List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread - No.2

[Premium]

Earlier in the year l speculated about a changing of the guard but still with the belief it wouldn't happen. But Crouch and Ross have seen to it themselves whilst Timmy looks probably gone as well. TC and Batts also.
I think it's a great thing now some responsibility will fall on some younger shoulders. I'm also looking forward to it.

Crouch might not be finished , no announcement on retirement - he well could front up next season who knows.
A year off could of worked wonders.

 

[Richter]

Hotton, Seb, Allison, Van Es, DMac, Langlands, Longer and even Acres (at least those are the ones I remember seeing there). It was actually sort of sad flicking through them to be honest.

There was a second box that had heaps of Crouch, Battle and Doogs as well as just a few of others like Wood, Webster and even one of Mattaes.

I saw a couple of pairs of Jade Gresham socks!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Premium]

I know it's an unpopular opinion but if the club are banking on Max King taking us to the holy grail they are going to be sorely disappointed. I'll lay odds that Max won't play every game at any stage for the rest of his career. He is like the straw man and will continue to break down yearly until he is forced into early retirement. He just hasn't got the body or make up for the rigours of the game.

Sorry to be the grinche but it's just how I see his career playing out.

Signed the guy long term to keep the poachers away - and it has to be remembered all contracts today are a joke.
A fit King will help us achieve our goal - it has to be remembered Joe Daniher went missing for about 3 yrs before he joined the Lions due to some injury.

 

[snails13]

I saw a couple of pairs of Jade Gresham socks!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Were they still clean?

 

[Joffaboy]

Paton was never better than a GOP. Nothing wrong with that, plenty of gops have ten year careers.
Unfortunately he had his career sidetracked.

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[PandaG]

Hope he was, we need a step ladder for markers up.

Has a connection to Damien Carol
Would be nice as a development coach. Might be a mother nice connection to Brayshaw

 

[PandaG]

Signed the guy long term to keep the poachers away - and it has to be remembered all contracts today are a joke.
A fit King will help us achieve our goal - it has to be remembered Joe Daniher went missing for about 3 yrs before he joined the Lions due to some injury.

Jesse hogan similar

 

[phantom13]

I honestly don't see why FA is needed. If a player is out of contact, they'll get to the club they want with minimal barriers.

Hell, even contacted players are getting to their preferred clubs these days.

So why keep FA? Just let clubs negotiate a trade for an OOC player and the controversy is gone. Hawks FR this year (currently 14) probably wouldn't have upset many people.

Between FA and players needing to agree to trades the player empowerment is pretty heavily balanced for them.

You look at us sports players get traded without consent constantly. Now Bailey Smith says he wants geelong and the dogs just have to ****ing cop it.

Probably need to do something with that tbh.

 

[stfan]

Hofmann is the Webster replacement. I know he hasn’t even been drafted yet, but he has all the attributes - speed, intercepting, defensive craft

McLennan is more a Starcevich so he’ll have to rely on body work more than closing speed. Definitely could lock down on medium defenders, but I’m not sure how he fits with the entire back 7 considering our defence is already quite slow especially losing Battle

If McLennan and Hofmann/Hastie can turn into the Starcevich Answerth pairing of the 2024 premiership team, it could work alongside Nas Sinc (Zorko, Wilmot), Doug/Cole Wilkie (Payne, Andrews), Arie/Hammer (Lester)

Yes there are a number of potential Webster replacements....which was all part of the thrust of my post that our backline is not going to fall off a cliff just because Battle has left us.

Back on Webster, you can also add Liam O'Connell to your list of potential Webster replacements as well.

​

 

[HeavenlySources]

I might be in the minority here but if we are after Andrew Brayshaw

8

Andrew Brayshaw

Age

25

Ht

185cm

Wt

88kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.8

4star

K

7.6

3star

HB

9.3

5star

M

2.6

3star

T

4.8

5star

CL

2.1

4star

D

18.4

4star

K

7.6

3star

HB

10.8

5star

M

3.3

3star

T

4.8

5star

CL

3.1

4star

D

12.6

4star

K

6.0

3star

HB

6.6

4star

M

2.6

3star

T

4.0

5star

CL

0.8

3star

, why chase Mccrae? I feel like we are going to over correct and have too many mids.

