wing if he even leaves GC

interestingly jay clark just said he think its adelaide pursuing luko moreso than port

You have got this call all wrong, Welsh is not some gangly undeveloped bodied tall he's a tallish medium forward in the Jake Stringer mold....only development he needs appears to be his endurance. He has only got a State Combine invite and whilst some of that could be recruiters knowing he'll most likely be heading to Adelaide it still means that not enough recruiters want a look at him athletically to garner a National Combine invite.

name another player who has kicked 5 goals in mens sanfl vfl wafl this year (not u18s).

you're kidding yourself

That's easy Jobe Shannahan for the Bombers VFL in round 20.

 

[crow2crow]

Keep leading with your chin

2 minutes research

Aiden Grace Centrals v Adelaide
Mitch Harvey North - Twice 1 v Centrals 1 v Glenelg

oh for goodness sake im talking about 17/18yos above to be drafted. we are talking about the draft arent we?

 

[GreyCrow]

oh for goodness sake im talking about 17/18yos above to be drafted. we are talking about the draft arent we?

Again - goalposts

Thats not what you said

 

[crow2crow]

You have got this call all wrong, Welsh is not some gangly undeveloped bodied tall he's a tallish medium forward in the Jake Stringer mold....only development he needs appears to be his endurance. He has only got a State Combine invite and whilst some of that could be recruiters knowing he'll most likely be heading to Adelaide it still means that not enough recruiters want a look at him athletically to garner a National Combine invite.

That's easy Jobe Shannahan for the Bombers VFL in round 20.

fair enough on jobe. i still think welsh will get bid on early