List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[buttox]

Now that would be really crazy and would just about cost your F1
just wait another season and he is a free agent

Problem with that is 17 other clubs will go after him and doubtful he picks us.

 

[New_Roo]

Now that would be really crazy and would just about cost your F1
just wait another season and he is a free agent

Yes maybe a free agent but then he is also open to every other club too.... some of which are also throwing big money around eg saints


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Scottroo]

Sam De Koning

 

[New_Roo]

Problem with that is 17 other clubs will go after him and doubtful he picks us.

Exactly, trading now is for exclusive access.... having said that giving our first wouldn't be the best option. Our defence is serviceable for now


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[New_Roo]

Sam De Koning

Someone mentioned him months ago.... interesting now been dropped or others preferred.... can't see it though


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Harris 10]

Yes maybe a free agent but then he is also open to every other club too.... some of which are also throwing big money around eg saints


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

They want mids

 

[THE_GUN]

Problem with that is 17 other clubs will go after him and doubtful he picks us.

Well thats why you will need to throw a number at him that wipes out other bids
North should have the most cap space and what better way to use it than a player like Balta

 

[DrZaius]

Lucky Houston is a match winner then.

By that logic so are Karmichael Hunt and Sam Lloyd.

 

[DrZaius]

Fix up those couple of small things from the Pies, Demons and West Coast game and we could have had 6 this year.

I don't see 5-6 wins next year as an unachievable "miraculous turnaround" lol. We'll easily get there and more.

We also fell over the line against WC the first time after losing the lead and got extremely lucky against GC with an easy miss.

The point is "what if's" don't matter at the end of the day and our recent history says we struggle to win games of football, so to double our win tally in a single year is a more unlikely scenario than not.

 

[New_Roo]

They want mids

They have just lost battle... and reluctantly extended Howard.... think they need a kpd too


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[hilly]

Sam De Koning

Hope your sources have improved boss.

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

The crazy part is the rumour we are trying this year mate.
I have no idea If it's true.
Doubt it tbh

While Houston would release McKercher to a wing, I would rather do Balter this year.

With 2,21, F1 and the smorgasbord of Richmond picks on the table, I’m sure a fair deal could be struck with picks going either way to balance the ledger.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Fix up those couple of small things from the Pies, Demons and West Coast game and we could have had 6 this year.

I don't see 5-6 wins next year as an unachievable "miraculous turnaround" lol. We'll easily get there and more.

We were saying the exact same thing 12 months ago

 

[Roosurgence]

While Houston would release McKercher to a wing, I would rather do Balter this year.

With 2,21, F1 and the smorgasbord of Richmond picks on the table, I’m sure a fair deal could be struck with picks going either way to balance the ledger.

They probably owe us with all the gifts we have handed them lately.

If we are that keen on getting Balta this year then maybe we see what they shake from the tree with their Baker, Bolton and Rioli deals and give them 2 and get Balta and a later first rounder?

I don’t get the argument that if we don’t get him this year we won’t get him as a free agent. If he wants to go to somewhere else as a free agent, why come to us this year?

I’d probably wait the year and put our best pitch forward under FA, but if we could get a first round pick that gets us someone that we have on our board early, then who knows?

Balta certainly starts to address the flexibility we don’t have with key position players. Like Comben he can go both forward and back.

 

[buttox]

While Houston would release McKercher to a wing, I would rather do Balter this year.

With 2,21, F1 and the smorgasbord of Richmond picks on the table, I’m sure a fair deal could be struck with picks going either way to balance the ledger.

I'd love him.
He would jump us 2 or 3 years forward in kpp development.
The price would be very high though.
I doubt we'd get any change from either 2 or our f1st

 

[THE_GUN]

They probably owe us with all the gifts we have handed them lately.

If we are that keen on getting Balta this year then maybe we see what they shake from the tree with their Baker, Bolton and Rioli deals and give them 2 and get Balta and a later first rounder?

I don’t get the argument that if we don’t get him this year we won’t get him as a free agent. If he wants to go to somewhere else as a free agent, why come to us this year?

I’d probably wait the year and put our best pitch forward under FA, but if we could get a first round pick that gets us someone that we have on our board early, then who knows?

Balta certainly starts to address the flexibility we don’t have with key position players. Like Comben he can go both forward and back.

Not sure why Richmond would do that

Keep Balta another year on a cheap contract and let him go next year to get pick #2 and get Sharp & Ludowyke
I would highly doubt there would be anything going back for #2 as thats almost guaranteed in 2025

 

[King Corey]

Sam De Koning

I know the family are big fans of Xerri.

 

[Makeshift Park]

I know the family are big fans of SDK.

Didn't realise Charles Manson was into footy, you learn something new every day.

 

[King Corey]

Didn't realise Charles Manson was into footy, you learn something new every day.

You're quick. Fixed.

 

[Makeshift Park]

You're quick. Fixed.

Here I was imagining they'd found kinship through a shared appreciation of long flowing hair and rural properties.

 

[Nutjob]

Now that would be really crazy and would just about cost your F1
just wait another season and he is a free agent

I’m not advocating we go after him this year, but we do run the risk of competing with a bunch of other clubs next year. We also get a type we desperately need a year earlier and can help us improve.

Much rather give up a F1 for Balta over Houston.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[FlyHigh18]

Sam De Koning

That headband culture isn't coming within 100 feet of Arden st.

I've put I've with a lot lately, don't send me over the edge!

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

I'd love him.
He would jump us 2 or 3 years forward in kpp development.
The price would be very high though.
I doubt we'd get any change from either 2 or our f1st

I’d do F1> Balta+Richmond F2.

 

[hilly]

That headband culture isn't coming within 100 feet of Arden st.

I've put I've with lately, don't send me over the edge!

I hope he tells the Kanga Lotto crew to gagf.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Sam De Koning

that would be huge

Rather him over Houston

Send them our future first