 

[saintbill]

Would have hoped he would show that before signing a long term contract, it's all well and good to talk like that now he's locked in for 8 more years.

Don't see why the club has done this, not yet.

It's insanely reckless, particularly with the way today's footy is played.

Nobody should be on an 8 year deal, let alone an injury riddled player who doesnt particularly look wrapped to be there like Max. If it goes pear shaped could completely stuff our list management for years.

I want to believe the club is finally in good hands, but I am getting nervous again. Butchered the b & f by not acknowledging Battle, we look like absolute tools to any potential incoming players.

We are still offering outrageous contract extensions. Not to mention how we handled the Tarryn Thomas debacle.

We complain nobody respects us, but my goodness from the outsode looking in, we don't come across as a professional outfit.

8 years on big money for an injury prone forward, who is showing signs his game has a lot of limitations, is the dumbest thing we have done since the Hanners contract.

 

[austinnn]

I red the hole trade board thred 4 Soldo and fairlie certain I lose IQ

Can any1 tell

A few posters spell like this quite regularly.

I did at first assume they were uneducated but now I understand that they'd been reading the trade board.

 

[akaifu]

Yes there are a number of potential Webster replacements....which was all part of the thrust of my post that our backline is not going to fall off a cliff just because Battle has left us.

Back on Webster, you can also add Liam O'Connell to your list of potential Webster replacements as well.

​

I see O'Connell as a winger - more a Wood replacement but wouldn't be surprised either way, he's got a versatile set of attributes

Just want to see him make it at AFL level first of all

 

[NasiahToKing]

Signed the guy long term to keep the poachers away - and it has to be remembered all contracts today are a joke.
A fit King will help us achieve our goal - it has to be remembered Joe Daniher went missing for about 3 yrs before he joined the Lions due to some injury.

Hogan

 

[Nutsngum]

It's insanely reckless, particularly with the way today's footy is played.

Nobody should be on an 8 year deal, let alone an injury riddled player who doesnt particularly look wrapped to be there like Max. If it goes pear shaped could completely stuff our list management for years.

I want to believe the club is finally in good hands, but I am getting nervous again. Butchered the b & f by not acknowledging Battle, we look like absolute tools to any potential incoming players.

We are still offering outrageous contract extensions. Not to mention how we handled the Tarryn Thomas debacle.

We complain nobody respects us, but my goodness from the outsode looking in, we don't come across as a professional outfit.

8 years on big money for an injury prone forward, who is showing signs his game has a lot of limitations, is the dumbest thing we have done since the Hanners contract.

This post is like a condensed day of SEN talkback. Vague predictions, parroting of list managment guesswork, exaggeration of potential proposed contracts that may or may not have been offered.. the list goes on.

Honestly, if all your going to do is base your opinion of the club and its actions on rhetoric from clickbait media why even bother? It sounds absolutely miserable to be that way.

 

[tomjoad]

If King realises his potential we’re contending for premierships. Plural. It’s that simple

"IF"...

 

[Dard Ball Get]

It's insanely reckless, particularly with the way today's footy is played.

Nobody should be on an 8 year deal, let alone an injury riddled player who doesnt particularly look wrapped to be there like Max. If it goes pear shaped could completely stuff our list management for years.

I want to believe the club is finally in good hands, but I am getting nervous again. Butchered the b & f by not acknowledging Battle, we look like absolute tools to any potential incoming players.

We are still offering outrageous contract extensions. Not to mention how we handled the Tarryn Thomas debacle.

We complain nobody respects us, but my goodness from the outsode looking in, we don't come across as a professional outfit.

8 years on big money for an injury prone forward, who is showing signs his game has a lot of limitations, is the dumbest thing we have done since the Hanners contract.

Is that why long term deals are becoming more and more common in the league?
Bill knows better? Somehow I think not.

 

[tomjoad]

It's insanely reckless, particularly with the way today's footy is played.

Nobody should be on an 8 year deal, let alone an injury riddled player who doesnt particularly look wrapped to be there like Max. If it goes pear shaped could completely stuff our list management for years.

I want to believe the club is finally in good hands, but I am getting nervous again. Butchered the b & f by not acknowledging Battle, we look like absolute tools to any potential incoming players.

