List Mgmt. 2024 National Draft - November 20-21

[Jen2310]

 

[Mollythedolly]

I find it hard to see a likely scenario where it would help Saints.

I'd like clubs to bid honestly without factoring anything else in, but bloody unlikely.

There's often an advantage in not bidding.
Tiges marketing department want their boy to go pick 1 - and there will be no gain for them in more Brisbane picks getting wiped out - it'll just benefit other clubs.
North are very likely to offer their F2 for Brisbane's 27, so wouldn't be interested in bidding. And even if they don't do that, tactically for them moving 62 up is about the number of picks used - they'd probably be better off with a later pick for Ashcroft and Brisbane matching with more junk picks than them being forced to use decent picks to match. Etc...

It doesn’t hinder them either and costs them nothing.

 

[pablo disco bar]

The afl need to introduce trading of a plater on draft night

What I mean for example
Collingwood.draft jack ginnivan pick 30
Hawthorn wanted him so they offer pick 33..a future 3rd and even a roomi pick

So his drafted and traded on the same night

 

[manicpie]

Make this happen and I’m officially Nostradamus.

You like that one pexy?, I thought I'd throw the cat amongst the pigeons

 

[SchuPie]

My fave night of the year and I can’t bring myself to watch

Hope Blues pick a dud at 3
Hope all 6 Tiger picks are duds
Hope Bombers pick duds

Theme for tonight, duds

 

[swoop42]

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Clubs are idiots.

You're in a competition with 17 others and that doesn't stop after the GF and resume again in the opening round.

Ashcroft is good enough to be bid on at No.1 and that's what Richmond should do.

Make your opposition pay the full price!

P.S- I hope SOS makes a bid on a Camporeale to stop Carlton being able to use 38 as a live selection.

Hell, for the giggles I hope he makes back to back bids on both.

 

[sr36]

My fave night of the year and I can’t bring myself to watch

Hope Blues pick a dud at 3
Hope all 6 Tiger picks are duds
Hope Bombers pick duds

Theme for tonight, duds

You don't kick off a gig with the Rolling Stones, some other chumps warm up the crowd for them. Everyone knows the important stuff is left to the end. Night 2 is where it's at - and the later in night 2 the better - we've got hte show stopping picks.

 

[Jen2310]

I do watch the whole draft even if we aren't involved, as when you watch a lot of U18 footy, you tend to get invested in where these kids go.
I've known Sid since he was 15 via the Arlo connection. Back when he was a chance to come to us... a pipe dream at the time.
And then interesting where the whitlocks go, given we were interested in them mid year. Then obviously those that trained with us over summer, Mraz.

And we'll see if we get involved in a pick swap tonight, as we have something up our sleeve with that whole trade we did with the lions. As atm, it feels it benefited the lions and not sure how it helps us given we wont take 4 players.

 

[sr36]

And we'll see if we get involved in a pick swap tonight, as we have something up our sleeve with that whole trade we did with the lions. As atm, it feels it benefited the lions and not sure how it helps us given we wont take 4 players.

We'll be either trying to trade up a bit - or the value move might be trying to trade a pick into the future for McGuane points.

 

[Jen2310]

Given carlton will be picking a mid anyway, so they have no incentive not to bid. Very strange.
Academy kids or FS rarely go pick 1 (JUH rare case in recent times)

 

[Jen2310]

We'll be either trying to trade up a bit - or the value move might be trying to trade a pick into the future for McGuane points.

Yeah, one of the two. Will be interesting the plan there. Something obviously in he plans behind the scenes.

 

[RobJD]

I do watch the whole draft even if we aren't involved, as when you watch a lot of U18 footy, you tend to get invested in where these kids go.
I've known Sid since he was 15 via the Arlo connection. Back when he was a chance to come to us... a pipe dream at the time.
And then interesting where the whitlocks go, given we were interested in them mid year. Then obviously those that trained with us over summer, Mraz.

And we'll see if we get involved in a pick swap tonight, as we have something up our sleeve with that whole trade we did with the lions. As atm, it feels it benefited the lions and not sure how it helps us given we wont take 4 players.

Agree, either 34 when a bid comes in for Ashcroft, or a 40's pick when the bid comes in for Marshall

 

[Matt_352]

Someone just told me that Melbourne might take AJ in the rookie draft.

Please please please

 

[Matt_352]

Dennis, Nicholls and Kennedy please and thankyou

 

[sr36]

Dennis, Nicholls and Kennedy please and thankyou

Davis Dennis West. Lock it in Ed.

 

[celestial]

The afl need to introduce trading of a plater on draft night

What I mean for example
Collingwood.draft jack ginnivan pick 30
Hawthorn wanted him so they offer pick 33..a future 3rd and even a roomi pick

So his drafted and traded on the same night

Collingwood trade : 1 breakfast platter, 1 fruit platter, 1 desert platter , 1 sandwich platter

For
hawthorns : 2× Mediterranean platter and 1 2025 christmas platter (details to be worked out closer to the day)

 

[Jen2310]

Dennis is the youngest in the draft, he's not 18 until dec 28
A dekka type of player. Because of his birthday, big upside

 

[sr36]

Collingwood trade : 1 breakfast platter, 1 fruit platter, 1 desert platter , 1 sandwich platter

For
hawthorns : 2× Mediterranean platter and 1 2025 christmas platter (details to be worked out closer to the day)

We're fleecing them.

 

[RobJD]

Davis Dennis West. Lock it in Ed.

In that scenario, does Davis slide or do you think we'll trade-up to get him?

 

[Tadpole]

Collingwood trade : 1 breakfast platter, 1 fruit platter, 1 desert platter , 1 sandwich platter

For
hawthorns : 2× Mediterranean platter and 1 2025 christmas platter (details to be worked out closer to the day)

I’d rather Melbourne’s charcuterie board/cheese platter.

 

[sr36]

In that scenario, does Davis slide or do you think we'll trade-up to get him?

I'll have a chat to the list managers and get back to you.

 

[Mollythedolly]

Given carlton will be picking a mid anyway, so they have no incentive not to bid. Very strange.
Academy kids or FS rarely go pick 1 (JUH rare case in recent times)

North overlooked Nick to take JHF and allow him the notoriety (and bonuses) that goes with that pick. Look how that worked out for them. First round, clubs should just take who they consider the best player available at their pick.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

It seems consensus now that Carlton won’t bid on Ashcroft at 3. What a rabble of a club they have become

Any surprise!!!

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Dennis, Nicholls and Kennedy please and thankyou

Or Dennis, Charlie West and Sulzberger

 

[Jen2310]

North overlooked Nick to take JHF and allow him the notoriety (and bonuses) that goes with that pick. Look how that worked out for them. First round, clubs should just take who they consider the best player available at their pick.

I get why it doesn't happen with #1 picks, I understand why Richmond arent bidding, but anything after that, a bid should come. But of course every club may have a different draft board, so some clubs may have one player over another.

 

[SchuPie]

Davis Dennis West. Lock it in Ed.

Davis, Nicholls, Dennis...or Polkinghorn