List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[The Nostradamus]

I think it would be to facilitate the Baker trade that gets that done for #3 and Richmond would take Jagga
I cant see North having an interest in Smith so it would be safe to do FOS/Jagga

#6 would be too valuable to trade out imo as it gets the 3rd of the top 7
But if the deal with the eagles for Baker does get done the importance for #2 will be diluted for Richmond

I feel the opposite if you get 3 it makes going after 2 more worthwhile

Gets the first 3 picks in the draft and you can hedge your bets

Essentially turning Bolton, rioli and baker (probably also one of your picks in the 20s) into 2 and 3

 

[pupstar]

Im pretty certain if we end up doing the Baker +#9 for #3
1.FOS
3.Jagga would be the call

Yeah i would not be surprised if you didn't take him regardless of if that trade gets done. Obviously i am hoping not as i really want FOS.

 

[shinboner magic]

I think it would be to facilitate the Baker trade that gets that done for #3 and Richmond would take Jagga
I cant see North having an interest in Smith so it would be safe to do FOS/Jagga

#6 would be too valuable to trade out imo as it gets the 3rd of the top 7
But if the deal with the eagles for Baker does get done the importance for #2 will be diluted for Richmond

Eagles aren’t trading pick 3 for a midget

 

[DesertRoo]

compare the quality of the forward entries, Dixon didn't stand a chance, i reckon the closest they hit him up was within 2m, meanwhile the Geelong forwards ( tall and small) dined out with the clean low entries out in front of the players. even Cameron got most of his posessions against alir by running off him rather than bodying up to him,

sheezel is a good example, best deliverer into our 50m arc by far,

This isn’t quiet accurate, when the game was on the line in the first half, most of Geelong goals were scored from the chaos ball inside, there was a pretty damning stat, they missed most of their goals from set shots.

That’s what set the game apart, once the ball came to ground, Geelong smalls got to work.

If Dixon got the ball the ground and had quality smalls at his feet like Geelong had, could’ve been a different game.

 

[pupstar]

Fcuk me that's a big call.... Holmes is a gun, Goater would be lucky to clean his boots at this stage of dev... hope you are right but there is a gulf there currently


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

In saying that most of the footy world had no idea how good he really was until this year. His potential was there to be seen though and it really clicked for him this year.

 

[THE_GUN]

I feel the opposite if you get 3 it makes going after 2 more worthwhile

Gets the first 3 picks in the draft and you can hedge your bets

Essentially turning Bolton, rioli and baker (probably also one of your picks in the 20s) into 2 and 3

Not sure we would

I dont think North are in to Jagga so he would be there at #3 and the cost of an extra 1st rounder would be too much to pay to move 4 how close the quality are from 4-6
im thinking id we get #3
1,FOS
2.Langford/Smillie/Trainor
3.Jagga
4.Draper
5.Armstrong/Shannahan/Trainor
6.Lalor

 

[The Nostradamus]

Jack Macrae demoted to sub again

 

[koshari]

Mahony was very unlucky to be delisted and cops a bad rap on here. Not a huge goal scorer but a committed player.

Yeah he worked hard but you can only carry so many journeyman, especially when you have spots wasted on the likes of biggy , sleevo and ccj.

 

[koshari]

This isn’t quiet accurate, when the game was on the line in the first half, most of Geelong goals were scored from the chaos ball inside, there was a pretty damning stat, they missed most of their goals from set shots.

That’s what set the game apart, once the ball came to ground, Geelong smalls got to work.

If Dixon got the ball the ground and had quality smalls at his feet like Geelong had, could’ve been a different game.

Chaos balls are low and unpredictable, they were not dump kicks parked on alirs head cherry ripe for him to kill.

 

[DesertRoo]

Chaos balls are low and unpredictable, they were not dump kicks parked on alirs head cherry ripe for him to kill.

That was another thing Geelong did well, Cameron had Alir following him, so he lead hard up the field opening up space behind them.
Workrate and working for each other without the ball.

 

[Zondor]

Sheezel's on SEN right now talking about how his main takeaway from last night is how important small forwards are.

Can we have him in charge of List Management as well as play? :stern look

 

[LB2Snake]

Well Danger is/ was one of the games best, Bowes was a pick 10, Bruhn pick 12, Holmes pick 20.