We are still offering outrageous contract extensions. Not to mention how we handled the Tarryn Thomas debacle.

We complain nobody respects us, but my goodness from the outsode looking in, we don't come across as a professional outfit.

8 years on big money for an injury prone forward, who is showing signs his game has a lot of limitations, is the dumbest thing we have done since the Hanners contract.

Don't agree with everything in your post, but i'm with you 100% on Max King and this new contract. It's a gamble to put all your eggs in one basket, but when the eggs are broken... it's just going to end in a big stinking, sticky, mess.

 

[_Maximus_12]

"IF"...

Not only do you know how to read, you also know how to use capitals, bold font and inverted commas. Congrats.

 

[stfan]

Then we bid on him at 8.

He is not worth Pick 8 though. So we waste a pick that would gain us the mid we need, for a player we do not need.


Guessing how another club rates a player is how StKilda missed getting Judd. We went Ball first in the belief that WCE would not pick Judd (due to should concerns) allowing us to get both Judd and Ball. So instead we got Ball and Xavier. That one little bit of predictive thinking trying to be too cleaver probably cost us a flag or three.

 

[stfan]

I see O'Connell as a winger - more a Wood replacement but wouldn't be surprised either way, he's got a versatile set of attributes

Just want to see him make it at AFL level first of all

.Hofmann having made it at AFL already then?

 

[the big lebowski]

If Norf saw McKercher as a winger then they wouldn't have taken him with pick 2

Sheezel is great off half-back, but he's elite in the midfield. Less touches, but 2x the damage

Wardlaw, Powell, Sheezel, McKercher will all be prominent mids for them going forward, with Duursma as a hybrid. Phillips also seems to be slowly coming good but still have doubts over him. They also have Simpkin who is still only 26 and are getting Parker in for I think it was 3 seasons? (I might be wrong)

I agree that they might need a bit more midfield depth, but they don't need top-end midfield talent anymore. They're more likely to take mids in the later rounds to address specific needs and midfield roles

They clearly want to take one of the top kpps in the pool - Armstrong and Tauru in particular. They can do so if they split pick 2 - might even have a chance at taking both if things go their way

Pretty much this.

North would love to trade down unless we thought FOS was a chance at generational and available through injury like wardlaw.

I was going to ask this board, what would you be willing to pay for north’s F1?

Would you do it for pick 9 and your second?

Also, im not saying this to start a fight or whatever, but the number of posts on LDU like it’s just a matter of when is astounding. Aside from the small matter of him categorically saying he’s staying at north, he will be the no 1 target of every Melbourne club. Ain’t happening sainters.

 

[Plugger35]

I'm watching the Footy Furnace Trade Edition on Ch9.

Damien Barrett is on there and straight away he rips into us "St Kilda getting pick 8 for Josh Battle

26

Josh Battle

Age

26

Ht

193cm

Wt

93kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

12.9

3star

K

9.0

3star

HB

3.9

3star

M

5.0

5star

T

2.4

4star

MG

196.8

3star

D

11.0

3star

K

7.3

3star

HB

3.8

3star

M

4.0

4star

T

1.8

3star

MG

142.8

3star

D

10.8

3star

K

6.2

3star

HB

4.6

4star

M

3.4

4star

T

2.0

4star

MG

175.6

3star

is a joke".

The only joke is you Damo you f***wit, you should be thrown into the footy furnace and never seen again.

 

[Saints4ever]

I'm watching the Footy Furnace Trade Edition on Ch9.

Damien Barrett is on there and straight away he rips into us "St Kilda getting pick 8 for Josh Battle is a joke".

The only joke is you Damo you f***wit, you should be thrown into the footy furnace and never seen again.

I watched this and found myself getting so so angry.

Jimmy tried to explain the system to Barrett who clearly would understand the system but all he wanted to do was be a complete f@ckwit about it.

 

[Plugger35]

I watched this and found myself getting so so angry.

Jimmy tried to explain the system to Barrett who clearly would understand the system but all he wanted to do was be a complete f@ckwit about it.

Jimmy Bartel is the only sensible bloke on that show, hard not to like him even though he tagged Lenny Hayes out of the 2009 GF.