2nds AFC 2022 SANFL Thread

[jackster83]

We could do worse than give him a couple of sighter games.

He'll probably struggle to get near it, but he'll learn a lot. Dropping one of Rowe/Murphy for a few games is not going to affect whether we win or lose anyway.

 

[Bearded Clam]

How many has Stengle kicked by himself?

please dont remind us all.. its painful!

we chucked a promising young kid in the bin over a few nose beers.. i mean, who gives a flying **** about a few nose beers..

oh, thats right… the goody goody, apricot slice munching, white shoe brigade that this dopey club has bent over for, to endlessly please, since its inception.

sure.. the drink driving charge wasnt acceptable.. drink driving never is.. but he aint the first player to have one of those and he won’t be the last..

 

[hey shorty]

please dont remind us all.. its painful!

we chucked a promising young kid in the bin over a few nose beers.. i mean, who gives a flying duck about a few nose beers..

oh, thats right… the goody goody, apricot slice munching, white shoe brigade that this dopey club has bent over for, to endlessly please, since its inception.

sure.. the drink driving charge wasnt acceptable.. drink driving never is.. but he aint the first player to have one of those and he won’t be the last..

Ahhh dear.

You do realise we offered him a chance to stay.... And he said no.

 

[hey shorty]

We could do worse than give him a couple of sighter games.

He'll probably struggle to get near it, but he'll learn a lot. Dropping one of Rowe/Murphy for a few games is not going to affect whether we win or lose anyway.

This is the crux of it really.

The poor lad will go from playing in a very competitive SANFL side to a not very good AFL side in a role that is difficult to play at the best of times.

 

[George Kramer]

please dont remind us all.. its painful!

we chucked a promising young kid in the bin over a few nose beers.. i mean, who gives a flying duck about a few nose beers..

oh, thats right… the goody goody, apricot slice munching, white shoe brigade that this dopey club has bent over for, to endlessly please, since its inception.

sure.. the drink driving charge wasnt acceptable.. drink driving never is.. but he aint the first player to have one of those and he won’t be the last..

I’ll put my hand up and thought the club had no choice, 3 incidences in a year is pretty bad. But it’s bloody hard seeing him succeed not for us whilst our smalls suck. Having said that, with our stupid gameplan he’d be spending a heap of time in our defensive half to cover for our crap midfield.

 

[hey shorty]

I’ll put my hand up and thought the club had no choice, 3 incidences in a year is pretty bad. But it’s bloody hard seeing him succeed not for us whilst our smalls suck. Having said that, with our stupid gameplan he’d be spending a heap of time in our defensive half to cover for our crap midfield.

Correct

Good on him for making the most of his ast chance but I'd say he'd struggle to be doing better than most of our smalls.

 

[Bearded Clam]

Mate it's time to grow up and move out of mum's house.

The way you're carrying on about Newchurch you'd swear he was peak Eddie Betts, you need some serious help

”grow up and move out of mum’s house”??..

is that seriously the best insult you could come up with?.. Faaark me.

you made a claim the lad kicks “cheap goals” (and god only ****n knows what those actually are).. you were then presented with evidence from just this weekend showing him kicking two great goals.. one that actually was eddie betts like if you really want to bring eddies name into this mind you..

and you responded with “oh, thats just a highlights reel”.. whatever the **** that means…

so come on smartarse.. you still haven’t given us all you definition of a “cheap goal” and some examples of Newchurch kicking them..

you’re all piss and wind mate.

 

[Bearded Clam]

Ahhh dear.

You do realise we offered him a chance to stay.... And he said no.

another load of deceptive bullshit from you..

we offered to make him sit out the entire season.. and told him we’d maybe give him another chance after that.. in other words we gave him little choice but to go elsewhere.

of course he was gonna say no to it.. its exactly what we wanted him to say. you seriously cannot be that ****n naïve..

 

[George Kramer]

Correct

Good on him for making the most of his ast chance but I'd say he'd struggle to be doing better than most of our smalls.

Oh he’d be doing better, maybe not as well as at Geelong but he’d be better than our lot. Unlike our smalls besides Rowe hes a natural forward and has good goal sense. Rowe should be better but he’s just not that good a player. As for McHenry and Murphy, my elderly dad would have more goal sense than those two.

 

[hey shorty]

”grow up and move out of mum’s house”??..

is that seriously the best insult you could come up with?.. Faaark me.

you made a claim the lad kicks “cheap goals” (and god only duckn knows what those actually are).. you were then presented with evidence from just this weekend showing him kicking two great goals.. one that actually was eddie betts like if you really want to bring eddies name into this mind you..

and you responded with “oh, thats just a highlights reel”.. whatever the duck that means…

so come on smartarse.. you still haven’t given us all you definition of a “cheap goal” and some examples of Newchurch kicking them..

you’re all piss and wind mate.

