- Moderator
- #4,082
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
True DD, but looking at how these players have been used this year, how Voss rates them and how we need to play more of the younger players like Lord, Moir, Binns, Wilson etc. I think the replacements are already there.Good way of putting it, but then you need to replace the players you trade with other role players.
If we trade any of Owies, Kennedy, Carrol and Young, we need AFL ready replacements
A hypothetical for the draft gurus...if we secure 12 from GC and have the list spots....come 12 there is a player on the board that the swans really like.....do you do 12 for 18&19 (and whatever other pick swaps) and if so who do you eye off with those picks?
Not the player, but traitsI liked the look of Hannaford, where does he project to go in the draft? And how would draft watchers compare him to Lindsay ?
I don't often get to watch much neutral footy, but they would be some good traits to have in the midfield. So many variables of course, but one ideal I'd like to see us move towards is complementary balance around the ground.Not the player, but traits
Hannaford Butter's like, Lindsay is more measured J Kelly like
I don't often get to watch much neutral footy, but they would be some good traits to have in the midfield. So many variables of course, but one ideal I'd like to see us move towards is complementary balance around the ground.
What's the highest pick you'd be comfortable taking Hannaford ?
I liked the look of Hannaford, where does he project to go in the draft? And how would draft watchers compare him to Lindsay ?
Appreciate the insights. A part of me misses the dark days where the paradigm shifted to bring excited about new players coming through, and being pleased by glimpses of progress rather than wins.Well other than us nuffies you can only base his rating on Twomey and Rookie Me.
Twomey has him at 30.
Rookie Me unranked
Lindsay - I would say more outside run and carry like Arrow said, that Kelly/Gulden vibe top end, bottom end maybe a Massimo styled player.
Hannaford - Top end like Arrow Butters/Daniels - I think he could start as a high half forward and move into the midfield. Maybe even start playing like Harwick as a defender/forward hybrid.
No KPD, no likey3 inside 25
11 Travaglia
12 Hotton
25 Hannaford
Thanks my picks and “I think” I’m sticking with it
Think we will get 1 late or as a sign on in 2025 tbhNo KPD, no likey
lt would alot of sense to take a key position defender when you already the Campo's as well, highly likely we will if we have those picks 3-4 good options.3 inside 25
11 Travaglia
12 Hotton
25 Hannaford
Thanks my picks and “I think” I’m sticking with it
I'd take Hannaford with our first pick. I suspect he will be gone before our pick. Has some rough edges but his GF was elite!
Agree. The Campos help our running stocks and we have Lord, Binns etc in the wings on top of our injured engine room returning. I see Trainor has fallen in some rankings to our range. He’s the best defender in this pool, concussions cost him numerous weeks, but that’s because it’s a 21 day protocol for kids. Must consider. There’s also Tauru(?), Whitlock, Mraz and my other favourite O’Farrell we must look at initially. I’d also scour the VFL and consider some of those also. Most teams need KPD, we must invest ourselves.No KPD, no likey
Berry would be a stretch at 11/12 imo.Can't help but feel that if we have picks 11 and 12 that it will be Berry and Lindsay. We need speed and foot skills and those two deliver in spades.
Stretch to last, or stretch because too early?Berry would be a stretch at 11/12 imo.
Be a waste of pick 11 and 12 if that was to happenCan't help but feel that if we have picks 11 and 12 that it will be Berry and Lindsay. We need speed and foot skills and those two deliver in spades.
Who would you like at those picks Crippa?Be a waste of pick 11 and 12 if that was to happen
Spot on3 inside 25
11 Travaglia
12 Hotton
25 Hannaford
Thanks my picks and “I think” I’m sticking with it
Just me personally - Tauru and TravagliaWho would you like at those picks Crippa?
No current season stats available
My dream haul would be Draper + Berry somehow but if we ended up with 11+12 my order of priority would beJust me personally - Tauru and Travaglia
Lalor would be the dream but that won’t happen. I also like Trainor
How about you Walshy?