![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/adelaide.png)
Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 84,376
- 88,236
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
Doubt we lose both.I think it will come down to are we losing Keane and Berry.
More likely both stay & at least 1 remains.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Doubt we lose both.I think it will come down to are we losing Keane and Berry.
Maybe. Lots of talk in the media all year though.Doubt we lose both.
More likely both stay & at least 1 remains.
Assuming we get Luko it will be amazing and worth chasing the 2018 draft thread about the despondency we had not getting either elite Izak or Luko. Now Luko is never going to be truly elite and dominant IMO but he is a cream on top player and if getting third or fourth best defender could actually do some real damage up forward OR be the much discussed swingman delivering to our “stacked” forward line.
Serious question - is there a better kick than Luko in the whole of the AFL (well besides Dawson and Curtin haha).
Keep Berg & Gollant.If we keep him, both Burgess and Gollant gotta go
80%+ of suggested media trade movements don't eventuateMaybe. Lots of talk in the media all year though.
IMO even keeping two of the three around is too much, especially after drafting Turray and with Welsh on the way (and Tex seemingly playing on)Keep Berg & Gollant.
Burgess can go.
I'd rather Himmelberg as a backup than Burgess.
That’s one of the only qualms I have about Reid, really - the fact he’s allergic to giving one year dealsSure, but a 2 year deal?
What's wrong with 1 year deals for not AFL standard depth?
True, but you can only get rid of so many per offseason without having to go very deep into the draft unless you pick up free agents and trade away future picks.That’s one of the only qualms I have about Reid, really - the fact he’s allergic to giving one year deals
Keep Berg & Gollant.
Burgess can go.
My guess would be he’s still getting 2 year deals elsewhere. Surely stays with us if he’s getting market value.Sure, but a 2 year deal?
What's wrong with 1 year deals for not AFL standard depth?
If we brought in Lukosius I’d agree. I’m less convinced he’s coming to us than others though.IMO even keeping two of the three around is too much, especially after drafting Turray and with Welsh on the way (and Tex seemingly playing on)
I’d like to get at least five open list spots
We need to increase not reduce our depth for next season.depends on who we can bring in
not a fan of keeping players who have been on a list for 4-5 years and still struggle to sting 3-4 consistent AFL games together
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
No current season stats available
And the stupidity of his commentary suggests to me that we are right in the mix.Good news... as that means Port are not getting him.
We need to worry about our first 22 before we worry much about depth.We need to increase not reduce our depth for next season.
Fair call...by popular demand (the original trade proposal sucked it seems), I amend it to try and balance it betterPerfect for Richmond.
Not so great for Suns!
That was reported (Twomey?) a while back but was also reporting he was looking for offers elsewhereObvs GWS got cold feet
No, we need to have 30 decent players like all top sides.We need to worry about our first 22 before we worry much about depth.
We need to increase not reduce our depth for next season.
You realise that’s not a 3 way trade, they’re 2 independent tradesFair call...by popular demand (the original trade proposal sucked it seems), I amend it to try and balance it better
Crows
in Luko
Out 2nd rounder (Melb)
GC
in Rioli, crows 2nd (Melb)
Out Luko & 1st (pick 11)
Richmond
in GC 1st
Out Rioli
GC now trading Luko and downgrading a 1st to a 2nd for Rioli. Richmond get pick 11 for him and we get Luko for a 2nd.
Dwayne is taking notes.In before "Whispering Jack" delivers in his debut.![]()