I'd say the 2 against Norwood were pretty cheap. On the weekend had 4 kicks, he averages 7.

With his lack of workrate that would half at best at AFL level.

You're all brawn and no brains, you jump off cliffs quicker than a suicidal lemming.

But go on, keep frothing

 

[hey shorty]

Oh he’d be doing better, maybe not as well as at Geelong but he’d be better than our lot. Unlike our smalls besides Rowe hes a natural forward and has good goal sense. Rowe should be better but he’s just not that good a player. As for McHenry and Murphy, my elderly dad would have more goal sense than those two.

Rowe's a better player than Stengle.

 

[hey shorty]

another load of deceptive bullshit from you..

we offered to make him sit out the entire season.. and told him we’d maybe give him another chance after that.. in other words we gave him little choice but to go elsewhere.

of course he was gonna say no to it.. its exactly what we wanted him to say. you seriously cannot be that duckn naïve..

Wrong again

You'll get one right one day. Or not.

 

[George Kramer]

Rowe's a better player than Stengle.

No friggin way

 

[hey shorty]

No friggin way

He absolutely is.

Has been at every level they've ever played.

I'd love to see Rowey in Geelong's side.

 

[George Kramer]

He absolutely is.

Has been at every level they've ever played.

I'd love to see Rowey in Geelong's side.

Nah. Doesn’t have the same tricks.

 

[Magma]

he's still a 19 year old kid. charlie cameron

23

Charlie Cameron

Age

30

Ht

180cm

Wt

76kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

12.1

3star

K

8.4

3star

HB

3.7

3star

M

3.0

3star

T

3.2

5star

G

1.5

5star

D

9.6

2star

K

7.9

3star

HB

1.7

1star

M

3.6

4star

T

1.7

3star

G

1.9

5star

D

9.6

3star

K

5.4

2star

HB

4.2

4star

M

1.4

2star

T

3.4

5star

G

1.2

4star

kicked 16 goals in 10 sanfl games. imagine if we never gave him a shot.

 

[George Kramer]

So Worrell gets another sanfl pump up which means Jack shit. Poor bloke needs a new club

 

[Bearded Clam]

I'd say the 2 against Norwood were pretty cheap. On the weekend had 4 kicks, he averages 7.

With his lack of workrate that would half at best at AFL level.

You're all brawn and no brains, you jump off cliffs quicker than a suicidal lemming.

But go on, keep frothing

Come on..

Definition of “cheap goal”

And all these examples of newchurch kicking them..

Chop chop smartarse..

 

[Bearded Clam]

Wrong again

You'll get one right one day. Or not.

So you are naive..

Nice of you to confirm it all for us..

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Rowe's a better player than Stengle.

Yep, going to be extremely difficult for us to hang onto Rowe

 

[Mutineer]

Yep, going to be extremely difficult for us to hang onto Rowe

Were club's queueing up to grab Stengle or did I miss that?

 

[DaKids]

Saw a decent amount of Newchurch junior footy. I thought then he suffered a bit for not being made to run through midfield or even spend time in defence. Didn’t develop a wider range of craft than just his forward stuff.

A lot of good small forwards I see develop were originally midfielders who didn’t quite have enough to progress in such an important role and they pick up secondary roles like small forward or even small/mid sized defender. Good midfield/defence craft allows the small forward to be more dangerous around stoppages and a better defender once the ball needs to be locked in.

I might have said this here before and sorry if so. But I think his narrow development will hold him back in the end. Hope I’m wrong of course.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Were club's queueing up to grab Stengle or did I miss that?

Just pointing out that it will be very difficult for us to hang onto Rowe given that he's way better than the current AA or near AA forward pocket

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Saw a decent amount of Newchurch junior footy. I thought then he suffered a bit for not being made to run through midfield or even spend time in defence. Didn’t develop a wider range of craft than just his forward stuff.

A lot of good small forwards I see develop were originally midfielders who didn’t quite have enough to progress in such an important role and they pick up secondary roles like small forward or even small/mid sized defender. Good midfield/defence craft allows the small forward to be more dangerous around stoppages and a better defender once the ball needs to be locked in.

I might have said this here before and sorry if so. But I think his narrow development will hold him back in the end. Hope I’m wrong of course.

It's a great observation and probably deserves it's own thread

Should young footballers as a general rule be rotated through some variety of positions during their formative years?

Being played to their strengths vs exploring their weaknesses

 

[skam85]

The way you're carrying on about Newchurch you'd swear he was peak Eddie Betts, you need some serious help.

Which we will never actually know until we play him at AFL level.