List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread - No.2

[stavro#4]

What’s the expectation on Graham’s compensation? 2R after theirs or end of 2R? Handy for them if they get 22-ish.

Rumours of 22ish

 

[Yawkey way]

so many options here.

Could we trade a F1 for the Barrass pick which will go to the tigers now?

Could we trade up to 3?

I hope we don’t trade up.

 

[stfan]

Ro needs to work on getting a handball off to a good user and i can't see why its not something he can work on and improve , but .....
If not able to what is worse ?

a) Kaos ball forward?

The Coach using the Cone of Silence for one on ones with our players.

 

[HeavenlySources]

This might as well be the tassie draft with Richmond expected to have, 1,6,9,13,17

 

[Remboy]

This might as well be the tassie draft with Richmond expected to have, 1,6,9,13,17

Could we get 13 & 17 for 8?

 

[beside the seaside]

Could we get 13 & 17 for 8?

The way to use the pick trading is wait until the night and see if someone is desperate for a player and will pay overs. Like what we did with GWS last year.

 

[sammm]

F*ck oath how good is it the premiers get the No.1 draft pick after their free no.2 pick wins the Norm Smith. Then you have some flog journos think it's a travesty if we get band 1 compo.

What a farking great sport the AFL is.

cOmpEtiTiVe InTegRitY

its all just luck. if we had won the premiership and Reiwoldt kids were number 1 father and sons, then we would be lucky!

 

[sammm]

Tell you what, if we refused to pay a F2 for Xerri a couple of seasons ago, but then do it for Soldo, then we're dumb as dogs**t.

diffferent coach, different list manager

 

[RWB4life]

F1 for tigers 13?

 

[bird_man]

Herald Sun (Jon Ralph and Jay Clark) running with the below on Battles contract. Hard to see how it’s not band 1 if this is true.

The AFL’s free agency period kicks off on Friday, with compensation for St Kilda over Josh Battle’s departure the most intriguing question mark given a six-year Hawks offer of just under $900,000 a season.

If that is the actual contract off, then band one would be likely.

It doesn't really match up with previous reports he was leaving for less money, hopefully these two have good mail.

 

[St Neil]

This might as well be the tassie draft with Richmond expected to have, 1,6,9,13,17

Add 21, 22 (Graham compensation) and 29 to the list.

Surely we can get one of those picks.

 

[stavro#4]

If that is the actual contract off, then band one would be likely.

It doesn't really match up with previous reports he was leaving for less money, hopefully these two have good mail.

Our final offer was a reported 950k.

So it still matches up.

 

[HeavenlySources]

We should get a second compensation pick for having to listen to these journos speculate and wind us up every Wednesday

 

[SaintsSeptember]

so many options here.

Could we trade a F1 for the Barrass pick which will go to the tigers now?

Could we trade up to 3?

Why would they trade those picks for our future first?
Why would Richmond toss us pick 3 in this draft, for an unknown pick in next years draft?

 

[saintbill]

Could we get 13 & 17 for 8?

Would be wrapped with an outcome like that.

Would allow 2 mids + one of the best key position players in the draft.

As much as we go on about the midfield, we actually have holes everywhere. Key position backs are painfully thin, need another promising ruckman and key forward.

 

[tony74]

Our final offer was a reported 950k.

So it still matches up.

Hawthorns offer is front loaded. Band 1 compensation is based on the first 5 years

 

[stavro#4]

Why would they trade those picks for our future first?
Why would Richmond toss us pick 3 in this draft, for an unknown pick in next years draft?

The eagles have pick 3 and by losing the Barrass pick they don’t have any other currency for a club in a rebuild.

Richmond has said they are open to moving some picks from this draft to the next.

Suns giants and lions have a plethora for academy picks next year they will need points for

 

[stavro#4]

Hawthorns offer is front loaded. Band 1 compensation is based on the first 5 years

Even so.

Lets call there offer 875k.

You would expect a 2% pay increase year on year.

Would give you an average salary of 920k over 5 years.

Which is apparently band 1. Which the club have been confident of getting.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

The Coach using the Cone of Silence for one on ones with our players.

I get that the coach has tried to get Ro to stop doing it, but that doesn't mean he's told him to stop clearing it. More likely he's trying to get him to improve his disposal.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Even so.

Lets call there offer 875k.

You would expect a 2% pay increase year on year.

Would give you an average salary of 920k over 5 years.

Which is apparently band 1. Which the club have been confident of getting.

AFL players don't operate like that.
5 year contract might be for 5 million.
You might end up with 2 million, 1 million, 1 million, 500 000, 500 000.
Its NOT a pay cut, you actually end up better off in theory.

 

[bird_man]

Our final offer was a reported 950k.

So it still matches up.

Crazy money for a fairly decent footballer.

I think it's a big win for the club if we get band one. Because of the draft pick obviously, but also because we aren't paying Josh Battle 950k a season.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

The eagles have pick 3 and by losing the Barrass pick they don’t have any other currency for a club in a rebuild.

Richmond has said they are open to moving some picks from this draft to the next.

Suns giants and lions have a plethora for academy picks next year they will need points for

I'm sure Richmond are open to it.....for the right deal.
I'd suggest we don't want to do a deal that's so right for them.

 

[OxSaint]

AFL players don't operate like that.
5 year contract might be for 5 million.
You might end up with 2 million, 1 million, 1 million, 500 000, 500 000.
Its NOT a pay cut, you actually end up better off in theory.

Listening to the right people means he could make good money on the extra salary via investments and be way better off in 6 years than an even spread or back loaded deal.

Money makes money in the right hands.

 

[Fehring]

its all just luck. if we had won the premiership and Reiwoldt kids were number 1 father and sons, then we would be lucky!

We will absolutely succeed at convincing the AFL to abolish Father Son just before the Riewoldt boys have the three greatest seasons in u18s history.

 

[Remboy]

Crazy money for a fairly decent footballer.

I think it's a big win for the club if we get band one. Because of the draft pick obviously, but also because we aren't paying Josh Battle 950k a season.

I agree 100%. As much as I liked Battle as a player if we gave him 950k it sets a pretty high standard. What are are the other player’s managers going to want?
Wilkie, Marshall, Steele, Sinclair would all want at least that. And when NAZ and Phillipou come out of contract they’ll use that number as a starting point.