What they have is burst speed and endurance.

Bruhn and Bowes have put on a lot of size since arriving at Geelong. Holmes is a ripper, solid unit too with serious wheels and can roost it.

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

Captain, coach and list manager. C'mon Harry lift ya game!

I’m getting Being John Malkovich vibes with this.

 

[krakouers]

Sheezel - Captain, List manager, and soon to bring back captain/coach

On SM-G991B using BigFooty.com mobile app

The kid is what 20 and close to being North Melbourne with all these roles…

As in we have our home base at Arden Street Sheezle House and are the Harry Sheezles?

Our new logo?

 

[justroyal]

Clarkson keeps dropping in his media appearances how important ball use and precision is when ‘cutting-up’ from the backline as being a dangerous part of finals footy. So you’d think we should be expecting this to be something blended into our game.

But I don’t know how we do that with Fisher, Scott and Stephens.

Obviously you can see how he wants to implement it with Sheezel and Kercher, but they’re needed up the ground?

 

[Lomas]

Clarkson keeps dropping in his media appearances how important ball use and precision is when ‘cutting-up’ from the backline as being a dangerous part of finals footy. So you’d think we should be expecting this to be something blended into our game.

But I don’t know how we do that with Fisher, Scott and Stephens.

Obviously you can see how he wants to implement it with Sheezel and Kercher, but they’re needed up the ground?

Stephens is actually a good kick. Sometimes. Actually does have it in him.

 

[Johnny99]

Fcuk me that's a big call.... Holmes is a gun, Goater would be lucky to clean his boots at this stage of dev... hope you are right but there is a gulf there currently


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Goater was well on the way to being a very good player. I don't know what he will be like after the Achilles.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Not sure we would

I dont think North are in to Jagga so he would be there at #3 and the cost of an extra 1st rounder would be too much to pay to move 4 how close the quality are from 4-6
im thinking id we get #3
1,FOS
2.Langford/Smillie/Trainor
3.Jagga
4.Draper
5.Armstrong/Shannahan/Trainor
6.Lalor

I think we’ll draft Draper to be honest which would mean we’d be more likely to deal with the Crows if at all.

 

[shinboner magic]

Stephens is actually a good kick. Sometimes. Actually does have it in him.

Would he be a better option off half back than fisher

 

[zoomba23]

Clarkson keeps dropping in his media appearances how important ball use and precision is when ‘cutting-up’ from the backline as being a dangerous part of finals footy. So you’d think we should be expecting this to be something blended into our game.

But I don’t know how we do that with Fisher, Scott and Stephens.

Obviously you can see how he wants to implement it with Sheezel and Kercher, but they’re needed up the ground?

Fisher has it in him too tbf. The only caveats are that he needs space and the right most sliver of the field is out of bounds

 

[THE_GUN]

Would he be a better option off half back than fisher

I was surprised North went after Broad , I would have thought Jayden Short would have been perfect for North with where the backline sits.

Now Talking about Backline , Surely North would be making a massive offer to Noah Balta next year
free agent and will only be 25 next year when eligible.

The North team will just about be finished with the rebuild and perfect timing to bring in a Noah Balta
If ever there is to be a 7 year $12 mil deal it would be this with where north are positioned

 

[shinboner magic]

I was surprised North went after Broad , I would have thought Jayden Short would have been perfect for North with where the backline sits.

Now Talking about Backline , Surely North would be making a massive offer to Noah Balta next year
free agent and will only be 25 next year when eligible.

The North team will just about be finished with the rebuild and perfect timing to bring in a Noah Balta
If ever there is to be a 7 year $12 mil deal it would be this with where north are positioned

Not paying balta 1.5 mil a year - maybe a million a year

 

[Lomas]

Would he be a better option off half back than fisher

He’s a pure wing player. Elite endurance

 

[THE_GUN]

Not paying balta 1.5 mil a year - maybe a million a year

With Battle getting $900k plus $1 mil doesnt buy you a 25 year old free agent Balta who is a much much superior player and athlete

 

[Roosurgence]

Sheezel's on SEN right now talking about how his main takeaway from last night is how important small forwards are.

Sack Brady and the Rectuitment Team.

Sheezel can be the first player/recruiter in the AFL.